• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The United States War of Independence had nothing in common with the Latin American Wars of Independence. Assess the validity of this statement.

Extracts from this document...


The Independences of the Americas "The United States War of Independence had nothing in common with the Latin American Wars of Independence". Assess the validity of this statement. Jack Tomlinson 25/09/08 IB History of the Americas HL The American Revolution was one of the most influential independences in the world, as it encompassed the majority of the world at the time, the colonists, the Spanish, the French the British Crown. The colonists were rebelling against the British Crown for mainly the idea that the taxes were unbearable and that the Patriots, or the group that wanted independence, thought that independence was necessary to escape British control. However they did not have the power necessary to confront the British, as they were the most powerful military force at the time, and thus they asked for assistance from foreign aid, which in this case was the French. The French agreed to the call for aid and thus called upon their ties with the Spanish to help them topple the greatest military power at the time, the British Crown. A similar dilemma was occurring in Latin America as there were groups that sought independence from the Spanish Crown due to the mercantilist policies and conflicts arose between the Patriots and the Royalists, those that were loyal to the Spanish Monarchy and thus great wars were fought for the Independences of Latin America. ...read more.


Theoretically, the colonies were designed to be economically complementary to Spain. Manufacturing was forbidden in certain colonies to keep the market open for imports. The economic health of the colony was always a secondary consideration. All colonial trade was channeled through a single port, first Seville until 1720, and then Cadiz. After 1765 this policy was relaxed to allow trade by other Spanish ports." (Rempel, lecture) Ultimately both of the Independences of North and South America occurred because of the mercantilist policies that the Mother country had inflicted upon their colonies. Another existing parallel of these two independences is that both of them were lead by intellectuals that believed in the Enlightenment. The Enlightenment is defined simply as the philosophical movement of the eighteenth century that celebrated reason - clarity of thought and statement, scientific thinking, and a person's ability to perfect oneself. The American Revolution was lead by intellectuals such as Benjamin Franklin. This man had an important role in the American Revolution, Benjamin Franklin, "with three other members of the Committee of Correspondence set up by Congress in November 1775 to make contact with our friends abroad , met with Archard de Bonvouloir and were instructed to open a dialogue on a possible alliance" (Axelrod, 242). Franklin accomplished his task by June of 1776 where "millions of dollars worth of military aid were funneled to the Revolution where France concluded an official alliance" (Axelrod, 243). ...read more.


"Fighting had already broken out between the royalists and the patriots" (Haynes, 167) and thus the conflicts were vast just as the war was starting in Venezuela, similarly to the situation in the colonies. The parallel exists here as both the American Revolution and the Latin American Wars for Independences had those groups that were loyal to the Mother country and those that sought to rebel against it. The American War for Independence and the Latin American Wars for Independence were both the result of conflicts with their mother countries, the British Crown and the Spanish Monarchy. At the finale of both conflicts the colonies won their Independences with the leadership of the elites of the Enlightenment. Both of these wars were fought because of the mercantilist system that the mother country placed on the colonies, both were led by men educated in the Enlightenment, and both had populations that were still loyal to the Mother country during the wars. The Independences allowed the colonies to live independently and not be in the grasp of the mother country. The America War for Independence and the Latin American Wars for Independence retained certain parallels, both sought to throw off the rule of a mother country whose mercantilist system hindered the further development of a rapidly growing colonial economy, both were led by well educated elites who drew their slogans and ideas from the Enlightenment and both were civil wars in which large elements of the population sided with the mother country. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. the causes and consequences of the spanish civil war

    [3] This would suggest that despite the long-term conflict and polarisation within Spain, the ultimate blame lies with those involved in Spanish politics between 1931-1936. One could say that there were too many factors involved to say what the chief causes of the Spanish Civil War were.

  2. How did the American anticommunism beliefs help advance the civil rights movement in the ...

    Hoover's actions and motives only strengthened the civil rights movement and its leaders by moving to end segregation to spite Hoover and others against racial equality. 2. Jim Crow Laws and Civil Rights Movement During the Reconstruction period, Americans took steps toward civil rights with the Civil Rights Act of 1875.

  1. A comparative study of two Latin American revolutions exhibits the causes and effects necessary ...

    The slaves cultured and nurtured the idea that "people of color could have decided on their own to overturn the social order established by whites (Popkin 18)" for they refused to settle for anything less than freedom.

  2. Compare and contrast the differences in the treatment of indigenous people in the British ...

    a big thing, culture, family status, and economic needs and wants like getting profitable resources and new trade routes. In the Spanish society, religion was very important and definitely had a large impact on the treatment of the indigenous people.

  1. 'More than a Mutiny, less than a War of Independence' - Do you agree ...

    Since it was carried out by subjects of various states under a kind of suzerainty of a trading company which was only de facto an arm of the British state, it falls short of being a rebellion properly so-called. However insofar as the participants were seeking independence from that company's

  2. IB History HL, Extended Notes: Russia, the Tsars, the Provisional Govenment and the Revolution.

    3. Economic improvements at massive social cost. Vyshnegradsky said ?we must go hungry but export? 1891-1892 famine 1.5-2m deaths. Government failure to respond effectively to famine encouraged support for opposition. Zemstva played important part in relief effort, showed effectiveness of ?responsible? opposition to Tsarism, increased push towards democratic system.

  1. Notes on the History and Development of the Arab-Israeli Conflict

    - Terrorism was largely unsuccessful in its aims Terrorist acts whilst attention grabbing, horrified rather than successfully alerting, informing and gaining sympathies of the international community. Terrorist acts were often too small to affect any political change, yet were still horrific enough to be psychologically damaging to both the Palestinian and Israeli communities.

  2. The History and Development of the American Dream

    Nonetheless, the question about the Dream and its weak and strong points is still open and highly disputed in the American society. (Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia: American Dream, para.2-8) Both definitions of Adams and Wikipedia authors are too concrete in the former as well as too general and narrow in the latter for describing such a complex subject precisely.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work