• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The League of Nations was a failure. How far do you agree with this statement? Explain your answer.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'The League of Nations was a failure'. How far do you agree with this statement? Explain your answer. [Paper 1, (c), /8] In the 1920s and 1930s, the League demonstrated that it can be both successful and a failure. In my opinion, overall, the League was more of a failure. The League certainly has a number of failures. First of all, the League didn't command its own army, thus it had to rely on member countries to contribute troops. In cases where the member countries were reluctant to send troops, the League would be rendered helpless; for example, at Vilna in 1920, the League was not able to stop the takeover of Vilna by the Poles, as the French didn't want to upset Poland (they saw Poland as a possible ally) and the British were not prepared to act alone. Secondly, the Corfu incident wasn't fully successful, as there were many loopholes in the League's actions. For example, although Italy withdrew from Corfu (violence was altogether prevented), Greece had to pay them compensation and apologise, even though it wasn't Greece's fault that Tellini and his team were killed. ...read more.

Middle

After the events unfolded, the League made up excuses to cover up its inadequacy in dealing with the Manchurian Crisis; the League said that Japan was so far away, that it was a special case, and that Japan did have a point when it said that China was itself in the grip of anarchy. We can agree that the League was powerless if a strong nation decided to pursue an aggressive policy and invade its neighbours. The Disarmament Conference in 1932 produced resolutions to prohibit bombing of civilian populations, limit the size of artillery, limit the tonnage of tanks and prohibit chemical waste. However, there was very little to show how these limits would be achieved, for example, bombing was prohibited but there was no attempt at abolishing planes capable of bombing. Moreover, Germany complained that it was the only country which had disarmed and wanted for all countries to disarm to its level; when the Conference failed to agree to the principle of 'equality', the Germans walked out. ...read more.

Conclusion

On the other hand, the League was quite successful in some of its operations. The League allowed for member countries to voice their opinions in the Assembly. At the Aaland Islands in 1921, Sweden and Finland wanted control of the Aaland Islands - they appealed for the League's help and accepted the League's ruling, so war was avoided. Another example can be Upper Silesia in 1921, when both Germany and Poland wanted control of the industrial region. In 1920, a plebiscite was organised for the Silesians to vote on which country they wished to join, and French and British troops were sent to keep order at the polling booths. The League used the results from the poll to divide the region, but built in many safeguards to prevent future disputes - violence was avoided. Bulgaria (1925) was successful to an extent, as violence was avoided and the aggressive country did leave from the country they invaded. The League had a number of commissions and committees that were set up to improve people's living and working conditions around the world. ?? ?? ?? ?? Mai Pham Thanh 11D 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Free essay

    May the League of Nations be considered a complete failure? Answer this question and ...

    if the "ambitions of an economically and militarily revived Germany were to be frustrated (Kitchen, p. 52)". Their absence also signified that the initial aim of collective security was bound to remain unaccomplished, as it was impossible for the organization to possess an armed military force of its own.

  2. Prohibition: an inevitable failure?

    "The 'great experiment' had failed." Similarities and differences in causes: There are quite a lot of similarities between what the sources believe to be the causes of Prohibition. Both mention the Eighteenth Amendment's passing; and its banning the manufacture, sale and transportation of alcohol.

  1. The League of Nations - Although the League of Nations had several successes, it ...

    [7] The League's reaction to the Italian invasion of Abyssinia (nowadays Ethiopia) in 1935-1936 is a perfect example of such objection to the idea of collective security. Although France and Britain had to protect the weaker and smaller country,

  2. How Successful was the Dayton Peace Agreement in Bringing Sustainable Governance to Bosnia and ...

    The practice of forcing international body's opinions onto the local governing was the debate amongst the Bosnian government officials however it was opposed by the High representative as unnecessary and rejected, "Democratization has a long way to go before one can safely say it has taken root in a country

  1. Historical Investigation - League of Nations - Abyssinian crisis

    for arbitration in the Walwal incident.6 Samuel Hoare and Pierre Laval met with Benito Mussolini in Rome to talk discuss about the arbitration.7 Mussolini stated that he would 'wipe the range of Abyssinia from the map.'8 The LON ordered all the members to impose economic sanctions on Italy.9 It took

  2. Was the League of Nations doomed to fail?

    Despite its initial years causing few feelings of optimism, the League of Nations did in fact make some important progress during the latter half of the 1920s. The establishment of the International Labour Organisation, financed by the League, turned out an impressive stream of reports, recommendations and statistics which provided

  1. Ancient Greece revision notes

    They were Greek warriors who were formed when the middle class bought arms. The hoplite was a foot soldier equipped with bronze body-armour, shield, helmet and spear. They were power bases for tyrants . Trireme: was a bow used during the battle of Salamis.

  2. Terrorism is very hard to define; there is no single universally accepted definition for ...

    Even though both the Zealots and the Assassins operated before the middle ages, they are relevant today; firstly they are the forerunners of modern terrorists in aspects of organization, targeting, and goals. Secondly, although both didn?t work out, the fact that they are remembered hundreds of years later, demonstrates the deep psychological impact they caused (History of Terrorism).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work