• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What evidence does Putnam offer for a decline in 'community' in America

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

What evidence does Putnam offer for a decline in 'community' in America? In his book, 'Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community', Robert Putnam discusses ways in which Americans have disengaged from political involvement and civil organisations. Much of his reasoned writing is corroborated by a collation of graphs and figures to explain the quality of American community. In this essay I shall evaluate the proof offered by Putnam to support his claim that community is in a decline in the U.S. To do this I must first provide a working definition of 'community,' a term with wide implications and varied definitions depending on the context of its usage. Putnam uses it as a synonym for social capital, a qualitative investment to create higher social cohesion through a civic virtue, rather than to describe a specific structure within society. Social capital 'refers to the collective value of all 'social networks' and the inclinations that arise from these networks to do things for each other' according to Putnam (Putnam, 1995. p.14). I will break down the idea of social capital into geographical locale and suburbanisation, association membership, acts of charity and religious affiliation to assess more easily Putnam's evidence and suggest that community is not necessarily in decline, rather is adapting to a more modern pace of living. ...read more.

Middle

The effects of this deteriorating involvement has been described as 'the dissolution of shared identities, which is tantamount to the dissolution of society as a meaningful social society' (Castells, 1997. p.355).The impersonal, contractual and heterogeneous nature of such organizations means that there is no widely agreed source of moral values and no traditional binding values within civic groups. It has been noted that at 1965, the point at which Putnam notes the beginning of the descent of society, crime rates grew conversely. Readings of these figures suggest that the wane in associational membership weakens the web of social ties and informal social control structures within a community and leaves room for criminals to operate. However, one might suggest that recession to the home could be a result of increased crime rates rather than a cause of it. Instead, it could be the case that increased crime rates have been brought about by the relaxation of laws such as those concerning firearms licensing. Sampson contends that we do not need associational affiliation so much to satisfy our personal needs, which are best met elsewhere, nor to meet our sustenance needs any more (Sampson, 1999. p.241-292). Instead, our personal needs for inter-personal contact are fulfilled in internet chat rooms and interactive television channels. ...read more.

Conclusion

Putnam argues that religion in necessary for social cohesion but does not assess the extent to which religious conflicts can damage society and exclude members based on religious differences, nor does he recognize the developing media in which religion can now be exercised. In this essay, I have taken a narrower view of social capital and community than is the norm among sociologists, touching on suburbanization, association membership and religion, themes offered by Putnam in 'Bowling Alone'. I have discussed factors that oppose Putnam's claims that 'community' in America is in decline. Instead, I have suggested a change in the ways 'community' is created and shared in this more modern world including developments in technology and transport. I have also assumed 'community' to be a positive and desirable entity throughout, though of course it's effects may have negative implications for a society, for example religious fundamentalism and the associated terrorism of late and the social exclusion of one community based on race. I conclude by recognizing that Putnam's work raises much debate about the nature of social ties within society but believe that modernization needs to be taken into account to fully assess the current 'community' in America and to direct research to areas where 'community' is increasing in the current climate. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. What Civil Society Can Do to Develop Democracy

    They need to connect with the people they voted to represent them. They need to feel confident enough to voice their support in elections and to take a vocal or written stand on issues they are concerned about. A public information program may provide many different products and services.

  2. The ancient civilizations of Central and South America

    � Over the years, as Tenochititlan and the other Aztec cities continued to grow, these calpulli became divisions in the cities. Each calpulli had a different political agenda, and it was often the case that the different calpullis in the city did not get along with each other.

  1. How Is The Harshness Of Community Life In Starkfield Conveyed By Edith Wharton?

    We learn that Ethan's house is quite poor and of a low class. "...The thin wooden walls, under their worn coat of paint, seemed to shiver." The use of 'thin' and 'wooden' shows that the house was inexpensive and that wood was the most Ethan could afford for his house- therefore, we can classify him as 'poor'.

  2. Media, leisure & fashion - Britain in the 1930's.

    Younger children enjoyed comics such as Chick's Own, Playbox, Rainbow and Puck. Older children enjoyed Gem and Magnet, by Charles Hamilton. The make-believe worlds portrayed in detective weekly, starring Sexton Blake, Champion, Thriller and Triumph appealed to children.

  1. Working More Creatively With Groups.

    Because we had only began the active listening skills the previous week, the first class since it I found myself trying to listen as actively as I possibly could. And I was pleased with myself in the groupwork class because for the majority of the class we had to listen

  2. What were the reasons for the decline of the power of the Samurai in ...

    The 'Kozuka' or knife (pictured below) iv used for Seppuku always measured about 11.5 inches across and the cut was always from left to right across the stomach and this cut was known as 'Jumonji.' The revival of dignity was increased depending on the time of death.

  1. How far is the gangster genre a creation of the necessity to promote civic ...

    The answer to this question is found amongst Marxist Sociological thinking on the role of the media in society. Marxist theory makes the assumption (an assumption which is upheld by this essay) that the mass media is a tool used by the government and other official offices such as the BBFC to indoctrinate the populace into acceptable ideologies.

  2. American film comedy and issues of social class in America

    At dinner he fails horribly when trying to eat watermelon like a gentleman. The watermelon gets on his ears so he ties a napkin around his head, which is a telltale sign of his lack of breeding. In his film The Count once again Chaplin is portraying a lower-class citizen in the role of a tailor's assistant.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work