• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comperative Commentary on Newspapers

Extracts from this document...


English A2 IB Charlotte.F.J.Walter Comparative commentary - Newspapers The articles from the Independent and the Sun are written on the 13th of September 2007 and describe the same event. Namely the new outbreak of foot- and- mouth disease. The articles are written by Andrew Grice (Text a) and George Pascoe-Watson (Text b) and both writers are political editors. Through different stylistic devices and aspects such as headings, photo's and sources, the reader gets drawn to the article. Both newspapers appear to be giving the exact same information. By using these aspects and the different styles of writing the perspective, reliability and information of these articles are influenced. The Sun (mostly right-winged) is a tabloid as to the Independent (mostly liberal) which is a broadsheet, because of this it can be known that the way they present information will be different. Both articles use aspects to influence the reader, but both emphasize differently which creates a difference in the emotion and view of the reader. ...read more.


Text a already shows this in its heading. This subheading is fairly informal because "Cam and PM" are abbreviations for the prime minister and Mr. Cameron. In the subheading "Questions", the paragraphs are the opinions of different sources in the article which criticize the situation. The subheading makes the structure clearer. As supposed to text a, where there are no subheadings needed because the information is shown clear in the heading. As sources add reliability to an article, both articles use sources. Some differentiate and some are identical. Mr. Cameron is one of the known sources that both of the newspapers have. "I think there is a real question about government competence" was shown in both of the articles, to indicate that this was probably a public conference and that everyone has access to this information. Because it is a source that more than one newspaper uses it can be assumed that this is reliable. Text a also has some other sources where it could be assumed that these are more reliable. ...read more.


Text b shows less pictures but shows a picture of Mr. Brown this is also used to show the reaction of Mr. Brown and helps the readers to understand that Mr. Brown is accused. This could possibly also relate to the fact that the Sun is a right- winged tabloid. Overall the photographs show in both of the newspapers the seriousness of the article and makes the reader understand faster and easier what is going on in the article. Both articles decided to emphasize on different aspects to create a perspective for the reader. The Sun decided to do this more with the headline, as to The independent which focuses more on pictures. Because of these aspects the readers view will differentiate after reading one of the articles. It would seem that with the Sun the reader gets influenced more because this shows clearly a right wing perspective as to the Independent who tries to only give information. No matter which aspect is used for a newspaper, each newspaper emphasizes more on a certain aspect than another to give their opinion towards the world in a subtle way. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Languages section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Languages essays

  1. English Commentary

    The reader also hears screaming winds while the use of "my [screaming] heart" prepares the reader for what is to come: an emotional event that forces us to examine what life is and what it means. The fact that everything is screaming conveys the severity of the situation communicated in an ominous tone.

  2. Poetry Commentary on To His Coy Mistress

    Moreover, with the use of repugnant images such as "worms" (L.27), "dust" (L.29) and "ashes" (L.30), the poet is able to emphasize the lifelessness of the poem, as the images are related to the decomposition of bodies, referring directly to the grave.

  1. The Canonization - Commentary

    Man speaking to people, and therefore a dramatic monologue where he addresses outsiders trying to defend his choice of love from upper class society who disapprove of the woman he chooses to love. However, the man is relentless in love for the woman, regardless of what others think, and asks

  2. WL-German: Comparative Commentary on "Der Fremde" and "Hexenjagd"

    Auch kann er keinerlei Liebe f�r andere Menschen als f�r seine Mutter empfinden. Sogar die Beziehung zu Marie beruht rein auf physischer Basis. Seine allgemeine Gleichg�ltigkeit spiegelt sich auch an seiner etwas seltsamen Antwort auf Maries Heiratsantrag wieder: "Ich habe ihr erkl�rt, dass das v�llig belanglos w�re und dass wir, wenn sie es w�nschte, heiraten k�nnten" (S.

  1. Maestro Commentary

    Goldsworthy uses syntax in his use of shorter sentences to emphasise the effect of what we are reading. Also, the 'As always' sentence uses alliteration. This adds to the effect of the short sentence, making it more interesting to read.

  2. Land Commentary

    His/her history is tainted with imperialisitc oppression, forcing upon the land a culture that it shames to carry. In the same way the imperialists objectified the black population, the local Africans have judged the remaining colonial population as successors of white superiority.

  1. Prose Commentary Pat Barker "Regeneration"

    In the next two paragraphs, the author makes the wind and its severity, an impacting factor on "Burns'" progress toward the safety that he seeks. The wetness of the setting which surrounds "Burns" is also again a major influence in his quest.

  2. Odyssey Commentary

    Next I lopped all the branches off the olive, trimmed the trunk from the root up, rounded it smoothly and carefully with my adze and trued it to the line, to be my bedpost. I drilled holes in it, and using it as the first bedpost I constructed the rest of the bed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work