• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent did the Treaty of Versailles reflect the original aims of the peacemakers?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

´╗┐To what extent did the Treaty of Versailles reflect the original aims of the peacemakers? The Treaty of Versailles reflected to an extent certain original aims of each peacekeeping nation. However, fundamental disagreements concerning the maintenance of peace and the treatment of Germany meant that reflecting the original aim of one nation would often entail dishonouring the aim of another. The main peacemaking countries taken into account are the US, Britain and France. Although Italy?s involvement in the Council of Four and Japan?s influence as a powerful nation contributed to the decisions made in parts of the Treaty, they are not taken into account, as their original aims were mainly to maximise wartime gains rather than to sustain international peace. Numerous points from US President Woodrow Wilson?s outline of American peacemaking aims, the Fourteen Points, were implemented into the treaty. The US was only associated with rather than directly involved with the Entente, and therefore were more free to create their own aims independent of French or British sentiments. Consequently, Wilson?s Fourteen Points was focused on maintaining a peaceful post war world through self-determination and economic freedom, and placed particular emphasis on a proposed League of Nations, an assembly of both powerful and small nations which would prevent the outbreak of war. Firstly, point 8, which stated ?the wrong done to France by Prussia in 1871 in the matter of Alsace Lorraine?should be righted? was upheld in the treaty, as the Germans were ordered to evacuate all occupied territory. ...read more.

Middle

In conclusion, the idealism of some of the Woodrow Wilson?s aims meant that they were unsuitable for the treaty, and the conflict in aims between the US and France and Britain also damaged the pursuit of many US aims. The aims of France focused more intently on weakening Germany and restoring a balance of power in Europe, and although these views were not shared by other countries, the major role France played in the development of the war ensure that their aims were reflected in the Treaty. France had been decimated by the war, with 1.3 million casualties and 2.8 million wounded, and was acutely aware of the potential strength that Germany still possessed as a result of the collapse of Austria-Hungary and Tsarist Russia. The French Premier Clemenceau wanted to make Germany pay for the damage she had caused in the war, and permanently weaken her in order to ensure that Germany could not start conflict again. France?s original aims were reflected in the Treaty of Versailles in numerous ways: Germany was ordered to disarm immediately and to a point where only internal security was could be managed. The Germans were forbidden to have submarines, tanks or air forces. Also, the French had wanted damages from Germany, and a way to suppress its economy, and demanding reparations was seen as an effective way to obtain both objectives. ...read more.

Conclusion

In conclusions, a number of British aims were reflected in the Treaty of Versailles. However, other British aims directly opposed those of the French. The British were far more sympathetic to Germany, and unlike France, recognized the advantages a cooperative and appeased Germany could bring. Britain wanted a peaceful united Germany which could act as a barrier to the spread of Bolshevism in the East and eventually develop a market for British goods. Lloyd George, the Prime Minister, wanted to avoid the annexation of German minorities in the newly formed independent states, as he feared this would create the bitterness which could spark a new war in the future. This approach was met by direct opposition from the French, who wanted to inflict maximum penalties on Germany. Consequently, the Treaty of Versailles was much harsher than the British intended, and did not sustain the general attitude of reconciliation that reflected the aims of the British, but also reflected the aims of the French who were seeking revenge. In conclusion, the Treaty of Versailles did in its entirety reflect many of the aims of the peacekeepers. However, the fundamental differences in ideologies and attitudes towards Germany and its place in international relations meant that often in reflecting the aim of one nation another nation?s aim would be disregarded. Also, despite the inclusion of a country?s aims in the treaty, flaws and loopholes often meant that these aims were unenforceable, reflected in France?s failure to obtain reparations from Germany. Therefore, the Treaty of Versailles, to an extent, managed to reflect only partially the original aims of the peacekeepers ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Assess the impact of the Treaty of Versailles on Germany, 1919-1930.

    The undermining of the military clauses was mainly because of Free Corps, who had created an "underground military organization". POV#3 - Since the Treaty of Versailles had blamed Germany fully for the Great War, she was held responsible for paying the reparations to the "Victors" while her economy was stretched

  2. To what extent did the Prague spring weaken Moscow(TM)s hold over Czechoslovakia, and Eastern ...

    New literature and philosophical ideas were born, for instance, Milan Kundera's timeless novel "The Joke", and a multitude of polemics and thoughts on the social phenomena. The meaning of free speech was fully pronounced. Czechoslovakia was a mere 40 years old at this time.

  1. Condensed Treaty of Versailles

    placed only where the League says so, and the number of factories is also regulated by the League * Germany cannot conscript * Number of military schools in Germany should reflect the number of army members allowed * German navy could only have 6 battleships, 6 light cruisers, 12 destroyers and 12 torpedo boats.

  2. hrough an analysis of the consequences of the treaty of Versailles, it is made ...

    defeated, WWI was not fought on German soil, its industries were relatively untouched and since mass media was not as developed as in the 1930s and later on, it was very difficult for the German to believe that Germany had lost the war.

  1. To what extent and in what ways did Elvis influence American pop culture?

    Word Count: 552 C. Evaluation of the Sources Source 1 - Extract From: Culture: The King Is Dead, Long Live the King, 2007, Birmingham post [Appendix A] This source is a newspaper article written in 2007 by Andy Welch for the Birmingham Post.

  2. Treaty Versailles Essay

    of the countries representatives had a different motive of the wording of the Treaty of Versailles.18 France had lost about 1.5 million military troops and about 400 000 civilians to World War I. Much of the industrialized northern France lay in forsaken ruins.

  1. US History. To what extent were the aims of Reconstruction achieved by 1877?

    acknowledged the right of being paid wages for their work and also the right to own property, therefore reconstruction achieved its aims as now the black people were recognized some rights and this made them strong and more free people and also made them more close to be integrated to

  2. To What Extent was the Treaty of Versailles a fair treaty that could keep ...

    No troops were allowed to stay in Rhineland and an Allied Army of Occupation was to be stationed in the area for 15 years.[7] Some territorial changes were also made. Germany was forced to disclaim large area of its territory.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work