• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate social identity theory, making reference to relevant studies.

Extracts from this document...


Daniel Evaluate social identity theory, making reference to relevant studies. Social Identity theory proposes that individuals "strive to improve their self-image by attempting to enhance their self-esteem." (Crane) Proposed by Tajfel and Turner in the 1970 and 80's, this theory highlights social belonging and affiliation within successful groups in order to boost self-esteem. Tajafel proposed that people within a group tend to show camaraderie within the individuals of their group, and view other people not in their group with hostility and apprehension. In essence, the individual does this because of the desire to belong and bond within the "in-group" and hence boosts his or her esteem. Yet, how effective is Tajfel's theory of social identity? Tajifel tested his theory in 1970, when he attempted to demonstrate that "categorizing people into groups is sufficient for people to discriminate in favour of their own group and against members of the other group." (Tajfel, 1970) His test involved testing 64 boys on tasks such as estimating amounts of dots and also to determine how much money went to members within the in-group and out-group. He separated the boys into two groups based upon their preference to one of the two paintings. ...read more.


We can see that this ties in with the in group / out group concept that Tajifel proposed; that people within the same group tend to bond and perform well with each other, while people on the other edges, who are not in the in-group are met with apprehension and dislike. However, the concepts of "in-groups" and "out-groups" can certainly reach an extreme. One such example was the Robber's Cave experiment conducted by Sherif in 1954 to demonstrate how people boosted their self-confidence within their own groups, yet showed hatred and disgust towards the other group; in merely a simple competition for resources. The study involved two groups of homogenous white middle class boys in a simulated camp setting, while in reality the camp scenario was set in order to foster group camaraderie and competition for limited resources against the other group. In conclusion, the study ended with hatred towards the other group, fighting, sabotage, psychical violence, theft, gang-type behaviour stemming from typical ordinary boys who one would not associate with any sort of mishap. Yet, this study again demonstrates the social bonding done between people within the same in-group. ...read more.


Yet, if their team lost that match, they were much less likely, How does that relate to the theory however? It relates because of the human need for positive self esteem; one would be much more positive towards something that he or she represents within "the group." Hence, Cialdini's study does corroborate social identity theory. Does the social identity theory really work out in society? To quite a great extent; yes. Tajifel's argument is that we bond well with our own group and go against the other group for the sake of our own self-esteem; other researchers' studies have corroborated that. However, the theory itself is not without its weaknesses and limitations. The theory does manage to describe, yet cannot actually predict the human behaviour. In other words, one can tell what social behaviours groups and individuals are going through, but cannot predict the actions that occur later. Another issue is that the theory reduces the individual into isolation, and does not address the environmental factors that also play a role with behaviour; not to even mention social factors. Yet, social identity theory is in general, rather well supported. Daniel handwrote this paper with only the aid of notes within one hour. May 31, 2012 Start time: End time: _______________________ ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Anthropology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Anthropology essays

  1. Anthropology: Study Notes (Trobrianders)

    They were an egalitarian culture. In the early 1960s the reindeer herders adopted the use of snowmobiles. The consequences of this: the cost of maintaining the snowmobiles created dependency on the outside world (Haviland). GET EXAMPLE OF THE CREE! The Cultural Future of Humanity * One World Culture: idea that

  2. Drum Role

    "Jack Irons [from the Red Hot Chili Peppers] was asked to leave multiple times because of poor rhythm, he was finally fired once the band got big. This proves that no matter how famous a band gets, the drummer will always be scrutinized" (Brown).

  1. Mitigating People Wildlife Conflict. Human-wildlife conflict (HWC) is also fast becoming a critical ...

    INSTANCES OF PEOPLE WILDLIFE CONFLICT This section reviews a selection of species-site specific cases to provide a better understanding of the HWC worldwide and to highlight common problems across local, regional and national levels. The case studies cover Europe, Africa, North America and Asia and demonstrate that HWC is more

  2. Free essay

    To what extent do individuals script their own lives and to what extent are ...

    Bruce, from the film '28up', was brought up in a traditional family however his father was often away. From the film, one gains a sense that Bruce feels quite abandoned.

  1. Outline and evaluate cross-cultural studies of gender role.

    Also there are methodological flaws, the checklist comes into account again as it is developed by Western psychologists, because of this the westernised perspective behaviours considered in one culture to be feminine may not be considered feminine in another, so therefore the findings may be of little use to those in other cultures.

  2. Discuss Free Speech in China Compared to the UK

    New Tang Dynasty Television is also able to broadcast uncensored news into China via satellite. As previously mentioned, there needs to be some consideration taken for who is concerned with the fact that there is no external media allowed, and whether the majority of Chinese citizens really care about only having Chinese media outlets.

  1. Evolutionary Theory for Food Preference and Obesity.

    This study showed how all animals has various preference when choosing mates. This is another point which supports the evolutionary idea, implying that we are ?wired up? to have attractions to characteristics which would provide us with better odds in the game of life.

  2. More adoption, less abortion.

    the father nor the mother; it is rather a live of a new human being with his [or her] own growth? (Bender, David and Bruno Leone 71). There is something alive within the mother?s womb when a sperm fertilizes an egg.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work