• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A comparative study of two Latin American revolutions exhibits the causes and effects necessary to define a struggle for independence. Through examining the Haitian and Brazilian independence movements, the differences between the fight for freedom and re

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Thuy-Khue Tran Mrs. Pereira 15 October 2009 IB History of the Americas 3-4 The history of Latin America endured a period that was riddled with conquest and a series of wars of independence. A comparative study of two Latin American revolutions exhibits the causes and effects necessary to define a struggle for independence. Through examining the Haitian and Brazilian independence movements, the differences between the fight for freedom and reform in Latin America become clear. The people of Haiti instigated their revolution - a true grass root movement. On the contrary, Brazil's movement for reform was strictly a consequence of a shift of political power from different authorities. In both countries, a driving force caused the people of Haiti and Brazil to commence a movement for change. Just as important as the causes of a war are the effects and the aftermath of the battle; at times the war is started to benefit the people and in other cases the war is fought for the advantage of the privileged and elite. The primary struggles, techniques and effects of the Haitian and Brazilian drive for independence visibly provide evidence as to why and how these two revolutions are distinct from one another. ...read more.

Middle

As a result, the main cause of Haiti's social movement for reform was to establish equality for all people and to permanently abolish slavery. Thus the Haitian war centered around the new ideals for equal opportunity and liberation. In sharp contrast, the battle for independence in Brazil did not result in blood shed or social equality. The prestigious and elite Peninusalres enjoyed their wealth of power in Brazil during Napoleon's invasion of the Iberian Peninsula. After Napoleon's demise, the Portuguese reclaimed control and dominance over their country as Portugal's various bodies of government reunited. Soon after King Joao VI returned to rule Portugal and he left his son Pedro to preside over Brazil as prince regent. However, "the Portuguese C�rtes was determined to rule the Empire from Lisbon and lower Brazil to the status of a colony again (Mabry 5)." The rich and powerful residents of Brazil feared a loss of their influence and privileges; they objected to the institution of the mercantilism policy which restricted their freedom to trade. The elite refused to conform to the rules and regulations of Portugal because like Spain and its colonies, "Mercantilism [would bring Brazil] into the world economy in a subservient position to the mother country (DeWitt 11)." ...read more.

Conclusion

Also, Emperor Pedro ruled liberally and pursued a stable and successful constitutional monarchy. By creating an independent Brazil, the elitist freed themselves from the chains of mercantilism, while still retaining the benefits of monarchy. On the contrary, Haiti did not reach their goal of liberty and equality. They replaced their system of slavery with a forced labor structure that generated chaos and conflict between the public and the government. Although Haiti has the distinction of being the first free black republic in the western hemisphere, it also has the unfortunate distinction of being the one of the most unsuccessful republics in the west. It is still plagued by poverty and continued on the path of instability from the early days of its revolution. Aside from the conflicts between social classes, Haiti also suffers from political damage from the revolution. By gaining independence from their mother country, Haiti and Brazil were left on their own to either prosper or ruin. The countries were building their steps to a better organized country. However, Haiti's revolution resulted in ruin, while Brazil prospered and accomplish its goal- to benefit the elite. In both cases, the political, social, and economic causes contribute to the vast differences in the Haitian and Brazilian revolutions. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. French Revolution and the rise of Napoleon - revision notes

    When the Republic of France was proclaimed, a new calendar (French republican Calendar) was adopted. It replaced a Gregorian Calendar. The new law forbade prisoners to employ counsel (adwokat) for their defense. It also suppressed (zataic) the hearing of witnesses and made death a sole penalty.

  2. The United States War of Independence had nothing in common with the Latin American ...

    One existing parallel of the American Revolution and the Latin American Revolutions is that both of these revolutions "sought to throw off the rule of a mother country whose mercantilist system hindered the further development of a rapidly growing colonial economy" (Haynes, 166).

  1. Revision notes - Causes of the French Revolution and the Development of the Revolution ...

    There were rumors of plots to withhold grain, destroy the National Assembly and starve Paris into submission. In the face of growing disorder, the king backed down. The nobles and clergy joined the Third Estate and vote by hand. By this stage, few Third Estate deputies trusted the king.

  2. 'More than a Mutiny, less than a War of Independence' - Do you agree ...

    wave of patriotic emotions which they privately despised, as Lenin, Stalin and Mao famously did. Nevertheless one must agree with the Marxists that there were a number of economic issues in the revolt: there were legions of Indians disadvantaged by the economic arrangements of the Raj.

  1. Comparing the Causes of the French and Russian Revolutions

    The lower classes of Russia and France both received unequal treatment by bearing the burden of tax and receiving only ignorance from the government. The nobles usually had good relations with the Tsar were mostly very wealthy, living in mansions and owning land as "The royal family was generous to its servants" (Oxley 18).

  2. The Life and Policies of Brazilian President Getulio Vargas - analysis of sources.

    Also, labor was controlled by the government. Business was stimulated by a program of rapid industrialization. Summary #2 - Backyard Relationship The relationship between Vargas and the United States was strained because of Vargas's nationalistic economic policies. More specifically Vargas's industrialization plan that was closed to foreign capital investment.

  1. IB History HL, Extended Notes: Russia, the Tsars, the Provisional Govenment and the Revolution.

    Workers took over factories and railways, banks were nationalized, private ownership of land was forbidden in the countryside, all estates were confiscated without compensation, and the land was shared among the peasants. 6. All schools were taken over by the state.

  2. Notes on the Causes of the American Civil War

    May 1846- Mexican troops ambushed a party of US troops in disputed territory. 5. Polk asked Congress to declare war. Congress did. 6. Southerner and Westerner supported the war , Northerners saw it as a war of Southern-aggression 7.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work