• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent was the Potsdam Conference responsible for the creation of East and West Germany?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Jensen Pon 13E To what extent was the Potsdam Conference responsible for the creation of East and West Germany? To what extent was the Potsdam Conference responsible for the creation of East and West Germany? Candidate Name: Pon, Chin Ching Candidate Number: 003257-041 Word Count: 1969 I s l a n d S c h o o l A Plan of Investigation The conferences at Tehran, Yalta and Potsdam between allied leaders are often cited as the groundwork for a postwar Europe. While ideological tensions had always existed between the western powers and the USSR since the Bolshevik revolution, the division of Germany in two was unprecedented. This investigation explores the extent to which the Potsdam Conference was responsible for the creation of East and West Germany. This requires an evaluation of the actual agreements at Potsdam in comparison to other pre-Potsdam and post-Potsdam events which were also factors responsible for East and West Germanyâs creation. The significance of the Potsdam conference is investigated through Western and Soviet European perspectives, using primary and secondary sources such as the protocol themselves, “The Myth of Potsdamââ by Marc Trachtenberg and James F. Byrneâs plan. B Summary of Evidence Potsdam was directly responsible Myth of “Unitary Policies” at Potsdam I. The Byrnes Plan of July 23-25 1945, by James F. Byrnes, US secretary of State, formed the basis of the Potsdam agreements on unilateral administration1 in Germany.2 II. ...read more.

Middle

official documents- James Byrnesâ Plan, which provides a more objective view on the role of US policy at Potsdam. This differs from conventional interpretation that Potsdam agreement had agreed on maintaining a unified Germany 22 , where Germanyâs division was cause predominately by Soviets violation of 9 "Avalon Project - A Decade of American Foreign Policy 1941-1949 - Potsdam Conference." 10 Mee, Jr., p.210. 11 Trachtenberg, 1996, p.14 12 Wikipedia, “Percentages Agreement." 13 BL Tsybulevsky., 1969. 14 "Avalon Project – The Yalta Conference” 15 Grenville, J. A. S, p. 235. 16 Gaddis, p. 22 17 Gaddis, p. 22 18 Gaddis, p. 20 19 Trachtenberg, p.15 20 Trachtenberg, p.4 21 Trachtenberg, p.3 unitary agreements.23 However, the sourceâs usefulness is limited as its argument has not been completely endorsed by the majority of Cold War historian e.g. “pre-eminent and internationally celebrated24” US diplomatic historian John Gaddis, who Trachtenberg claims to have “not been privy to what had really gone on at Potsdam”.25 Thus this source only represents view of a minority of Cold War historians, and may contain an element of subjective bias. The second source is a compendium called “Tehran-Yalta-Potsdam, Collection of Documents” containing”, a collection of papers produced at the Potsdam conference on 1st of August, 1945, which is compiled by a Soviet historian SH.P Sanakoev, BL Tsybulevsky. As the source was published in 1967 by the “Moscow Publishing House „International Relationsâ”, the views it presents regarding Soviet responsibility at the Potsdam conference regarding the division of Germany is undoubted heavily influenced by Soviet authorities and censors. ...read more.

Conclusion

The percentages agreement implied “a division of Europe into spheres of influence” and left “little room for the Europeans to determine their future.” At Yalta, the Red Army occupation was densely spread across Eastern Europe. Poland in particular, had been seized by the Red Army, imposing a new government with the help of Lublin Poles. This suggests though the war had forced cooperation between the western allies and the Soviets, this “unnatural alliance” was only driven by a common goal of defeating the axis powers, and had not reconcile their ideological differences. Thus, the cause of East and West Germany creation may lie in the roots of ideological incompatibility, where Potsdam merely catalyzed Germanyâs inevitable division. E Conclusion In conclusion, Potsdam was directly responsible for the creation of East and West Germany, through laying a hidden framework of economic division of Germany on the basis of incompatibility of post-war economic interest. Although Potsdam had achieved many fundamental agreements, the nature of these agreements on Germany were on foundations of unilateralism and a silent confirmation their ideological could never allow for any real economic or political cooperation, and in the long run, would only lead to severe disagreements. In simplistic terms, the agreements of Potsdam “had agreed to separate Germany”. Ultimately, Potsdam was essential and indispensible in causing the creation of Germany into East and West since it created the permanent conditions for Germanyâs separation precluding the possibility of unified Germany in a future post-war Europe. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Who was responsible for the Cold War?

    The Russian Revolution, as famous Russian poet Boris Pasternak described, implemented "general upheaval and reorganization of the whole of society" (Doctor Zhivago, 1957) This shock event was so revolutionary that the West had at this point the perfect opportunity to cooperate with Russia, wiping away the long standing antagonism created by conflicts such as the Crimean War (1853 to 1856).

  2. Lenin's Role in Creation of USSR

    take power, to end Russia's involvement in the First World War, confiscate big estates and establish workers control of the industry. These announcements were not only highly popular and broadened support for the Bolsheviks, a vital factor for the successful revolution, considering that the Bolsheviks did not face any opposition when they seized power.

  1. Compare and contrast the policies of the USA and USSR towards Korea between 1945 ...

    The American Army emerged from Korea convinced that its vastly superior firepower and equipment could always defeat a poorly equipped Asian army if provided the opportunity to deploy them. * Results of the Korean War was not good for the USSR.

  2. Yalta and Potsdam Conferences

    Potsdam Conference 1. What factors might have encouraged the members of the Grand Alliance to continue working together at Potsdam despite their differences? Europe was in disarray following the German surrender and the end of WW2 in Europe.

  1. How valid is to claim that "Europe stumbled into a war in 1914"?

    Furthermore, Russia-British relations were strengthened in 1907 with the Anglo-Russian Entente. Moreover, Germany made another diplomatic mistake by provoking the Moroccan Crisis and putting pressure on France to test British friendship, which only increased German unpopularity and strengthened the Alliance System.

  2. The Role Played by the Yalta and Potsdam Conferences in the Origin of the ...

    In Poland the Americans wanted an entirely new government since they felt that there had not been a �free and democratic� vote.

  1. IB History HL, Extended Notes: Russia, the Tsars, the Provisional Govenment and the Revolution.

    Zemstva came under Ministry of the Interior?s control. 7. 1892 Municipal Government Act restricted (and thus reduced) the urban electorate to owners of immovable property over a certain amount. Effects 1. Nobility continued to decline despite the introduction of the Land Captain.

  2. To what extent was Germany responsible for WWI?

    and their confidence their plan of attack made war a risk worth taking. They were also involved through the alliance system with Britain and Russia in which France knew that she could rely on them for support, seeing its opportunity to reclaim its lost lands.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work