There was something gorgeous about Gatsby. Compare and contrast the statement from two characters point of view.

Authors Avatar

Gatineau Zoe        English        17.09.’09

There was something gorgeous about him.

 Compare and contrast this statement from the point of view of two main characters

The title of the novel The Great Gatsby is meant to describe Jay Gatsby, the main character. In the novel a few characters concretely express their thoughts on Gatsby and not all agree that there was something gorgeous about him. The narrator of the novel Nick Carraway feels sympathy towards him and soon becomes one of his closest and only true friends, he agrees with the statement. On the other hand Tom Buchanan a secondary character disagrees with it. As everything else in Jay Gatsby his greatness is a double edged sword and it for oneself to decide whether the statement is true or not.

        Tom Buchanan, Daisy’s husband and father of their child is introduced to Gatsby by Nick and Daisy at one of his parties. It is at this party that he wonders who really Mr Gatsby is, he tells so to Nick:

“Who is this Gatsby anyhow? demanded Tom suddenly. Some big bootlegger? Where’d you hear that I enquired. I didn’t hear it. I imagined it. A lot of these newly rich are just big bootleggers, you know.” (Page 114)

Tom does not understand at first who is Jay Gatsby, he suspects that Mr Gatsby is one of the “nouveau riche”. These are people who did not have a fortune from birth, but gained it from hard work and labour or by being involved in some unclean businesses. Tom’s words are only a reflection of the state of mind of the mind of West people. They despise ‘nouveaux riches’ and they do not consider them as part of the crowd. West country’s crowd think that these newly rich are people without the elegance and taste of the already-wealthy. They are just farmers who by some kind of luck got their selves out of their village and into the “big” world; they do not deserve to be here as it is not in the family tradition. The readers understand that this why Jay Gatsby is forced to lie in order to be from the same social ran as Daisy to be accepted and considered by her. Tom Buchanan also disdains Jay Gatsby that very first evening because he does not understand the purpose of having a party every weekend with unknown faces and an uninvited crowd who would turn the house into a pigsty. Furthermore, there are far too many famous people to be introduced to and everyone is in a slightly drunk state. Tom is determined to lead an investigation on Mr. Gatsby because his intentions and purpose seem vague and suspect. When he discovers the truth his original suspicion is confirmed as Jay Gatsby appears to be a young man from nowhere in North Dakota and from humble parents. He also discovers that Gatsby has never been to Oxford and thus does not have the proper education of an “Oggsford” man. The author clearly shows his despise for him when Tom Buchanan erupts in a mocking tirade on the hottest day of summer, in a hotel room with Jordan, Nick and Daisy present:

Join now!

“Self-control! repeated Tom incredulously. “I suppose the latest thing is to sit back and watch Mr Nobody from Nowhere to make love to your wife. Well if that’s the idea you can count me out...”          (page 137)

Although it is not specified in the text the readers can guess in what tone these words are shouted, in a tone of contempt and almost of disgustingness.  Tom does not find anything gorgeous about Jay Gatsby when the accident happens he almost goes to the point of insulting him of coward because he did not stop to enquire ...

This is a preview of the whole essay