• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent is there validity to Ilan Pappes argument that the Palestinians were victims of a deliberate Israeli policy of ethnic cleansing in 1948?

Extracts from this document...


PLAN- FOR: * Plan D * Dier Yassin * UN partition plan * Ethnic cleansing * Zionist intimidation * "No room for both peoples in this country" * Boundary establishment. Territorial loss * Attacks on Arab villages * The Jewish offer to stay deceitful and hypocritical * Arab pop in the state may cause trouble * Room for more Jews Lydda and Ramla had the Arab communities driven out * Moshe Sharettt * David Ben-Gurrion * No evidence supporting Israeli claims * Israel's interests AGAINST: * Inter-communal violence * Encouraged by invading Arab armies * Dier Yassin was exaggerated. Scared many people * Rumours spread * No resilience to protect from Arab countries * Jewish attacks were in retaliation to Palestinian attacks. Convoy incident * Arab violence was more brutal. The Palestinians anticipated the same in return. * Left voluntarily. Will be defeated soon. Return soon. * 156,000 still remained in Israel * Neighbouring countries welcomed the refugees encouraging them to leave. * Could have accepted the UN partition plan which would have avoided the refugee problem by avoiding the war altogether. * Were not really "refugees" * Plan D didn't actually state the idea of ethnic cleansing. Was vague. ...read more.


All of these quotes support the want of the Arabs out of the country and the keen desire to keep it that way. There are also towns with evidence showing the deliberate expulsion of the Arabs from those areas. The well heard examples of Lydda and Ramala, as seen in source O as well as in source S, where 'ethnically cleansed' "in response to direct decisions by Israeli leaders". These show clearly that the Arabs were forced out of their country for the interests of Israel. The Israeli leaders had a clear aim to expel the Palestinians and make Israel an all-Jewish state without any interference. On the other hand, we have evidence showing that it was not entirely the Jews who were responsible for the refugee crisis. Many of the Palestinians were actually afraid of the inter-communal violence taking place and not the persecution by the Jews [Source B]. The war had brought about a lot of enmity between the two races and this lead to violence taking place. However, though this is true to a great extent, the Jews took this violence into their own interests to drive out the Arabs in many cases. ...read more.


"The Palestinian exodus had by this time assumed its own dynamic" and the turn of event coincidently were in favour of the Israelis. Plan D was also a plan "to counter the expected pan-Arab assault on the emergent Jewish state." [Source O]. The uncertainties and fear created during this period added to the cause of departure of the Palestinians. The refugee crisis is a delicate matter for both the Jews as well as the Arabs. Blame cannot be entirely put on either of the groups, as there were many outside factors resulting to this political quagmire. Strong arguments can be held from either perspective, but one has to accept that history is shaped by individual perspectives and each source would be lenient to either side. As said by Mark Tessler "In the face of incomplete evidence and conflicting claims... there is no single cause of the Palestinian refugee problem and accordingly, that there is a mixture of fact and propaganda in both the Arab and Israeli arguments." One has to take a self-evaluated stand and till there is more evidence available, we can only hope these are morally correct. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Women During the Period of Crusades. Crusades were expeditions as well as being ...

    Prime example of women taking charge was Blanche of Castile (1187-1251), queen of Louis VIII of France, who became in charge while her crusader son, King Louis IX, took up arms in his "holy war". On his going away in seventh crusade, Louis IX told his capable mother: "I leave my three children for your care.

  2. The Crusades

    Led by Peter the Hermit, Walter the Penniless, Godfrey of Bouillon, Baldwin and Eustace of Flanders, the First Crusade had been on its way.9 Christians seeking to repent their sins and redeem themselves had an urge to incorporate themselves with this mission.

  1. British Foreign Policy Failures in the Palestine Mandate

    The Palestinian area is regarded by Jews as their homeland due to religious significance and the traditional and cultural connections thus attached to the land. Herzl in his book Der Judenstaat writes that "we shall not revert to a lower stage; we shall rise to a higher one.

  2. Did Germany plan and wage a deliberate war of aggression in 1914?

    Having said this, we can also say that this plan was not defensive at all, we can say that Germany had been planning to use this strategy ever since, and the assassination of Franz Ferdinand happened to be the perfect pretext to put it into action.

  1. Muhammad and the Jews

    Their only available option was to surrender, and surrender they did. After that, they were exiled up North away from Medina with a pact to never harm Muslims again. Obviously, the first encounter between Muslims and Jews didn't have pleasing results due to the Jews deceiving ways.

  2. Notes on the History and Development of the Arab-Israeli Conflict

    There were two peace negotiations which were proposed and failed: The Reagan Plan and the Fez Plan Significance of the war for Israel and the Palestinians - 19 000 Palestinian's died, 368 Israeli's - About 8,000 Palestinian fighters were dispersed across the Arab world helped by an International Peacekeeping force.

  1. To what extent were the social changes in Germany between 1865 and 1890 the ...

    Smaller German states were used to their independence and peaceful co-existence with the two big German powers: Prussia and Austria (the Habsburg Empire). Until the age of Bismarck, Germany and Austria were involved in a fierce competition, the winner of which would be the master of Germany and Central Europe.

  2. An Ethnic History of Canada.

    1837: Upper Canada rebels against the Family Compact (a group of officials that dominated the government- executive and legislative councils, as well as the judiciary). People were outraged over their land granting, education and economic policies.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work