• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Historical Investigation

Extracts from this document...


A: Plan of Investigation i) Aim of the Investigation On the 23rd October 1923 the communist party of Hamburg attempted a putsch. The uprising was put to an end after no more than three days. Despite getting a considerable amount of votes in the elections of 1921, the communists received extremely little support from the citizen during the uprising itself. The aim of this investigation is to find out to what extent the communists were actually supported by the citizens of Hamburg and what factors influenced the extent of support. ii) Methods used in the investigation To find out about this, an eye-witness account of the chief of the police of Hamburg in 1923 as well as a speech by one of the leading German communists of the time has been studied. Additionally photographs of the uprising as well as eye-witness accounts of uninvolved citizens have been looked at. To get a broader overview, secondary literature has been read and some internet research has been done. Word count: 151 B: Summary of Evidence i) Extent of support a) For the communists Hamburg had always been a very industrial city with a very strong working class, consisting mainly of the workers from the docks of the Hamburg harbour. Thus it is hardly surprising that the KPD1 had a rather large electorate - in the 1921 elections for the senate of Hamburg they gained 11.0% of the votes2. The head of the KPD of Hamburg, Ernst Th�lmann3 described the uprising as a glorious fight of the united workers against the class enemy, which was strongly supported by the workers - 'Hundreds of workers built barricades in the streets. ...read more.


Therefore the use of Th�lmann's account for anyone trying to reconstruct the events of the uprising is very limited. It is of great value however, for anyone studying how German communists in later years (especially in the DDR) used the events of the uprising in Hamburg for their propaganda. Word count: 454 D: Analysis The first aspect to be analysed has to be the actual extent of support for the communists. The accounts discussed earlier draw very different pictures of the events of the uprising of October 1923. Where Ernst Th�lmann describes a heroic fight of a united working class, which can partly be supported by photographic evidence, other sources speak of the isolated fight of a small minority of left extremists. The truth most probably lies somewhere in between these two opposing positions. Fact is that at least some parts of the population helped the communists. This support from the population however was limited to certain districts of Hamburg - namely Barmbek18 and Schiffbek, where support for the communists was traditionally strongest. In other districts of Hamburg there was very little support, which, according to Danner, was at least partly forced. On top of that, the Vereinigung Republik, a social democratic group of workers, who had joined the group voluntarily, fought against the communists, which shows that there was no general support for the cause of the communists among the workers, but only support from certain extremist parts of the working class. There were two main reasons for the lack of support for the communists - the lack of communication and organisation amongst the communists and the generally moderate political climate in the working class of Hamburg. ...read more.


6 The picture can be seen in the appendix I a) page 7 7 The Ordnungspolizei was a division of the police of Hamburg, which was trained for combat and street fights. In this Investigation the words Ordnungspolizei and police are used interchangeably. 8 For the German original of this quote see appendix III b) page 8 9 From " Ordnungspolizei Hamburg - Betrachtungen zu ihrer Geschichte 1918 bis 1933" by Lothar Danner (1958) 10 For the German original of this quote see appendix III c) page 8 11 From an unpublished eye-witness account of Lothar Danner, chief of the Ordnungspolizei in 1923 12 For the German original of this quote see appendix III d) page 8 13 From 'R�ckschau eines Unangepassten - Barmbeker Erinnerungen des Fotografen Gerd Mingram (GERMIN) geb. 1910' by Gerd Mingram 14 For the German original of this quote see appendix III e) page 8 15 A copy of the account can be attained from the "Geschichtswerkstatt Barmbek" 16 His book ist called 'Ordnungspolizei Hamburg - Betrachtungen zu ihrer Geschichte 1918 bis 1933'. It was first published in 1958. 17 'Die Rote Fahne' (Berlin) No. 245, 23rd October 1925 18 Approximately 20% of the people of Barmbek had voted for the KPD in 1921. 19 Cominter - Communist International, founded in 1919 in Russia by Lenin and lead by Gregory Zinoviev. The aim of the Comintern was the promotion of a world revolution which was supposed to be achieved by supporting communist groups in other European countries, most prominently Germany, Britain and France. A committee that was involved in the planning of the uprising in Hamburg had prominent members such as Leon Trotsky, Gregory Zinoviev and Karl Radek. ?? ?? ?? ?? Katharina Ziegeler History SL 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Historical Investigation

    that presented the US planning for response to any Japanese aggression against the United States during the period between World War I and World War II. The operation name Edward Miller wrote about was called War Plan Orange. Ultimately, the conclusion was that War Plan Orange was successful more due

  2. To what extent did nationalism contribute to the creation and expansion of the Indochinese ...

    France formally organized the Indochina Union of Cochinchina, Annam, Tonkin, Cambodia and Laos (appendix III). A governor general in Hanoi administered French Indochina establishing it as a French colony. This second external threat and colonization of Vietnam was the most significant event in the escalation of nationalism.

  1. Historical Investigation - What were the long term consequences of the Great Fire of ...

    Due the reconstruction being led by rich citizens the districts were not evenly developed with the consequence of the West End becoming a noble quarter and Seven Dials deteriorating into a slum located in the heart of the city3 ?

  2. WW2 historical investigation. To assess the degree to which intelligence lead to the victory ...

    30 In 1943 the U-boats effectiveness drastically decreased as it only sunk 310 merchant vessels at the cost of 254 U-boats. 31By 1944, the allies were sinking more U-boats then the Germans could construct. 32As a consequence, "on the 4th of May 1945 D�nitz called the U-boats to cease hostiles

  1. Interwar Years: 1919-39

    * The USSR and Germany promised each other that they would remain neutral in the event of either being attacked by a third power. * The three foreign ministers - Gustav Stresemann, Aristide Briand and Austen Chamberlain - were jointly awarded the Nobel Prize for Peace in 1926.

  2. IB History HL, Extended Notes: Russia, the Tsars, the Provisional Govenment and the Revolution.

    Unsympathetic 1. Claim that the July Days were one of Lenin?s worst miscalculations which threatened the destruction of the Party. 2. Failure led Bolshevik propagandist to lie about the event and say that the initiative came from the Kronstadt base and factory workers.

  1. Notes on the History and Development of the Arab-Israeli Conflict

    For many Jews, this was justified on the account that Arabs had not accepted the UN partition, and thus shouldn't need to cater for their return. Many also simply claimed it was a hindrance to the new state. - Moshe Sherok: "reintegration of the returning Arabs into normal life, and even there mere sustenance, would present an insuperable problem."

  2. Notes on the history of Communist China

    institutes in the city, and all modern means of communication - newspapers, films, magazines, radio spread the message of communism to the citizens 8. 1944 met with Nationalists for peace negotiations ? could not be worked out Civil War 1.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work