• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

American Anti-Imperialism vs. Imperialism

Extracts from this document...


Anti-imperialism vs. Imperialism American imperialism, beginning prominently in the 1890s, had a number of motives. The dominant directive motive was the demand for markets for profitable investment. There was also the element of inevitable expansion, the "frontier mentality" and the need to secure world standing in order to remain competitive. Finally, there was a religious motivation, the providential charge to bring Christian civilization to foreign cultures. Simultaneously, anti-imperialists argued on behalf of a variety of objections to the pursuit of colonialism categorized into broad categories as constitutional, economic, diplomatic, moral, racial, political, and historical. Quintessentially, the most influential arguments were the economic argument for imperialism and the moral argument for anti-imperialism. One argument was imperialism. Albert Beveridge of Indiana was a leading advocate of American imperialism. In his 1898 March of the Flag speech he presents a case for overseas expansion. Americans were producing more than they could use and foreign markets would increase national prosperity. Acting on Alfred Thayer Mahan's book, The Influence of Sea Power upon History, American imperialists felt the need to protect expanding mercantile trade through a strong two-ocean navy, coaling stations in the Caribbean and the Pacific, and a canal. ...read more.


In fact, many anti-imperialists believed that imperialist policy was against the spirit of the Constitution, a document that stood the test of time and often served as a source of guidance for citizens of America. They believed that a self-governing republic based on representative rule and protection of liberties cannot govern another country without contradicting its own ideals. Many argued that a nation based on self-government couldn't subjugate other people. There are others who argued that both the spirit and the letter of the Constitution prohibited the establishment of the colonies. Some argued that there cannot be one law for a citizen and another law for a colonial inhabitant. The phrase - "Constitution follows the flag" - sums up the argument put forth by many anti-imperialists. There was also a moral dimension to the Anti-Imperialist arguments. They believed that it was simply wrong for the United States to control the destiny of other people and other countries, a philosophy the average American could sympathize with even relate to considering the increasing number of immigrants. Anti-imperialists primarily cared about the United States which convinced many that they would act in the best interest of its people. ...read more.


Under this view, the colony grabbing of 1898 (Guam, Hawaii, Philippines, Puerto Rico) was only the most obvious episode of American imperialism; it was the short period before the US discovered more subtle methods of economic domination, known as "neo-imperialism". What really made the difference was a sudden shift in opinion among a "Foreign Policy Elite" consisting largely of businessmen, intellectuals, politicians, bureaucrats, and newspapermen. Partially, this shift might have occurred because of economic motivation, especially the search for new markets and the need to protect those markets with coaling stations, as advocated by Mahan. Alternatively, imperialism could have been a continuation of "Manifest Destiny", the ideology that fueled westward expansion. With the West mostly won, people now looked elsewhere to expand. The "Foreign Policy Elite" also may have justified imperial expansion using the theory of Social Darwinism, which suggested that only the strongest nations would survive, and that fierce competition was natural and necessary. Finally, the Foreign Policy Elite might have looked to Europe and followed the example set by European imperialists, in particular Great Britain. Most likely is that some mixture of these various factors all worked together to change the mind of the Foreign Policy Elite regarding the acquisition of an American empire. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. How did the American anticommunism beliefs help advance the civil rights movement in the ...

    Morgan also lived through the era of the second Red Scare which allowed his opinions to influence his proof on the existence of McCarthyism. The HUAC released the report "The American Negro in the Communist Party" December 22, 1954. The report is a primary source that provides two perspectives on

  2. Industry vs Agriculture: The Economics Leading to the Civil War

    A: It is evident that the Northern and Southern regions had contrasting economies which created tension between the two regions who felt the need to defend their economic systems. Q: What exactly were the two economic systems? A: The South had an economy based on agriculture by means of slave labor.

  1. The Growth of American Imperialism in the 19th Century

    After this, the U.S. remained until a new government had been established. This shows the U.S. exerting it's power in South America, using the Monroe Doctrine to it's full capacity. The final example of American Imperialism in the late 1800s is Hawaii. The incident started with Pearl Harbor.

  2. articles vs. constitution

    regulate trade, and amendments to the articles required the unanimous consent of all the states. During 1781 to 1789 under the Articles of Confederation, the State governments exercised powers derived from the people whereas the national government held only such powers as had been granted by the States.

  1. To what extent and in what ways did Elvis influence American pop culture?

    This article was written more recently so it is also valuable for it offers more knowledge on Elvis' posthumous impact after examination of his overall influence. It clearly expresses how Elvis impacted American culture by integrating black music into a white society and introduced a newfound sexuality and rebelliousness to musical performance.

  2. To what extent was Imperialism the key cause of World War One ?

    By taking Britain away from her Splendid Isolation, and the creation of the entente, Germany only served to make herself feel even more surrounded and threatened. A second key aspect of imperial dispute that would ultimately lead to war can be found in the Balkans.

  1. Notes on the History and Development of the Arab-Israeli Conflict

    colonialism in Egypt and transform the political system - Nasser was a key player in the overthrow of Farouk - Nasser's early measures included extensive land reforms. Holdings were limited to 80 hectares and the excess redistributed to the peasants - Nasser persuaded Britain to remove its troops from the

  2. History IA: What were American peoples responses to the Vietnam War in 1965 1971?

    In 1972, 48 % said television while only 21 % said newspapers[16]. ________________ b) Change in news on screen Support began to decrease in the fall of 1967[17], but the major turning point in television's coverage of the war occurred during the Tet Offensive in late January 1968[18].

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work