• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

George Orwell in the Spanish Revolution

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History Assignment Homage to Catalonia 1) Explain the difference between Orwell's perception of the war and the political reality. When George Orwell had joined the Republican struggle against the Nationalists, his perception of the war was one of the News Chronicle and New Statesman. He had an over-simplified view of the Spanish Civil War, as if it was a purely military conflict opposing two sides: democratic and Fascist forces (this is highlighted by his carelessness for joining a party for which to fight, he just happened to find himself with the POUM). But it went much farther than that. It was not a simple two-sided conflict with each side following one clear "line" or policy. At least on the Republican side, there still were many different groups, and by "different groups" I mean different parties, with each distinct "lines," following distinct policies - besides fighting the fascists (and even this is arguable). The reality of the war was that "as a militiaman one was a solider against Franco," which was always Orwell's understanding, but "one was also a pawn in an enormous struggle that was being fought out between two political theories." And by "two political theories," he is not referring to the over-simplified version of "democracy standing up to fascism" but to different "lines" within the Republican 'fight fascism-line'. This amounts to say that the parties were, more or less, as much interested in implementing their own party-"lines" as in fighting the Nationalist Front. 2) Label the political orientations of the party initials, and explain what their 'line' was. ...read more.

Middle

As the USSR started to supply arms, the government took a swing towards the right. It was conducting anti-revolutionary activities and policies such as expelling the POUM and CNT out of the Catalan government, replacing the more leftist socialist prime-minster Caballero by the more rightist socialist Negr�n and ousting the CNT and UGT of the national government. The events that led to that swing are more thoroughly explained in the next question. 9) What were Russia's terms for lending assistance? How did it affect the 'revolutionary' aspect of the war? In October-November of 1936, the USSR started supplying arms to the Republican forces, especially the Communist Party which caused the latter to become more powerful than the Anarchists. It was from that point on that the government, apparently, took a "swing to the right" by adopting anti-revolutionary policies. Orwell suggests that the terms for assistance were "prevent revolution," and so the government and Communist Party "moved against the revolutionary elements," characterized at first by the expulsion of the POUM from the Catalan government. Later the Anarchists and Caballero's socialists were also targeted (Caballero was replaced as prime-minster as mentioned before). Thus evidently the strict revolutionary aspect of the war suffered as they not only struggled with the fascists but with strong internal forces. The worst was such instances where internal quarreling was put above stomping fascists such as the Communists' will to not distribute arms to the POUM on the Arag�n Front. 10) What moves were taken to remove power from the trade unions? The government employed series of small moves to recover power from the trade unions without making an obviously counter-revolutionary move. ...read more.

Conclusion

This also made it difficult for the POUM to defend itself as it could not express anti-Communist Party articles/propaganda. And on an international level, the POUM did not have newspapers while the Communists did all around the globe. International newspapers like the Daily Worker in Britain could be in contact with the Spanish party and publish whatever evils the Spanish accuse them of this time. Readers of the Daily Worker would encounter no arguments against (as again, the POUM had no internationally affiliated newspapers). And such things were published in Communist newspapers all over the world. 16) What were the main differences between the POUM and the Communists - what was above and below the surface of their quarrel? the surface was the fact that the POUM wished for an immediate revolution while the Communists, under commands of the USSR, did not. Below the surface was attempts to undermine one another, especially the Communists against the POUM as they even settled to assert that the POUM was actually working for Hitler and Franco while publishing that all over the globe. 17) What is a fifth column? According to the American Heritage Dictionary, a fifth column is "a clandestine subversive organization working within a country to further an invading enemy's military and political aims." The term actually originates from the Spanish Civil War, more precisely from Nationalist General Emilio Mola who, at the siege of Madrid, said that his four columns outside of the city would be supported by a fifth one that was already inside the city. Therefore the term can be association to treason and infiltration, as if the POUM was a group of fascists that had infiltrated the Left to betray it. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Notes on Italian unification - background and main events

    troops to divert Garibaldi from the Papal states which risked bringing France into the situation * Cavour really only ever achieved unification of the North Venice Joins the Italian State 1866 - Venice still needed to be redeemed as part of Italy - In 1866, Bismarck was planning for Prussia

  2. the causes and consequences of the spanish civil war

    The wishes of the left alarmed those on the right and vice versa. Political infighting was in danger of pushing Spain into social revolution. In The Spanish Civil War, Hugh Purcell comments that 'the main reasons for the outbreak of Civil War were the irreconcilable quarrels among the Spanish people

  1. The Glorious Revolution

    As a result of the English Civil War, the monarch Charles I was executed and a Rump Parliament was established. After Charles I's execution, Oliver Cromwell, the leader of the New Model Army, took over. The Rump Parliament began by abolishing the monarchy and the House of Lords.

  2. Napoleon: Enemy or Son of Revolution

    which meant that there was neither: nobility nor peerage, nor hereditary distinction, nor distinction of orders, nor feudal systems, nor patrimonial justice, nor any titles, names, or prerogatives derived from them, nor any order of knighthood, nor any corporation or decorations for which proof of nobility could be demanded, or

  1. Why did the Communists win the Civil war?

    It was obvious that Chiang Kai-shek found himself distracted by the CCP. "Believing that China was not yet ready to confront Japanese military power and obsessed with his desire to eliminate domestic opposition, Chiang Kai-shek adopted a policy of appeasement and conciliation towards the Japanese" (Journal of Asian Studies, February 1985).

  2. IB History HL, Extended Notes: Russia, the Tsars, the Provisional Govenment and the Revolution.

    1892 to 1895 2000 less university student, nobles/officials from 47 to 56%. ?real schools? rose to 26000. Church schools 4000 to almost 32000. 1897 21% literacy. 7. Government believed peasants should receive a minimum amount of education as education encouraged dangerous ideas.

  1. Analyse the causes of the Spanish Civil War

    The right republic came to power in November 1933, because of the bad reputation the left was getting, by smoking out anarchists and killing many opposition, causing the loss of support from the left republic working class. This lead to a complete revolt in Spain, that went completely against left modernizing policies, eventually causing damage to the citizens.

  2. Notes on the History and Development of the Arab-Israeli Conflict

    War and Peace Causes, course and consequences of the 1967 (Six Day) War Background: - During 1966-67, military tension was high as the number of Fatah attacks increased and Israeli retaliation was quick and ruthless. Nasser was coming under increasing pressure to do something about Israel - The war was

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work