• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Poetry Commentary "Carpets"

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparative Study A comparative study of the two poems "Carpet-Weavers, Morocco" and "Ispahan Carpet", brings us into an Eastern culture of young girls working skilfully, their small hands creating woven carpets of great beauty. Both poets create different environments by injecting emotionally charged descriptions of similar scenes. I believe that the success of these poems results from their splendid use of themes, emotive vocabulary and contrasting as well as similar issues raised. The poem, "Carpet-Weavers, Morocco" is, as I see it, the lighter of the two poems, has three lines in each of its four stanzas. The first line contains the main theme seen in both of the poems; it talks of "another world", which as is followed up later in the poem, refers to the constant differing between the East and the West. The poem continues and in the first stanza there is reference to the second theme, that of the children being like machines, working constantly. There is more reference to the East versus West contrast opening the second stanza. ...read more.

Middle

The poem says that the carpet is all that they know, the poet says this in the words, "O, eyes whose whole horizon is the carpet". The poem goes on to sound like a line from a movie stating, "Who can unravel/ The worlds weaving?" Which is used to make a statement saying just what is all this about, the poet seems confused here. The poem ends in a powerful two lines making a statement about the thinness of the children's "greenstick shoulder" in comparison to the poet's "swollen hand" as well as the strong disapproval as the child looks at the poet with a "speaking darkness" Both poems are clear in the fact that it is the young girls weaving and not the boys; this is a "traditional" aspect of the Eastern world. The constant recurrence of the seeming clash between East and West is a big theme in both poems. In "Carpet-Weavers, Morocco" there is a line that says "They watch their flickering knots like television" which hints that these Eastern girls are transfixed by their "knots" as Western children are by television. ...read more.

Conclusion

In "Ispahan Carpet" there is also the "f" sound in "flickering fire". In both poems there is also the slithering "s" sound in words like "sensuous" and "servants of the mosque" the sound makes you think of the slithering, weaving, knotting of the girls at work; this could also have some relation to the Arab pastime of snake charming. In "Ispahan Carpet" there is repeating "b" alliteration in the first stanza this adds to the dark, slow movement of the poem. In contrast "Carpet-Weavers, Morocco" has the accentuated repeating "f" giving the poem a quick flittering feel. These two poems have raised the issues of child labour in a culture where the creation of beautiful objects, the carpets - the end result, justifies the means. However the difference or similarity in these poems is not so much the use of imagery as the differing opinions on whether it is a good and useful experience or not, I believe both poets have achieved their objectives, creating vivid images of the children working and the ultimate values of their sacrifice. ?? ?? ?? ?? Joshua Johnstone L6IB ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Languages section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Languages essays

  1. Poem analysis-Mad girl's lovesong

    The word choice of this poem tends to give the readers an imagery of the end of the world with the entire world drops dead, and hell of fires fade.

  2. Sailing to Byzantium Poetry Analysis

    The birds in the first stanza are referred to as "dying generations", which along with images of the natural word are used to symbolize transience and mortality, highlighting the ephemeral aspect of the world he lives in, thereby contrasting it against the timelessness of Byzantium's magnificence.

  1. A commentary on "THE GREAT GATSBY" by F. Scott Fitzgerald

    This is related to imagery, another literary feature. These images help the reader to get a further understanding of the novel, as the reader can smell, touch, taste, hear and see for himself/herself the situation, object or person being described.

  2. Fasting Feasting by Anita Desai Detailed Study Notes

    in and tries to bring Arun up to live in, to become the "healthy mind, healthy body". Desai exposes a similarity here between Papa's aspirations for prosperity and the American emphasis on the "pursuit of health". So the postcard represents "Arun's own endurance, his survival".

  1. Ispahan carpet analysis

    She also uses onomatopoeic words to emphasize the labor and pain it takes in weaving the carpet. The poem does not follow any rhyme scheme and is written in free verse. The varying length of line signifies the uncontrolled and instantaneous flow of emotions on the sight of such a child labor resulting in "swollen hands".

  2. Compare how the Poet uses Poetic Devices and Imagery to create vivid Descriptions about ...

    Language is used as a metaphor for love: 'my body now a softer rhyme/ to his'. The narrator uses this metaphor to show how in awe she was of the power of Shakespeare's writing. Carol Ann Duffy links the lovers together as it compares the rhyme and it is much softer than his.

  1. Owen's war poetry

    They start of as enthusiastic youth only to see themselves slowly rotten away to death. That is the brutal reality of war that Owen brings to readers. Through this we can see clearly that he is strongly anti-war. Together with depicting the physical pain, Owen also highlights the trauma that

  2. Isfahan Carpet

    As we move on through the poem, more detailed images of the girls working begin to surface, "their unsupported bird-bones, bent like old woman" can then we can only begin to imagine how they are living and the minimal resources they have.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work