• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparative Commentary Text 1 Those Winter Sundays, Text 2 The Boat

Extracts from this document...


Andrea Diaz Va1 Comparative Commentary - Text 1 "Those Winter Sundays", Text 2 "The Boat" Text 1 and Text 2, both have the common theme of fathers. Text 1 is a poem titled "Those Winter Sundays" by Robert Hayden, while Text 2 is an extract of the short story "The Boat" by Alistair Macloed. The purpose of Hayden is to tell the story and to tell younger people to appreciate their father; on the other hand Alistair MacLoed's purpose was to entertain the audience. The common theme are the fathers, both texts narrate the story and the relationship between a father and a son. Both texts show how they treated their fathers in a careless way but then realized they shouldn't have. In text 1 he realizes too late, and he can't do anything to change it, however in text 2 the character realizes just on time and starts loving his father and appreciating what he does. There are several other similarities and differences like the fact that both fathers do hard work and they probably belong to the working class or even to the poorer class. ...read more.


The structure of text 1 is very different to text 2, first of all the fact that text 1 is a poem and text 2 a short story. As it was already mentioned, the regretful tone in text 2 is transmitted through the development of the story; the story is structured in paragraphs. The structure of the short story is very important as it starts by setting the scene as it describes the "good summer". In the second paragraph Alistair MacLoed describes the father and how he suffers and keeps on working, "his lips still cracked so that they bled when he smiled", this starts creating a tone of guilt as the character saw his dad suffer and did nothing. In the third paragraph we notice some transformation as he starts to realize the hard work his father does but it's in the last paragraph is where we see the biggest change as he changes his attitude and starts loving his father. Structure is also very important in text1, the poem. ...read more.


The use of the words "chronic angers" suggest tension in the family and opens the possibility of a long lasting fight happening inside the house, "speaking indifferently to him" also adds into the suggestion of tension in the house and the use of the word "indifferently" creates guilt as he treated his dad in an indifferent way. Furthermore Alistair MacLoed, the author of text 2 uses common diction through out the short story, the diction in both texts is very similar. MacLoed uses several times the word "and" there are several purposes for the use of the word "and", at the beginning, when describing the father's effort the word "and" is used for repetition as it increases the effect of empathy in the sentence. Later on in the story the word "and" is used to link ideas and to establish a good relationship between father and son as the text reads with a happier but still regretful tone. In conclusion both texts have clear similarities and differences as they both shared the topic of fathers and their relationship with their sons, though they have different purposes and therefore differences. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Languages section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Languages essays

  1. Free essay

    Child and Insect by Robert Druce - Commentary

    This makes it seem Iike the author is giving the grasshopper an image of something greater than just an insect.

  2. A Comparative Essay, Discussing The Similarities And Differences Of The Text And Film Adaption ...

    For very different reasons, both Winston and Julia desperately want to continue their relationship with each other. In the meeting with O'Brien, the couple says they will do anything they have to, with the exception of betraying each other. This act of commitment could be seen as an act of love, it is far from it.

  1. Macbeth Act 5: Scene 2 Commentary

    audience relates this back to earlier in the play when she said "Go get some water and wash this filthy witness from our hand" (Act 2, Scene 2) to Macbeth after Duncan's murder. She says "Yet who would have thought the old man to have had so much blood in him?"

  2. English Commentary

    is feeling and makes us imagine what it would be like to experience a similar situation. In line 20 there is a less hopeful tone and an attempt to face the reality of death on Pi's part. He seems to be examining the frail nature of a weak animal on the verge of death; struggling for survival.

  1. "Bleak House" Commentary

    that takes pleasure in attacking weak, vulnerable people like 'ancient Greenwich pensioners' and the 'shivering little 'prentice boy'. Another very effectual line is 'Chance people on the bridges peeping over the parapets into a nether sky of fog, with fog all round them, as if they were up in a balloon, and hanging in the misty clouds'.

  2. Poetry Commentary on To His Coy Mistress

    Immediately, we notice how the poet finishes the transition with the use of the word "now" (L.33). Here, we can see that he wants to have sex "now... while the youthful hue / sits on thy skin like morning dew" (L.33-34).

  1. Comparing and Contrasting Nadine Gordimer's Narrative Situations

    In "Some Are Born to Sweet Delight", 3rd person narration seemed to make the reflector more sympathetic, but in "A Journey", after reading in 1st person, 3rd person seems more detached and impersonal; readers relate less to the father than the son because, in general, the public's sympathy resides with the more innocent: in this case, the son.

  2. L'etranger chapitre 2 et 3

    passent, comme les familles avec la m�re �norme, les jeunes gens du faubourg et plus. Il ne va pas dehors et parler avec les autres donc il se d�tache de soci�t�. * Cette expression d�crit peut-�tre sa nature m�canique et style de vie; il s'assoit dans son balcon toute la journ�e au lieu de faire d'autre travail.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work