• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Free Will and Determinism

Extracts from this document...


Core Theme: What is a human being? Analytic Perspective Free will and Determinism Background: the issue of freewill arises in the context of the analytic perspective on the question of what a human being is because of the initial definition of the human by Descartes as made up of immaterial mind and material body. While the body is determined by the laws of physics (e.g. we are determined to fall if we jump off a building) we also experience the sensation of being free to choose in other matters (e.g. we feel free to choose whether to jump off a building). The question has profound implications for ethics: normally the ability to choose freely is a precondition for taking moral responsibility for an action (e.g. isn't there a difference between choosing to jump and being pushed off that building?) Philosophers in the analytic tradition (and farther back in the essentialist tradition) have debated the issue. The following is a summary of the general idea of many of those arguments. Arguments for Determinism 1. Theological argument: based on the notion of 'Predestination'. We are not free because the future is known by an all-knowing God who has already 'created' our future. 2. Metaphysical argument: based on the idea that 'every event must have a cause'. The events which are human actions are not exempted. ...read more.


But you do not have to be in control of any of these things in order to have compatibilist freedom. They do not constrain or compel you, because compatibilist freedom is just a matter of being able to choose and act in the way one prefers or thinks best given how one is. As its name declares, it is compatible with determinism. It is compatible with determinism even though it follows from determinism that every aspect of your character, and everything you will ever do, was already inevitable before you were born. If determinism does not count as a constraint or compulsion, what does? Compatibilists standardly take it that freedom can be limited by such things as imprisonment, by a gun at one's head, or a threat to the life of one's children, or a psychological obsession and so on. It is arguable, however, that compatibilist freedom is something one continues to possess undiminished so long as one can choose or act in any way at all. One continues to possess it in any situation in which one is not actually panicked, or literally compelled to do what one does, in such a way that it is not clear that one can still be said to choose or act at all (as when one presses a button, because one's finger is actually forced down on the button). ...read more.


So compatibilists need to say what the relevant difference is between dogs and ourselves. Many suppose that it is our capacity for self-conscious thought that makes the crucial difference, because it makes it possible for us to be explicitly aware of ourselves as facing choices and engaging in processes of reasoning about what to do. This is not because being self-conscious can somehow liberate one from the facts of determinism: if determinism is true, one is determined to have whatever self-conscious thoughts one has, whatever their complexity. Nevertheless, many are inclined to think that a creature's explicit self-conscious awareness of itself as chooser and agent can constitute it as a free agent in a fundamental way that is unavailable to any unself- conscious agent. Compatibilists can agree with this. They can acknowledge and incorporate the view that self-conscious awareness of oneself as facing choices can give rise to a kind of freedom that is unavailable to unself-conscious agents. They may add that human beings are sharply marked off from dogs by their capacity to act for reasons that they explicitly take to be moral reasons. In general, compatibilism has many variants. According to Harry Frankfurt's version, for example, one has free will if one wants to be moved to action by the motives that do in fact move one to action (Frankfurt 1988 ). On this view, freedom is a matter of having a personality that is harmonious in a certain way. Freedom in this sense is clearly compatible with determinism. (http://www.rep.routledge.com/article/V014SECT1) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Misc section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Misc essays

  1. Free essay

    Situation Ethics

    Evaluating 'Situation Ethics' 1. In 1952, Situational ethics was condemned by Pope Pius XII as he believed that it was 'an individualistic and subjective appeal to the concrete circumstances of the actions to justify decisions in opposition to the natural law or God's revealed will.'

  2. The History & Development of Reflexology

    Even if the individual has no other serious illness, the loss of brain function itself will eventually cause death. Research carried out by William Rossi states that the modern shoe could actually be the only cause of Alzheimer's disease, because he considers it to be the only thing 'capable of

  1. Are Science and Religion Compatible?

    The debate based on this question often centres around certain basic questions regarding such conflicts as whether evolution or creationism is the correct explanation for the formation of animals and plants, or whether the big bang theory or the literal truth of Genesis in the bible is the correct explanation for the formation of the universe.

  2. Communicating with children

    This is much easier for children than listing the process they need to follow and leaving them to it. For example when the carer asked me to organize the children (almost 3 years of age) for playtime outside the classroom, I got the children's attention and gave them the following instructions: "It is time to go outside and play.

  1. Fruit Fly Lab

    Gently tap the vial to knock flies away from the top of the foam stopper. 3. Soak the wand with fly nap solution and gently place it in the vial 5. After the flies stop moving, gently, tap the vial of flies onto a piece of paper Step 3: Sexing and Counting Flies 1.

  2. Extenuating Circumstances Commentary - Antjie Krog

    All of these striking examples of imagery convey her message of the power of writing, how it can have a mind of its own, how it can help express oneself. The overall effect this has on the poem is to evoke appreciation for writing, but also note that it can be uncontrollable.

  1. Comparing and Contrasting Envy and Deception in Shakespeares Much Ado About Nothing and Othello

    , not only has Claudio's mind been poisoned, there is a chance that an underlying suspicion has been reaffirmed. Don John has spotted a weakness in the fact that Claudio answers to Don Pedro and so can not muster the courage to question Don Pedro's motive.

  2. Guterson's Snow Falling on Cedars

    It is an 'eccentric ... sea village, down trodden and mildewed, the boards of its building bleached and weathered, their drainpipes rusted orange'. Battered and run down, the emotions of the community are heightened, thus conveying the raw anguished experienced by the characters: the true essence of humanity.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work