• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Commentary on February the 17th

Extracts from this document...


Krithika Narayan Commentary - February 17th The poem 'February 17th' written by Ted Hughes describes a premature lamb being born dead. It is extremely graphic and its vivid imagery is extremely grotesque, gripping the reader completely. The tone is tense and the poem induces a reaction of disgust and fear from the reader. It also shows a shockingly real image of what birth can be like. The poet uses various literary devices throughout the poem to bring out the graphic images and construct a feeling of dread in the reader's mind. The poet explores the theme of the harsh side of nature and birth, and how new beginnings can go wrong with fatal consequences. The pain of the mother is described vividly. For instance, in the line 'So I kneeled wrestling with her groans' he shows us how painful her labour is with a very auditory sense. The last line 'The body lay born, beside the hacked-off head' is the end of her physical labour and pain, but the beginning of her mental pain. The fruit of her labour is a mutilated body of her child. Only two lines earlier he talks about the 'Parcel of life', and the juxtaposition of the two highlight the contrast between nature's wonders and her cruelty. ...read more.


These images are disturbing and increase the disgust the reader feels. The poet also uses violent, aural verbs to make each image more raw and visceral. For instance, in the lines 'Sliced the lamb's throat-strings...brought the head off // To stare at it's mother', the verb 'sliced' makes the reader cringe because of the violence of the action. Other verbs used are 'hacked' and hauled'. The image of the lamb's head staring back at the mother, with the 'throat-strings' trailing behind it, is not just grotesque but also emotional as it moves the readers by presenting them with the mother's emotional pain of seeing her child's head in front of her. At the end when the lamb comes out, behind him trails 'yolk-yellow, // Parcel of life // In a smoking slither of oils, soups and syrups.' This metaphorically indicates a broken egg, something that could have been a new life and is now a mess of 'oils, soups and syrups'. The alliteration of the last line tends to cause a sense of nausea in the reader. The tone of this poem is harsh and brutal. It portrays brilliantly the emotional and physical pain of stillbirth. The poet only ever refers to the sheep as a 'mother', which makes our relationship with the sheep more intimate. ...read more.


The use of the pronoun 'he' also conveys the narrator's sadness at the lamb's death. He then however switches back to using 'it' as seen in the monosyllabic line 'Till it came'. The short sentence conveys the shock that the poet feels. It seems to have given way suddenly and now it is the end of his and the mother's labour. The narrator's close relationship with the mother is seen in the phrase 'the birth push and the push of my thumb'. The juxtaposition and repetition of the different 'pushes' highlight the closeness of the two creatures. It also shows the narrator is doing all in his capacity to save the mother's life. The poem is a visceral, sometimes disgusting, poem that successfully captures the readers' interest and grips their imaginations. Hughes is blunt and describes his experience just as he experienced it, without any beating about the bush. This is similar to the style he uses in 'Pike' and 'Birth of a Rainbow'. The poem explores themes such as nature's cruelty and human involvement in nature's processes and presents the poet's view on each one. The imagery is dense, graphic and detailed and the themes are clearly visible throughout the poem. Also the narrator's personal involvement further captures the reader. It is a brilliant poem, which embodies Hughes' writing style and manner of expression. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Misc section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Misc essays

  1. ITGS portfolio Loss of employment and privacy issues regarding the rise of online grocery ...

    (See the 50 best websites of 2009.) All of this online shopping has given rise to a new version of one of America's favorite holidays. Cyber Monday was coined in 2005 to represent the boom in online sales that comes the Monday after Black Friday - the day after Thanksgiving and the largest shopping day of the year.

  2. "Night" Commentary

    The syntax of the line is also important as Elie could have chosen to write "quite strange", but instead it is "pretty strange", as this is more intimate and friendly, and that effectively adds humor to their situation. However, in the following line, Elie's father, who's "eyes were veiled", seems

  1. Information Technology in a Global Society - article commentary "What are the security risks ...

    (SC Magazine, 2010) Criteria D: Solutions to Problems Arising from the Issue There are many different way that an organisation could do to help reduce the risk. An option would be to ban personal storage devices from the workplace or have a limit for applications and connectivity allowed on the mobile devices.

  2. English Commentary

    In the line "I was convinced at the start that...she was simply better at inhabiting her body than I was... " the words "at the start" foreshadow and warn us that Gail's current superior position is going to change. This is also exactly what happens where from line 23 and

  1. Langston Hughes

    Langston Hughes also promotes a peaceful and fair solution saying that Democracy will not be awarded "Through compromise and fear" (Line 4). This may be a reflection on how the African-American people were treated and a display of Hughes' protest of acting the same way towards the Caucasian people.

  2. Extenuating Circumstances Commentary - Antjie Krog

    There doesn't seem to be any logical progression in her ideas although each stanza has its own idea. For example, the first stanza which would normally be used to describe the setting is used to dive right into what the poem is about, writing poems.

  1. English A1 HL - Detailed Plan & Commentary on Planting a Sequoia

    * Fourth paragraph talks of the tree and nature like they are child and parent; i.e. nature is raising the tree. Figurative meaning [add quotes] * A lock of hair is supposed to represent the essence of a person and so by burying the lock of hair with the seed,

  2. GCSE Welsh Baccalaureate Completed Diary Pages

    I feel in dismay though due to the vulnerable women and children who come between the disputes and are unable to defend themselves. I also feel disgusted about the avarice of high powered people conducting such terrible crimes. For example, I am aware that Apple themselves source a lot of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work