• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Why did Plato think women could be legitimate political guardians?

Extracts from this document...


Why did Plato think women would make legitimate political guardians? By Sarah Kennedy Word count: 2823 To Plato the role of the state, or republic, was to create a philosophical utopia within a community, this republic was to achieve this through many different factors. Plato himself despised democracy, "Dictatorship naturally arises out of democracy, and the most aggravated form of tyranny and slavery out of the most extreme liberty." [1] He instead wanted to have a hierarchical government at the head of which would be a 'philosopher king' and under him the government would consist of well trained philosophers who would guide, protect and rule the state and it's people. Everyone in Plato's utopian state was of an equal status, whether they were rich, poor, man, woman or child, Plato argues that for his utopia to work the people of the state have to act as one community each with their own personal job suited to them, if someone doesn't perform their job then the state would crumble but if everyone performed their jobs and to their best efforts then what could be achieved would be a harmonious state where everyone could co-exist happily. As mentioned at the very top and with the key role within Plato's hierarchical society was of course, 'The Philosopher King' This person was to make all the decisions and would of course make the right decisions, for him or even her to come to such a high position of power they would have to be able to 'perceive the truth' or in other words the good or the best decision for everyone within the Republic. The Philosopher King would become almost like a God themselves and their duties included contemplating the good, the world of harmonious ...read more.


Plato believed this because he believed the men and women who were training to be guardians would be of equal status in knowledge for example, even if they were of different gender, Therefore they shouldn't be treated differently because of their sex but in a difference of talent, "Differentiation in treatment between one guardian and another should be based on difference of talent, not on difference of sex" [6]. As well as equality and being treated the same Plato wanted the guardians to share all the same ideals whether they were male or female, this also included their political views, if guardians had different ideas and especially political views then how could they run a state effectively if they all wanted something different or believed something completely opposite to what they were trying to uphold? It wouldn't be a utopia but a state of chaos. Therefore to have them all think alike they would obviously have to be educated exactly the same in precisely the same fields or differences and conflicts would easily arise on how was best to govern, on who would be the best to rule, what was best for the people and other ideas that a guardian was meant to represent and uphold. Women also took part in precisely the same sports as men and also warfare, they had to be equally as fit as they're male counterparts or how else would they be able to perform their duties as good as the men or perform the same duties? "We shall have to train women also then in both kinds of skill, and train them for war as well, and treat them the same way as men" [7] Plato expected women to stand side by side with the other ...read more.


Plato believed, that if women were taught something other then how to bring up a family and were taught in precisely the same way then how could they two sexes have any differences? To conclude Plato believed women could be legitimate political guardians because he believed that they could perform the same job as men if they had the same education and were treated the same and he believed they would be able to the guardian role in the first place because everyone had a slot within a community and without them working towards protecting and ruling the community his idea's would never work and the Republic would never exist or survive. "The best course is for the men and women to receive the same education, share children, and co-operate in the guarding of the rest of their fellow citizens...whether it involves staying within the community or going out to war. The women should help in the guarding and hunting, as female dogs do. They should share everything as much as the can, and this will not only be the best course of action for them, but is also not incompatible with their nature, as compared with masculinity, and is the kind of partnership which nature intended for the two sexes" [10] [1] Benjamin Jowett, The Dialogues of Plato, Great Books of the Western World, Encyclopaedia Britannica, pp. 409-413 [2] Plato "The Republic" 540a (Oxford Edition) [3] Plato "The Republic" 455b (Oxford Edition) [4] Plato "The Republic" 451e (Oxford Edition [5] Plato "The Republic" 451e (Oxford Edition [6] Plato "The Republic" 540c5-9 (Oxford Edition) [7] Plato "The Republic" 452a (Oxford Edition) [8] Plato "The Republic" 468a (Oxford Edition) [9] Plato "The Republic" 457d (Oxford Edition) [10] Plato "The Republic" 466c/b (Oxford Edition) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Determining the Elite within Politics and the Judiciary.

    As neither seems to dominate the political agenda all the time, some commentators have stopped trying to contrast prime ministerial and cabinet government and have instead developed the concept of "the core executive" (Budge et al 2001 p224).

  2. Does Boxing have a future?

    loss, in a sample of active professional boxers, 50% had at least one sight threatening injury to the angle, lens or retina." Whilst these acute injuries are in themselves sufficient to give rise to considerable concern about the public interest served by allowing boxing, greater significance is the chronic injury of brain damage.

  1. Plato's "The Republic" ...

    He is ridiculed for leaving in the first place. The simile deals with all the aspects of Plato's philosophical beliefs, one belief held by Plato is that the philosophers are the only members of society fit to rule, because they are the highest educated.

  2. Justifications for excluding women from the Military selective service act (MSSA).

    Constitution, as well as the United State's international obligation to provide benefits to families whose dependent children have been deprived of parental support by an unemployment of the father but denying benefits because of unemployment of the mother. Women as a group, however, unlike men as a group, are not eligible for combat.

  1. Hamilton Political Views

    judges should remain in their offices during good behavior." By making the tenure of federal judges are not permanent and temporary, "said Hamilton, the Constitution provides that judges should not be changed according to the stimulus of interest or other branches of government.

  2. Disucss the conention that weak leadership, rather than any economic or political factor was ...

    2 Hovell has Cleary used evidence selectively. However, was Hovell's harsh judgement justified or has he made a sweeping generalisation? In other words, have historians since presented a more sophisticated, as well as a more sympathetic understanding of the nature of chartist leadership and their problems it faced?

  1. Politics of Plato and Aristotle

    The non-rulers are a higher level of civil servants and the ruling is the society's policy makers (Hacker 32). Auxilaries are soldiers and minor civil servants (Hacker 32). Finally the Workers, are composed of farmers and artisans, most commonly unskilled laborers (Hacker 32).

  2. Does Islam Constrain or Liberate Women?

    From the beginning, Muslim men have interpreted their scriptures in the light of socio-economic and political situations. This text has thus served as both the foundation and as the point of convergence of many different interpretations. Also the colonisation of the East by European powers involving the 'abuse of female

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work