• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing Trench Warfare and Blitzkrieg

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

´╗┐During old times, the main elements of victory were size of army; the bigger the army had more possibility to win a war. However as world develops, the ideology of war begin to shift, and it required more than the size of army. The shift included World War I and II[a]; the wars required well-organized army, abundant supplies, maneuvers, and tactics. Most important element of these wars was the tactics, without any military tactics, the army, supplies, and maneuvers will be wasted. Trenches were main tactic during World War I and ?Blitzkrieg? was during World War II. This research paper?s main purpose is to determine whether these two military tactics would be more efficient in battle than the others. Trench Warfare During World War I, trenches were used widely among countries because of its effective defense against large number of enemy. Trench allowed soldiers to defend enemy forces from passing particular bounders or places, or to buy a time until the ally reinforcement[b] arrives. In the beginning, the trenches were made to provide protections to soldiers from enemy fires but later it becomes complex system. However, trench warfare had numerous negative feedbacks that affect soldiers? lifestyle and the progress of war. ...read more.

Middle

Secondly, the poison gas made the trench warfare much bloodier because of its super effectiveness in massacring people. When poison gas is released in the trench, it spread out quickly and will stay for long period in enclosed space. Thirdly, the tank provided progress to the war by being the moving shield for ally infantries. However, tank at that time really lack speed; slower than man?s normal walking pace. Also ironically, the tank will fall into trenches because of the deep depth of trench and tank?s slow speed that makes impossible to pass the trench. The new weapons somehow made progressive in slow trench warfare to be ongoing, but made it much slower. Trenches were infested with rats and lice due to its enclosed spaces. And also soldiers? bad hygiene that makes them easy target for illness; soldiers were unable to wash themselves because of limited spaces, and water supplies. Sometimes, when it rains, the trenches are flooded with rain water, drowning soldiers or damaging supplies. If the water does not drain fast, it will be contaminated from dead corpses in the trench. ...read more.

Conclusion

Meanwhile, trench warfare was purely military versus military. Only looking at the death counts of two World Wars, it already shows that blitzkrieg was far more progressive and effective in battles than trench; less military death due to short period time of battle until the enemy surrenders. (World War II Statistics) [d] Conclusion Overall, the trenches were used for resist enemy forces, and to protect soldiers from enemy attacks. However, the trench warfare during World War I had greater death counts than World War II mainly because of diseases. In comparison to the trench warfare, blitzkrieg was more successful during World War II; there were lot more progress in the war and more effective. With armored and aerial supports, the army can easily break through enemy defense line. But this tactic lack reinforcement, since blitzkrieg is based on high mobility and offense rather than defense due to limited supplies. These two tactics: trench and blitzkrieg cannot be determines as good or bad tactics because it?s depended on which situation that was used. But the efficiency on the battle will be the blitzkrieg than trench; the high mobility acted as spearhead and breaks through defense line, while trenches are for resist enemy forces. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Letter from the Trenches

    Even so, large numbers of German troops were able to advance through the gap, and take up positions within the salient. One such area was known as Kitcheners' Wood. We were ordered to counter-attack into the gap created by the Germans poison gas.

  2. Creative writing. Letters from the trenches.

    under any condition and our great Canadian commander, Sir Arthur Curry, was up to the challenge. Then on the 9th of February we started our training, Sir Arthur Curry did thing in this battle that was never done before, first he gave all of us maps.

  1. The Depictions of the Holocaust in Night and Schindlers List

    the majority of the inmates were musicians and have not suffered as much as the others have in Auschwitz. This newly found relief soon changed. The conditions soon worsened once the officer in charge of the camp was replaced by a more cruel and brutal new one.

  2. Causes of WWII

    * In 1938 Hitler sent troops into Austria, Britian under Chamberlain allowed it to happen as he argued the Treaty of Versailles was unfair. Hitler's reason was to conduct the voting in peace and the vote went overwhelmingly in his favor, Austria was now part of Germany.

  1. How did collective security develop, in particular between WWI and WWII?

    The main outcome was the Concert of Europe. ("Concert of Europe") The Concert of Europe was a system to prevent wars in Europe. It wasn't a system in which countries were obliged to keep to certain rules and always support each other in order to maintain peace.

  2. Origins of WWII

    Being left with a devastated nation and an economy in utter turmoil, the Weimar Republic was left hated by the German people and therefore, the government found it difficult to appease both its people and the victors at the same time.

  1. Explain the Confucian theory of just war. In this essay, I will explore Confucian ...

    According to Mencius, this is unjust for it does not promote benevolence and peace but it is greatly unnecessary. In an ideal world, all wars are unjust if they do not strive to achieve tian xia and pacifism would be the only justifiable moral stance.

  2. How effective and influential was guerilla warfare in aiding communist victories in the 20th ...

    Maoist theory of guerilla warfare also involved targeting infrastructure, i.e. Winning the support of the population (peasants) by destruction of the government machine and by the spread of pro-communist propaganda, increasing attacks on vital military installations and government institutions and full on conformist attacks are carried out, the government is overthrown and major cities are taken over,3.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work