Discuss how aid can both harm and hurt a country

Authors Avatar

Name:        Jonathan Tam                Class:        13A

International Baccalaureate – Economics

Aid hurts a country more than it helps. Discuss

Aid can be given to developing countries in different ways. Aid can be given through either bilateral aid or multilateral aid. Bilateral aid is when a country gives aid directly to another country. Multilateral aid involves an NGO (non-government organization) or a third party during the giving of aid.

Bilateral aid is often less desirable. It is because there are no other agencies which regulates the process, and often political issues are involved. For example, the US might give aid to Philippines in order to get their support in the United Nations on the war of Iraq. By this, although the developing countries get aid which will benefit their economy, this aid is not desirable. Multilateral aid involves a third party who is politically neutral, e.g. the International Monetary Fund (IMF). The IMF regulates the donation of aid, and also gives professional advice on how the developing countries can have a sustainable development in the future. The IMF suggests the structural adjustment program (SAP) to the developing countries in order to let them have sustainable development. This include: sound fiscal policy (government revenue = government expenditure), a broad tax base (the introduction of indirect tax, or Value Added Tax, in order to make more people pay unavoidable tax), government invest on infrastructures, market driven economy instead of command economy, etc. Through this, the aid given is utilized and does not alter the political position of the developing country.

Join now!

Also, there are different forms of aid. Tied aid is where the country gives the aid to the developing countries with certain restrictions on the spending of the aid, e.g. only spent on the industry of the developed countries. For example, Germany can give aid to Africa on buying more trucks and buses, with the restrictions that only Mercedes cars can be bought with that amount of money. Without this restriction, Africa will look for the lowest possible price and thus buy the maximum number of cars. However, since Germany is protecting its own car industry, which is less ...

This is a preview of the whole essay