• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent, if any, did the Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster contribute to the fall of the Soviet Union?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent, if any, did the Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster contribute to the fall of the Soviet Union? Word count: 1,998 A. Plan of Investigation According to the International Nuclear Event Scale, April 26, 1986 marked the worst nuclear power plant accident in history, the Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster. This power plant in Ukraine was under direct jurisdiction of the central Moscow authorities, and the accident raised concerns about the safety of the Soviet nuclear power industry.1 Five years later, the Soviet Union collapsed. Within this context, to what extent, if any, did the Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster contribute to the fall of the Soviet Union? In order to understand the extent of the impact that the catastrophe had, the investigation will examine the Soviet government's engineering operations and lack of safety culture, the government's actions after the disaster and the possible cover-up, and the ideas and reactions during the time that may have contributed to the fall. Historical research and oral history will be used to evaluate Chernobyl's significance. Two of which will be Gorbachev's Glasnost: Red Star Rising, a compilation of editorials from various United States newspapers addressing the Chernobyl accident and a translation of a Moscow broadcast report in The Ukrainian Quarterly, which will both provide Western and Soviet reactions and insight to the Soviet government's role during the nuclear crisis and will then be evaluated for their origins, purposes, values, and limitations. B. Summary of Evidence In the midst of the Cold War, the power of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU) ...read more.

Middle

mentioning their own nuclear catastrophes in his speech in order to divert the attention from only Soviet nuclear mistakes, and felt that his country's "misfortune was being used as a propaganda point."21 Approximately 300-600 million people were contaminated (estimates vary).22 Soviet officials confirmed that the general public was kept in the dark during the incident;23 one even stated, "If we are treating a patient for cancer, we never tell them they have it; we don't want to give them hope. In this regard, we treat the population as children."24 Western leaders called for a international convention requiring information exchanges on nuclear accidents and emergencies with the Soviet Union under condemnation for not initially revealing the accident and withholding information on the mishap.25 C. Evaluation of Sources According to a Moscow broadcast report, the Soviet Union hid the incident from the general public. Translated by Yurii Bohatiuk in The Ukrainian Quarterly of 1986, this broadcast that originated from the Soviet government, stated that "there [was] no destruction that some Western agencies [were] writing about." Its purpose was to provide a counterstory to the outside news media's reports, attempting to prevent any public panic that could occur. It also accused Western mass media of spreading rumors. In light of the opening of the Soviet archives after 1991, this source is valuable since it supported the fact that the Soviet government was secretive about its operations, which contributed to the responsive ideals of "public-openness." This source is limited because it serves as a public broadcast to downplay the incident and not as a government memorandum. ...read more.

Conclusion

The exploitation of the Soviet government caused many citizens to view the regime as illegitimate, especially since so many of their lives were at stake. The disaster opened a "Pandora's Box" of negativity toward the central government. Once the government was longer seen as infallible, its people began to lose confidence. Eventually, in 1991, with so much opposition from its people and within its own government, the Soviet Union collapsed. However, the contamination from the Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster still lingers, and many lives, including military personnel that tried to clean up the mess, were lost. E. Conclusion The Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster still carries a great impact and shook the Soviet Union into a harsh reality, a crisis of leadership. However, historians such as James Oberg argue that it was the policy of glasnost that was the greatest contributing factor toward the fall of the Soviet Union. This policy was already taking its course, but the disaster led to international involvement. With the availability of mass media, both Western and Soviet, this disaster sped up the eventual victory of openness over reflexive secrecy. The Soviet people were already experiencing a deteriorating economy, but then they fell victim to the deathly consequences of a corrupt society, leading to the unveiling of other government crimes such as the use of a black market system that mainly benefited corrupt Communists officials. The Chernobyl Disaster helped determine whether the government was adequate and successful in its response to a time of trouble, but glasnost revealed to the Soviet people that the government was not. F. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. To what extent did the Prague spring weaken Moscow(TM)s hold over Czechoslovakia, and Eastern ...

    close proximity were rigged, nullifying the agreement at Yalta that all East European states should be allowed to have free elections. At the time, the Eastern Bloc was ruled by a collection of coalition governments, a fraction of the party being communist due to Soviet influence.

  2. China's socio-economic changes under Deng Xiaoping

    management and efficiency" The adoption of the "contract responsibility" system in agriculture was expanded as the organizational norm for the entire country, and the commune structure was largely dismantled. By the end of 1984, approximately 98 percent of all farm households were under the responsibility system, and all but a handful of communes had been dissolved.

  1. To what extent did nationalism contribute to the creation and expansion of the Indochinese ...

    which then gave birth to several radical anti-colonial and independence movements (i.e. Vietnam Nationalist Party and the Viet-Nam Quang-Phuc Hoi). However, the weaknesses of these movements and their ignorance of which political system to adopt, allowed for the Indochinese Communist Party (ICP)

  2. Prohibition: an inevitable failure?

    The method of conveyance was slightly different; however both agree on the consequences of prohibition; that it was a great failure. To summarize, both agree quite a bit about the causes and consequences of prohibition; how Anti Saloon Leagues and the Eighteenth Amendment caused the one of the greatest crime waves America had ever seen.

  1. To what extent did Skanderbegs diplomatic and military skills prevent the Ottomans from taking ...

    He was then connected with the Arianiti family, through Angelina, who already had a good relationship with the Byzantine imperial family, who had one of the strongest armies and also put forth soldiers for Skanderbeg to lead. Jelena and Vlajka provided Skanderbeg connections with the Musachi family, who had an

  2. Analyse the causes and consequences of Glasnost and Perestroika up until 2000

    For Gorbachev?s policies to succeed, he needed the support of reformers. Since 60 percent of the Central Committee was made up of Brezhnev?s supporters, political reform was difficult to be implemented. Nomenklatura was against change, as it would withdraw their special privileges.

  1. To what extent did the Munich Conference contribute to the outbreak of World War ...

    "Czechoslovakia has ceased to exist!" Hitler announced to the German people later that day? (The History Place). Chamberlain, along with the France government, ?issued a war guarantee to Poland? (Mandel and Buchanan). The Allies immediately stopped pursuing the policy of Appeasement and promised to protect Poland, even if this could lead to a war against Germany.

  2. The Rise and Fall of Civilisations

    These were known as the hunter-gatherer civilizations. They were nomads who continually migrated in search of food resources with the changing of the seasons. From natural progression some of these peoples evolved to stay in one area and cultivate crops that beforehand they had mostly gathered.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work