• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Describe and evaluate the experiment as a research methodology.

Extracts from this document...


Describe and evaluate the experiment as a research methodology. The experimental method is one of the most common psychological enquiries used by psychologists. In the experiment a theory generates different hypothesis, or predictions, that are tested by collecting data. It is the only method that investigated the concept of 'cause and effect' by manipulating the independent variable (IV) which affects the dependant variable (DV). However, to enable the experiment to work, all other variables have to be controlled; otherwise confounding variables may occur. A controlled experiment can be replicated, which is a great advantage in psychology, to test previous results. Some disadvantages are the ethics concerned, which can make it difficult to perform the experiment properly. To analyze this method properly we have to look at other methods such as natural experiments, naturalistic observation or correlational studies. The experimental method depends on the manipulation of the independent variable while all others are kept constant, to investigate a causal relationship. The hypothesis predicts this, and data is collected to see if the independent variable (the cause) affected the dependant variable (the effect). ...read more.


However, it is hard to accurately achieve this, since the experiment has to be controlled and confounding variables avoided. For example, in the subway investigation by Piliavin et al, the cause was the appearance of the 'victim' collapsing and the effect was the participant's reaction towards helping the victim. The drunk victim received far less help than the cane victim and demonstrates a causal effect of the appearance towards the behavior Another strength of this method is the ability to replicate a previous experiment. In theory, if the experiment was controlled and had no confounding variables you would be able to repeat it and find the same results. Even though this is extremely hard to do, it is easiest with the experimental. It is much harder to replicate a quasi-experiment for example because the "manipulation of the independent variable is often not in the control of the experimenter" (Eysenck 819). It also does not work in naturalistic experiment because they usually evolve around a naturally-occurring event (for example a natural disaster). So the experimental method proves to be the most suitable out of all other methods for replication. ...read more.


However even laboratory experiments, like the Milgram and the Stanford Prison experiments have been regarded ethically unacceptable (Eysenck 787). In the Milgram experiment the participants were lied to, thinking they were shocking a person up to 450 volts electricity, while it was actually just an actor pretending to feel pain. In the Stanford Prison experiment the participants were mentally, emotionally and physically harmed, even though Zimbardo (who led the experiment) had them sign a consent form and held debriefing sessions. Even though these experiments were debated unethical, they showed us significant insight into human behavior, which could not have been achieved with other methods or hypothesis. Today, psychologists have "become more aware of their social responsibilities towards the individual research participant" (Eysenck 787). Altogether the experimental method relies on a tight control of the variables, and a valid manipulation of the independent variable to investigate the cause and effect, described in the hypothesis. It is difficult to avoid confounding variables that could disrupt the experiment completely and therefore it is also difficult to replicate it accurately. Experimenters also need to follow distinct rules to provide ethically acceptable experiments, which can make it difficult to investigate certain hypothesis. However the experiment is the only method that is closest to providing the most accurate results and is the most commonly among psychologists. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Psychology essays

  1. IA stroop effect

    School handout. * Bower, B. (1992). Brother Stroop's enduring effect - J. Ridley Stroop, experimental psychology. Science News. Volume 141, pages 312 -316. Found at http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Brother+Stroop's+enduring+effect-a012249057. Last updated: unknown. Viewed 19 February 2010. * MacLeod, C. (1998). Training on integrated versus separated Stroop tasks: The progression of interference and facilitation.

  2. An experiment investigating the effect of background music on students ability to recall a ...

    The experiment will go for approximately 10 minutes, and there will be two parts to the experiment. In the first part, a list of 15 words will be displayed on the projector. You will be given one minute to memorize these words in silence.

  1. Psychology Experiment. The study that is being replicated is the first experiment of J.R. ...

    Results Average times of Participants Number of participants Mean time for words printed in colors* Mean time for words printed in black* Difference in seconds 15 15.980 13.705 2.275 *Figures rounded to the nearest thousandth of a second The total number of words to read was 72; 36 for words

  2. IB Revision Psych

    Current Standing of the Learning Perspective See BA49 B. Framework A. Key Concepts 1) Classical Conditioning - Discovered by Pavlov. He was an animal physiologist studying digestion in dogs. - He noticed that the dogs began to salivate at the sight or smell of food, or even at the sight of the person who brought in the food, whereas

  1. An experiment to investigate the effect of categorical organisation on the recall of words ...

    The study will be performed will use Bower's study as a guide but will be giving different words to the subjects. Null (Directional) hypothesis (H�): there will be no statistical difference between the recall of words, by 16-18 year old higher education students shown an organised hierarchy of words.

  2. Ethics In Psychology

    Many of the potential alternatives to animal experimentation, such as computer modelling, are currently not at a functional level at which they could be considered feasible replacements to vivisection. Regardless of whether it is ethical or not, the fact remains that despite potential technological advancements or intellectual progression, abolishing animal

  1. A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier by Ishmael Beah--A Psychological Analysis ...

    During the fifth month of Ishmael?s rehabilitation, Esther informs Ishmael that there is to be a talent show at the center and that he should perform one of his reggae songs for the competition. Ishmael insists that he will perform a Shakespeare monologue, but ends up doing both.

  2. The Effect of Interfering Stimuli on Naming Colours Experiment.

    The Stroop effect is a phenomena involved in attention processes. Attention enables to block out information and perceptions that are not relevant, and focus on the information that is important. The Stroop effect (Stroop, 1935) is a phenomenon that demonstrates how one's reaction time slows down when it has to deal with conflicting stimuli.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work