• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9
  10. 10
    10
  11. 11
    11
  12. 12
    12
  13. 13
    13
  14. 14
    14
  15. 15
    15
  16. 16
    16

Did Truman really save 500,000 American live through dropping the Hiroshima atomic bomb?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Did Truman Really Save 500,000 American Lives through Dropping the Atomic Bomb? 1 Total Word Count:1979 Candidate Name: Amelia Zhang Candidate Number:00079-053 School: Beijing World Youth Academy Table of Contents A. Plan of Investigation Pg 3 B. Summary of Evidence Pg 4 C. Evaluation of Sources Pg 6 D. Analysis Pg 8 E. Conclusion Pg 11 F. Bibliography Pg 12 G. Appendix Pg 14 Plan of Investigation (Word Count: 135) This investigation will consider neither the motives nor the alternatives to the decision of dropping the atomic bombs, but focus simply on "did the decision to drop the atomic bombs save 500,000 American lives?" as claimed by Truman. To answer this question, I will evaluate the Japanese military situation in the summer of 1945, and casualty estimates for the planned invasion of Operation Downfall through casualty reports, memoranda, intelligence reports, and press documents, supplemented by books written by revisionist and orthodox historians, as well as university lectures, interviews, and documentaries. I will focus particularly on Truman's memoirs because it provides a first hand insight to his thoughts and feelings during presidency in context; as well as the book Hiroshima in History as it is a secondary source written by award winning historians through numerous perspectives. A. Summary of Evidence (Word Count:591) The military situation: After VE day, American allies turned their focus on the termination of the Pacific war. Japan's military capacity was irrevocably destroyed yet showed no willingness to accept the unconditional surrender demanded at Potsdam2. The strategy of naval blockade and strategic bombing undermined Japan's ability to develop a defensive line or conduct further offensive operations3. By September 1944 American forces had taken the Mariana Islands, and were in position near Japan's mainland. Nevertheless, by June 1945 the tremendous casualties of Okinawa, where in 82 days resulted in 72,000 casualties; forced American policy makers to rethink their strategy4. Employed Strategies: By early August, 67 Japanese cities had been heavily bombed, resulting in 500,000 deaths5, and 10 million Japanese refugees.6 The Tokyo ...read more.

Middle

Nimitz concluded 49,000, similar to MacArthur's staff's estimate of 50,000 casualties. In short, the casualty estimates for Downfall ranged from 220,000 to 500,000 during the meeting 42. However the July ULTRA interception made a mockery of the lower estimates43. As Drea aptly puts "Japanese reinforcements seemed to blossom with the warm May weather in Kyushu."44 The casualty estimates had to be continually "revised up" as they approached the invasion date45. In Stimson's memo to the president on July 2nd, he argued that an invasion into Japan would result in "an even bitter finish fight than Germany", implying over a million casualties.46 Stimson had been a colonel of artillery during WWI, his point would have not been taken lightly by Truman, and furthermore he was backed by nobel prize winner William Shockley with an estimation of 1,700,000 to 4,000,000 casualties47. In addition Hoover's memorandum submitted upon Truman's request, claims that an invasion would cost 500,000 to 100,000,000 American lives.48 Even Churchill suggested that the bomb could save 1,200,000 lives, among which 1 million American lives49. However Churchill was motivated to convince the U.S to defeat Japan and had the tendency to exaggerate his numbers.50 General Groves even regarded his number "a little high" and suggested slightly under a million51. Yet these high casualty estimates were not limited to the military planners, predictions from the press were equally high. On July 2nd, News Republic claimed that it would cause 500,000 American casualties.52 Life magazine went to the extent of referring to one million53. Similar figures were given by Kyle Palmer from Los Angelus Times54 as well as the magazine Catholic World55. More over, if one considers it from a mathematical standpoint, Okinawa cost 155 soldiers/10sqr miles56, applying only 38% of this rate, an invasion of Japan's mainland would cause 507,280 casualties. Nonetheless revisionist historians have challenged Truman's number, most dominantly Barton J. Bernstein. Basing his argument heavily on MacArthur staff's 2 time estimation of around 100,000 casualties for the opening months of Olympic, contrasting favorably yet erroneously with Truman's casualty estimate of operation Downfall. ...read more.

Conclusion

(Drea 66) 22 (Truman 383) 23 Ibid 24 Harry S. Truman Library & Museum. U. S. Strategic Bombing Survey: The Effects of the Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, June 19, 1946. President's Secretary's File, Truman Papers. Effort and Results., page 42 of 51. Retrieved on February 11, 2010. 25 (Drea, Hiroshima 74) 26 Ibid 27 (Frank, Light 57) 28 Most notably "Weapons for Victory: The Hiroshima Decision Fifty Years Later" 29 There subjects include American and Japanese history, the Pacific War, the atomic project, and biographical sketches of American and Japanese leaders. 30 (Frank, Why 62) 31The leading revisionists are P.M. Blackett, Gar Alperovitz, and Barton J. Bernstein. 32 (Truman 3) 33 (Truman 379) 34 (Truman 3) 35 e.g. when Truman claims the atomic bomb as the "greatest thing in history" the Chinese version translates it into "?????????" which completely eliminates the positive nuance in the word, making it a neutral word meaning the most important thing in history. (Truman 387) 36 (Fog of War) 37 "U.S. Fatalities in and around Afghanistan." iCasualties.org: Operation Enduring Freedom. icasualties, 01 apr. 2010. Web. 5 Apr 2010. 38 (Chalmers 52) 39(Giangreco and Moor 117) 40 (Truman 381) 41 (Giangreco 110) 42 'Minutes of Meeting held at the White House on Monday, 18 June 1945 at 1530' cited in (Giangreco 87) 43 (Drea, Hiroshima 65) 44 (Drea, Macarthur's 207) 45(Giangreco 92) 46(Stimson 102) 47 (Frank, Downfall 340) 48 'Memorandum on Ending the Japanese War' cited in (Giangreco 112) 49("Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists" 38) 50 (�tansk� 29) 51 ("Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists" 38) 52 ("Newsweek" 37-38) 53 ("Life Magazine" 22) 54 (Chappell 88) 55("Catholic World" 422) 56 Total area of main land Japan (Honshu) is 88996.55square miles, multiplied by the casualty rate of 150 casualties/10 sqr miles, the result is 1334948 casualties. 57 ("Peace and Change" 224) 58 ("Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists" 38) 59 He uses Luzon as an example 60 ("Society for Historians of American Foreign Relations" 57) 61 (Newman 4) 62 (Weintraub 127) 63 (?? 92) ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. How did collective security develop, in particular between WWI and WWII?

    However, at matters which involved sides that were non willing towards cooperating, the League of Nations didn't have enough power to enforce anything. The League had some successes and failures, however, when the world was heading towards another war again in the 1930s, countries could simply quit the league without any consequences.

  2. The atomic bombs were necessary to end the Second World War. To what extent ...

    For instance, most factories would be converted to make weapons or military vehicles, and food rationing would be put into place. Because the general population would be brought into the war effort, then the general population would become a valid target for enemy attacks.

  1. To what extent was President Lyndon B. Johnson responsible for the escalation of the ...

    China's 'fall' to communism in 1949 made the Americans frightened by the prospect of a communist Southeast Asia, following Eizenhower's warning of the vulnerability of this area to the 'domino effect'.14 During Kennedy's years of presidency, who considered Vietnam to be "the place to make [America's] power credible"15, the number of "advisors" in Vietnam rose considerably.

  2. My research questions: did the United States of America really lose the Vietnam War ...

    It is self-evident that the vanquished is not the one who lost the least men but the one who failed to achieve its goals. The same situation occurred in the Second World War since the USSR was the one to lose the most men but Germany was the defeated one.

  1. The Evaluation and Effect on the Formation of W.E.B Du Boiss NAACP during the ...

    Du Bois emphasized that the division between whites and blacks was very dangerous because it would halt any progress made towards providing solutions to the causes of African American criminality. He strongly believed the Emancipation Proclamation only left opportunity for blacks fail; because once blacks were freed they still weren't treated equally.

  2. Notes on the History and Development of the Arab-Israeli Conflict

    achieve such a comprehensive and decisive victory in the first Arab Israeli War." As a result of this, King Abdullah expected Israel to help him mobilise international support for incorporating the remains of Palestine into his Kingdom. These talks began in Dec 1948 and resulted in a major victory for Israeli diplomacy (although they had also used military force)

  1. The History and Development of the American Dream

    It is not a dream of motor cars and high wages merely, but a dream of social order in which each man and each woman shall be able to attain to the fullest stature of which they are innately capable, and be recognized by others for what they are, regardless of the fortuitous circumstances of birth or position».

  2. Extended Essay History: How did the US media reporting of the Vietnam War out ...

    village to search for weapons and Vietcong who were purportedly hiding in the village. Several mem bers of the platoon's squad had been killed in the clays before reaching My Lai through a series of booby traps and regular sniper fire, although they never saw their enemy, presumably causing the members of the platoon to be nervous, frustrated and frightened.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work