• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why, according to Lee Kuan Yew, are Western democratic systems unsuited to East Asia?

Extracts from this document...


Why, according to Lee Kuan Yew, are Western democratic systems unsuited to East Asia? Lee Kuan Yew, prime minister of Singapore between 1959 and 1990, and now Senior Minister of his country, commands much respect and influence in both the East and the West. This respect and influence reaches to the highest echelons of world leaders, to the vast multitude of academics, commentators and development strategists, and to the millions of people who live in East Asia. Regardless of whether or not this esteem is justified and deserved, ti is real, and therefore must be analysed, interpreted, criticised or praised while not forgetting the importance and effect his beliefs and proclamations have had, and will have. Any discussion of world politics, especially in East Asia, cannot ignore the hows, whys and wherefores of the current situation and the influence that current ideas and thought may have on the future. Lee's views have undoubtedly shaped his own country, certainly have influenced other governments in the region, and will definitely bear their markon the short- to mid-term future of East Asian politics. This explains the reasons why this essay solely deals with him. The essay is divided into three main sections. Firstly, I will discuss Lee's ideas and policies, and why he believes in an 'Asian values' view of the politics of the region. Secondly, I will explore some of the responses that have been made in opposition to his views, and thirdly, I will present some observations and conclusions of my own. ...read more.


These three main features of Lee's take on East Asia's political and social climate - culture, the place in society of the individual, and a well-ordered society - are admittedly affected and influenced by the West over time, and are not seen as developing without the impact of colonial rule and imperialism. ...our Confucianism has been attenuated by 120 years of British rule and education in British and other English-speaking universities (IHT, 2001). But, despite this impact Lee steadfastly denies any further infusion of Western democracy into East Asia, especially Singapore. ...this doesn't mean we are going to be like a Western society. The values are different (de Borch, 2001). Lee is not the torch-holder for everyone though. Whilst he receives praise from his counterparts around the world, there are many in the academic and development strategist world that strongly disagree with him. Of course, it is not just a simple case of disagreeing over a matter of opinion, there are many valid and strong arguments against Lee's ideas. From this myriad of arguments, I have identified three main strands of contestation - historical arguments against Lee's 'Asian values', the theoretical arguments concerning discussions of what democracy should be and how it should be followed in East Asia, and the problems and criticisms of the actually existing governing style of Lee. First then, arguments against Lee taken from history. ...read more.


Lee makes much of the need for a 'well-ordered' society. The heavy-handed way this society is brought about blatantly contradicts Lee's notions of freedom. He talks of East Asians being able to have "maximum enjoyment of his freedoms" but Lee's notion of what is behaving and what is misbehaving sets a Singaporean's realm of freedom for him. This is certainly not the freedom that John Stuart Mill wrote about. It could be argued that it is better to have a society that is not so 'well-ordered' but democratic, than it is to live in a society such as one that Lee envisages; faith must be placed with society to check its members' activities rather than have all aspects of life limited by an all-seeing government. Lee's ways may also only be suited to a small state such as Singapore. Even he admits that, within that small population, total control is practically impossible. This for me leads to the heart of the importance placed by Lee on 'Asian values' and why Western ideas of democracy are unsuited to East Asia. It is very hard to escape the conclusion that the justification of 'Asian values' is solely a political smokescreen to maintain power. It is even harder to escape this conclusion when the man himself proclaims: So when Americans tell me: you ought to govern in this way, I say thank you very much, I have listened to you very carefully, if I don't think we are ready for that, I have to do it my way (IHT, 2001, my emphasis). ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. What Civil Society Can Do to Develop Democracy

    Additionally, he states that "civil society performs many other crucial functions for democratic development and consolidation." These functions include: limiting the power of the state more generally, including challenging the abuses of authority; monitoring human rights and strengthening the rule of law; monitoring elections and enhancing the overall quality and

  2. Max Weber: Basic Terms (The Fundamental Concepts of Sociology)

    Each of theses fields may be rationalized in terms of very different ultimate values and ends, and what is rational from one point of view may well be irrational from another. The development of economic rationalism is partly dependent on rational technique and law, but it also requires people to

  1. Determining the Elite within Politics and the Judiciary.

    people they are and the position they hold in our society; [and because] this position is part of established authority and so is necessarily conservative not liberal." (Griffith 1991 p36) This orientation towards consensus and the status quo is in keeping with the traditional interests of the Establishment, with great

  2. Gender Disparity and the ways in which it underpins major social and economic inequalities ...

    accounting for the employment of 96 percent of economically-active women in India, 75 percent in Nepal and Bangladesh and nearly 65 percent in Pakistan. "2 Methods to incorporate the contribution of the women to the economy should be implemented. This would be the only possible way of assessing their productivity accurately.

  1. Environmental Lessons From History.

    Kilda on the mainland. 'To me it was peace living on St. Kilda and to me it was happiness, dear happiness. It was a far better place.' The life on St. Kilda was, without doubt, a hard one. Was its demise as according to Hughes (2000)

  2. Masculinity and Asian gangs

    scales in psychology, ethnographic discussions of masculinity which describe the pattern of men's lives in any given culture (Connell 2001). The problems with the positivist approach to defining what masculinity is could be seen as a major problem as Connell suggests that, masculinity is a cultural terminology and application of

  1. Prostitution in South East Asia and its effect on Female Identity.

    When you see people getting these things the whole business appears quite attractive....and it wasn't difficult to follow the same path' (Skrobanek;1997;p1) In my opinion, this statement encompasses all that is inevitable in the sex trade in the Eastern part of the world.

  2. Have Social Democratic governments had to limit their ambitions to being mere managers of ...

    This change in the view of how to gain power obviously meant new and different paths would have to be tread on the way to achieving socialism. Now, rather than appealing to the proletariat to follow insurrectionary tactics, they would now concentrate on ensuring that the workers went and voted.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work