• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent can Berlin or Vienna can be held accountable for the start of WW1?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History HL History Internal Assessment To what extent can Berlin or Vienna can be held accountable for the start of WW1? Candidate Name: Vladimir Nardin Candidate Number: Center Number: May 2010 Session Word Count: 2000 words Contents Page Section A: Plan of Investigation page 3 Section B: Summary of Evidence page 3 Section C: Evaluation of Sources page 5 Section D: Analysis page 6 Section E: Conclusion page 8 Section F: Bibliography page 9 A: Plan of Investigation To what extent can Berlin or Vienna can be held accountable for the start of WW1? Subject: This investigation seeks to examine the origins of World War One in relation to Austria-Hungary and Germany. Furthermore, this investigation seeks to establish from which personages the pressure for war came and to assess to what extent each country can be held accountable for its outbreak. The debate revolves around the Orthodox viewpoint where Germany is held accountable and Nationalism in Austria-Hungary's case. Method a. Research for bibliography about the origins of WW1. Instrument: Books. The main criteria used for this selection were: reliability of the source, how recently they were written/updated. b. Examination of two primary sources to support main thesis: Count Szogyney, Austrian Ambassador in Berlin to Count Leopold Berchtold, Austro-Hungarian foreign minister, 5 July 1914 (letter) ...read more.

Middle

However, the source does not give us an ensemble of the decisions of Kaiser Franz Joseph "His Apostolic Majesty... would be reluctant to march into Serbia"7. This casts serious doubt of whether or not Austria-Hungary truly desired a European war as it was pressured by Germany. Another limitation consists of the fact that the source is a letter with specific personal opinions and not an official declaration of war by Austria-Hungary upon Serbia. Additionally, it does not give the full picture of events only concentrating on the relationship between Austria-Hungary and Germany and not on the global European diplomatic situation (July Crisis). Source B: War Fever in Vienna Excerpt from the front-page article in the London Times on 27th July 1914. Report from a correspondent in Vienna. The origin of Source B is Excerpt from an article in the London Times on 27th July 1914. The article was a report from a correspondent in Vienna. The purpose of this newspaper article is to inform the reader of the general situation and mood in Vienna concerning the Austro-Serb conflict after the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand. This is described as "war fever"8 in the article. This document is of great value to historians. It gives clear and concise details on the development of the general mood in Vienna towards an armed conflict with Serbia "A crowd ...another ...read more.

Conclusion

was seriously threatened by Serbian panslavist's ambitions. E: Conclusion In conclusion, Joachim Renak, Bernadotte Schmitt and F.R. Bridge all view that Austria-Hungary in July 1914 went to war to save itself. Fear dominated the Viennese planners; fear of Pan-Slavic nationalism; fear of loosing the military advantage to Serbia, Russia and France; and fear of forfeiting Berlin's support. Austria-Hungary had to emerge from the crisis as the dominant political force in the Balkans. Both the pace and the decision-making remained in the hands of Conrad von Hotzendorf, Austrian Chief of staff, and the Foreign Minister Berchtold. In July 1914, nothing short of war even a World War could achieve that purpose. Nonetheless, there is a general agreement amongst historians that German decision-making was a crucial element in the tense situation after the June assassination. It has been widely asserted by Fritz Fischer, John Leslie, John Lowe and Paul Kennedy that German foreign policy held the key to the situation in the summer of 1914. Bethmann Hollweg, Foreign prime minister, held the pivotal role. It was the German desire to profit diplomatically and militarily from the 'third Balkan crisis', which widened the conflict from an Eastern Europe one to a continental and world war. Ultimately, I believe for those reasons that Austria-Hungary and Germany both tried to exploit the July Crisis to their own benefits, engendering the First World War making them responsible for its origins. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Causes of WW1

    Therefore it can be said that Imperialism gave the countries a long term start to their rivalries. It gave them a background of unrest and instability. Another major cause of the war was militarism between the countries in Europe. During the period from 1870-1914 an arms race was going on between the countries.

  2. The Treaty of Versailles vs. The Treaty of Vienna. Both the Congress of Vienna, ...

    a war again; in other words present French belligerence was prevented and there was peace. As a result, the actual purpose of redrawing of the European territorial map was achieved as it guaranteed peace. However it was left to a system of alliances to preserve that peace.

  1. Why did Germany & Her Allies Lose WW1?

    Yes, they could have been aided with the help of resources and manpower, but a firm sense of leadership was required. The formation of the Allied Supreme Command towards the end of the war, led by General Foch, not only gave the Allies a sense of unity and purpose but

  2. World War 1 Information

    only Liberia and Ethiopia remained independent (Liberia was created by US in the send slaves back to Africa movement) > First Moroccan Crisis > France wants to make Morocco a French colony, but Germany objects > Britain agrees with France that Morocco was in French sphere of control > German

  1. Nazi Germany

    belonging to a great nation, which is racially and culturally superior to other nations The impact of the Second World War on Germany Hitler promised to the German people that he would: o reverse the Treaty of Versailles o rebuilt Germany's armed forces o unite Germany and Austria o extent

  2. To what extent can Mussolini(TM)s foreign policy be described as a failure?

    In an attempt to show the new nation of Yugoslavia that Italy could create many difficulties for it, Mussolini supplied Ahmed Zog, the leader of the state of Albania on Yugoslavia's southern border with resources, staffed its army with Italian officers and encouraged Italian investment in the country.

  1. IB History HL, Extended Notes: Russia, the Tsars, the Provisional Govenment and the Revolution.

    of their own (by 1904 peasants had bought 33% of nobility?s land). Abolished the poll tax in 1886 (reduced burden). 3. Expansion of cities and increase in strikes led Bunge to try to reduce socialism?s appeal through limited concessions such as laws to protect their right to work.

  2. To what extent did militarism contribute to the origins of the First World War ...

    The telegram sent by the Kaiser was brought up in both the British and German press, the British resentment towards Germany only grew and the German population praised the telegram. The British South Africa Company paid almost £1 million in compensation to the Tansvaal Republic to ease the tensions, but the tension between Germany and Britain only grew stronger.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work