• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Mother Courage and her children commentary

Extracts from this document...


Mother Courage and her Children Does mother courage deserve some sympathy or is she merely a greedy callow business woman. Through the actions of resisting the recruitment of her son to the war and charging high prices for increased profits, Mother Courage is seen to be the greedy business woman who only takes from the war, but does not give. However, are her actions of mere greediness simply being a loving mother trying to protect her children? Though Mother Courage seems to deserve sympathy as a result from the death of all her children, examples throughout the playwright suggest that the sympathy comes directly as a consequence of her greediness. The reasons for her sympathy are because of her greediness which are seen in the first, third and last scenes of the playwright, where Mother courage resists Eilif's participation in the war, the death of Swiss Cheese and the death of Kattrin. Bertolt Brecht's use of key literary features also contributes to the representation of Mother Courage being a greedy business woman. ...read more.


The scene where Swiss Cheese dies is another strong example where sympathy results only from Mother Courage's actions of greed. Taking place in chapter 3, (p.42) Swiss Cheese is killed because of Mother Courage's greed to sell the cart for a higher price, "Yvette: Well, you got what you what you asked for, with your haggling and trying to keep your cart. Eleven bullets they gave him, that's all." Some sympathy can be shown towards Mother Courage as her son has just died; however, her greediness is one of the sheer reasons for the death of her son. If Mother did not bargain the price for her cart, and barter for a higher a price, the life of Swiss Cheese could have been saved. It is evident that Mother Courage may be sympathised with because of her being represented to be a caring mother who has lost her son. When in reality she has simply brought upon the death of Swiss Cheese onto herself as if it was not for her greed in the negotiation between the selling of the cart, the sympathy resulting from the death would not have occurred. ...read more.


It can be seen that for each act of greediness she displays, a consequence is followed with. The greed to take from war but not give, she loses Elif, the greed to bargain the price of the cart results for the death of Swiss Cheese and for the greed of sheer money she loses Kattrin. This suggests that Bertolt Brecht wants to communicate that his intension was not to create a mood of sympathy for Mother Courage, but rather a punishment. Though one may seem unusual to have absence sympathy for someone who has lost their children, Bertolt Brecht is communicating the message that the greed of Mother Courage is the reason for the sympathy the audience is feeling. Though Mother Courage may seem like the good mother looking out for her children, analysis shows that this is not the case. She is merely the greedy business woman who is punished with the loss of her children for the reason of her greed and in return the audience feels some sympathy. However, the sympathy is only the result from her greed which has created the loss in the first place. ?? ?? ?? ?? Riki Nagoya ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Languages section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Languages essays

  1. Mother Courage scene 5 Analysis

    He's being sarcastic by saying that the fur coat to mother courage is equivalent to the baby, a human life, to Kattrin. Irony: Set design: "the village has been shot to pieces" which is supposed to bring about grief and loss yet, "victory music can be heard" as if destruction brings them success and pleasure.

  2. Nature of Sympathy in Anna Karenina

    in the pursuit of goals larger than his own private desires, and Oblonsky's unrepentantly indulgent lifestyle - this can be taken as representative of Tolstoy's reflection on the influence of city and country life.

  1. Mother Courage and Her Children

    This image is intensified by the next line How can you flog them into battle as you usually flog large animals. This gives the impression that soldiers are mindlessly following the commands of their superiors because loyalty demanded it of them.

  2. Articles of VN War

    Sau 1975, Nguy�n Khac Tu lo dien l� vi�n dai t� Viet Cong. H� tro tan t�nh cho Ho�ng Kim Loan l� Tr� Quang, ��n Hau. C� th� n�i tu 1963, sau dao ch�nh, d�n 1966, l� thoi gian n�i loan Mi�n Trung cua Th�ch Tr� Quang, Th�ch ��n Hau.

  1. Comparison of Crime and Punishment and Julius Caesar

    he (the ordinary person) will suffer when he realizes the error of his ways...There's no permission or prohibition involved (for the extraordinary people)." Secondly, the protagonists both choose to abandon their families and isolate themselves. In Julius Caesar, Portia questions Brutus's behaviour, "And when I ask'd you what the matter was, / You star'd upon me with ungentle looks.

  2. Hamlet ACT I Scene I:1

    � Scene III: He cautions her against falling in love with Hamlet, who is, according to Laertes, too far above her by birth to be able to love her honorably. Since Hamlet is responsible not only for his own feelings but for his position in the state, it may be impossible for him to marry her.

  1. Mother Courage & Love in the time of cholera

    is later described to have been "the most sought-after young man in his social circle"4 regardless of him being "ugly and sad"5. As the novel progresses, it becomes clear that his place as an illegitimate child with little education is the direct result of his hard life.

  2. Review and commentary on "13 reasons why" by Jay Asher

    Jessica liked Alex but thought he liked Hannah. Jessica and Hannah would be able to talk about different stuff, however Hannah was betrayed by Jessica. She believed that the rumors were true, therefore she starts to create a distance between herself and Hannah. One day Hannah noticed that Tyler Down has been at her window stalking and taking photos of her, while she was in her house.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work