• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How do Marquez and Lorca Explore Affirmation of Self Through Reputation?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How do Marquez and Lorca Explore Affirmation of Self Through Reputation? 'In The House of Bernarda Alba', the role of reputation is of central significance. Bernarda Alba is obviously very concerned with what her neighbours think of her and her family as desire for social standing drives her actions, something Lorca makes very clear throughout the play. M�rquez displays the colonel and his wife's concern for reputation in a more subtle way but it still comes across powerfully. The colonel is more concerned about looking strong despite living in absolute poverty. This is perhaps linked to the fact that he was once a highly-ranked military officer. Bernarda Alba is from a wealthy background and family and seems to think that her high social status requires particular behaviour from her and her family. She lives in fear of her reputation being tarnished and is hence very concerned about what her neighbours think of her and her daughters. This is apparent from the outset, before we even meet Bernarda herself. The first characters in the play that are presented to us are the Poncia and the Servant. Whilst cleaning the house for Bernarda's dead husband's funeral, they mention how Bernarda would be furious if everything was not looking impeccable for the guests. The Servant and Poncia have no respect for Bernarda ("Damn her!") but it is she that employs them and so, against their will, they must clean everything for their mistress and whilst the Servant complains "I've got blood ...read more.

Middle

This almost certainly comes from a sense of pride that he treasures, having lost everything else. We see this throughout the novella, not only from what the colonel does but also what he does not do. For example, he attempts to sell things to people at a reasonable price, like the clock (despite "The colonel felt ashamed" even at this) and, eventually, the rooster. But he is reluctant and hates asking "for credit in the neighbourhood stores". We know this because "he had to grit his teeth many times". This is mentioned only once and this is perhaps explained by the fact that the colonel is ashamed of this and although the novella is written as a third person narrative, events are explored from the colonel's perspective. The fact that M�rquez only mentions this incident once and quickly shows that it is something that the colonel would rather hide and let pass. There is another moment in the text where he is at Sabas' house and he declines another umbrella and says that he would rather wait for the storm to pass. Although the colonel and his wife are in desperate need of money and the colonel's pension, they would hate to show that they are suffering. They want to appear strong more than anything and want to keep up their image and hence, their reputation. As well as there being a definite desire for reputation amongst the eponymous protagonists in the two texts; there is a similar feeling amongst many other characters. ...read more.

Conclusion

Marquez uses the Colonel to tell the tale of a time of deep injustice for both civilians and war veterans in Colombia. Reputation is hence a key theme because when everything has been taken away by their government, all they have left is image and reputation to survive with. Conversely, this is something that the government has lost amongst the people. In conclusion, I believe that the themes of reputation and image play a key role in both The House of Bernarda Alba and No One Writes to the Colonel and that they, in a certain way, dictate the ways in which the main characters act throughout their respective texts. What is very interesting to notice is the difference in the reputations that Bernarda and the Colonel are attempting to live up to whilst taking into account their situation. Whilst Bernarda has money but maintains her power in her household in a most brutal way and a great lack in faith and friends, she is worried about seeming very religiously correct, to the point that she exaggerates this greatly (she decided on eight years of mourning for her and her family). The colonel, on the other hand, is a good man but has no money. Therefore, his concern is about seeming strong despite this and he realises that he has friends and that people like him so he has no fears about being a good citizen and friend. Both writers show us that how we are perceived by others affects our sense of identity and, in turn, our status in society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Languages section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Languages essays

  1. An exploration of the symbolic significance of the horse in Federico Garcia Lorca(TM)s Blood ...

    of the play, evoking the idea of predestination and thematically linking traditional life in rural Spain with the force of destiny in classical tragedy. The powerful symbolism of the Horse connotes different representations of Leonardo's personality: the lover, the passionate man and the loyal young boy.

  2. study guide- Ibsen's A Doll's House

    My least favorite character in the work would most definitely be Torvald While the name calling and putting woman down did not really bother me in the beginning of the first Act, it started to later on. "My dear Nora, as a lawyer, I know what I'm talking about.

  1. Comparing and Contrasting Nadine Gordimer's Narrative Situations

    The second story in which Nadine Gordimer uses narrative situation to inform readers about the nature of humankind is "A Journey". "A Journey" shifts narrative situations most significantly from 1st person dissonant to 3rd person figural and dissonant; Gordimer uses these to indicate change in characters as they adjust to their surroundings.

  2. Articles of VN War

    Phan d� may man l�m boc lo ch�n tuong cua Trinh C�ng Son. Nguoi dung ra thi h�nh l� gi�o su T�n Th�t Duong Ti�m, v� L� Canh �am, l�c d� l� T�ng Thu K� �ai Hoc Y Khoa Hu�.

  1. The Significance of Money In Controlling The Fate Of The Female Characters in A ...

    Work, politics and money business were left to the males. This is what the society expected from Nora. Therefore, when it is revealed in the play that Nora once forged her father's signature to borrow the money, she transformed from Torvald's "possession" to an independent woman who is making her own decisions.

  2. Death(TM)s Effect on the Realities of Life in House of Bernarda Alba and The ...

    a new life waiting as Ranyevskaya's final trip to Paris proves at the end. In addition to the circular structure, the start and end is essentially the same in plotline and the reader can see how this would be a vicious cycle, imagine how the story of these characters' families would continue.

  1. DIE AUFLEHNUNG GEGEN DAS GESETZ IN SOPHOKLES ANTIGONE UND IN FREDERICO GARCIA LORCAS BERNARDA ...

    Frauen vom Leben ertr�umen und was in ihrem Inneren an unterdr�ckter menschlicher Selbstverst�ndlichkeit schmachtet. Lediglich mit Worten gelingt es ihr, sich von der unmenschlichen Unterdr�ckung zu befreien. Wie sehr Bernarda diesen Freiheitsdrang, der selbst bei der Alten noch lebendig ist, zu unterdr�cken versucht, wird in der Tatsache deutlich, dass sie

  2. Biography of Professor Higgins by Colonel Pickering

    I must add here that the story is well known by now and the success of Higgins' experiment can only lead us to override class distinction in England, with its rigid rules about pronunciation and manners. Higgins' experiment has proved that exceptional individuals may reinvent themselves through hard effort.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work