• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Ib psychology IA

Free essay example:

Two theories of Crowd behaviour

  1. Deindividualisation theory (Festinger)
  2. Collective unconscious theory LeBon (1895)

Deindividualisation theory (Festinger et al. 1952)

In crowd or large group there is a loss of sense of personal identity. We become more anonymous. Control over our own behaviour is weakened and we are less concerned with observing social norms.

In a crowd or large group there is less concern with how our behaviour will be evaluated. There is also less likely to think of the consequences. Our inhibitions are lowered and aggression becomes more likely. One tends to relinquish personal control.

Reasons why deindividualisation leads to aggression

1) Diffusion of responsibility: As an individual we take full responsibility for our actions. As a group responsibility is shared 2) Disinhibition: As an individual we are easily identifiable. Less easily identifiable as a group. Less likely to lead to unpleasant personal consequences. Fear of punishment reduced. Lose our inhibitions - free to behave anti-socially 3) Anonymity: Belonging to a group gives a sense of identity/ belonging. At the same time our personal identity can merge with the group - becoming more anonymous.

Research support for deindividualisation theory

Rehm: Children divided randomly into five a side teams to play handball. One team played in normal clothes – other team played in orange shirts. Those who wore orange shirts played significantly more aggressively than thon those who wore their everyday clothes

Mann ’81 Analysed 21 suicide reports in newspapers. In ten cases identified a ‘baiting' crowd e.g. shouting jump. Baiting more likely to occur at night with a large crowd and when there was some distance between the crowd and the person threatening suicide. (NB This is another example of the archival method which probably made use of content analysis).

Zimbardo 1970: Anonymous lab coat experiment. Woman dressed in white lab-coats and hoods – anonymous. Control wore ordinary clothes and name tags. Similar to Milgram’s study - participants had to shock a victim. Anonymous participants shocked longer (more painfully). Anonymity contributed to aggressive behaviour. Evaluation: Klu Klux Klan effect: Association with KKK may have affected intensity of the shocks given rather than anonymity; Nurses in uniform shocked less in an equivalent experiment; Sample entirely women; Unethical – lacked informed consent and protection from harm.

Research challenging deindividualisation theory

Gergen et al. (1973) Darkened room arousal study. Gergen looked at the effect of anonymity on deindividualisation. Male and female students interact for an hour in an environmental chamber. No rules. Afterwards they leave alone with no interactions.  There were two conditions: lights on; total darkness (anonymous) Lit room condition: participants found the study boring – no hugging! Dark room condition: half hugged 89% intentionally touched reported experience to be sensuous and fun.  Many volunteered again. The conclusion deindividualisation leads to freeing of inhibitions, not necessarily aggression. This is evidence against deindividualisation theory of aggression. In fact it’s an example of anonymity leading to a pro-social act. Note: The study is low in ecological validity, it is artificial and involves a small number of participants.

Evaluation of deindividualisation

Can you think of an example where people act pro-socially in a large group or crowd? E.g. pop concerts, peace rallies, natural disaster, large gatherings for religious festival. Clearly deindividualisation doesn’t always lead to anti-social behaviour. A meta-analysis of 60 studies looking at crowd behaviour and deindividualisation concluded there was insufficient support for the theory. Deindividualisation doesn’t always lead to aggression, in fact it can at times lead to increased pro-social behaviour.

Collective unconscious theory Le Bon

Men undergo a radical transformation in a crowd. Individuals in a crowd lose their conscious individual personalities to the primitive, animalistic spirit of the crowd. Individuals in a crowd descend ‘several rungs in the ladder of civilisation’ showing impulsive, irritable, highly suggestible and overly emotional behaviour and an incapacity to reason

The mechanisms of what happens 1) Anonymity: due to sheer numbers the individuals, the crowd feels a sense of invincible power along with a lack of responsibility. 2) Contagion: crowd behaviour spreads amongst its members like an involuntary disease 3) Suggestibility: the suggestions of crowd members or leaders are accepted uncritically due to loss of conscious personality

The crowd has the following effect upon its members: 1) Homogeneity of personality: all members behave in the same way. 2) Intellectual retardation: Crowds are intellectually inferior to the individuals who compose it, showing rapid shifts of attention and acceptance of ideas in the absence of evidence. 3) Violent action: with a loss of constraint, savage and destructive behaviour is shown. 4) Exaggerated emotionalism: Crowd members become excited and impulsive

Evaluation of theory: 1) Reporting – unscientific based largely on anecdotal evidence 2) LeBon contrasts the irrationality of the crowd with a model of normal isolated people – lone individuals can be just as irrational, stupid and emotional 3) LeBon does not distinguish between types of crowds e.g. often peaceful gathered for the purpose of enjoyment and celebration 4) Explanations of crowds being mobs serves the political purpose of denying crowd action about legitimate concerns. 5) Others challenge theory, suggesting that crowd behaviour is not wild and unruly and does not involve a loss of identity.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Psychology section.

(?)
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related International Baccalaureate Psychology Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related International Baccalaureate Psychology essays

  1. IA stroop effect

    M 15.85 14.47 27.56 21.37 15.16 24.47 12 F 27.25 13.14 26.62 25.93 20.20 26.28 16 M 9.43 9.81 23.25 28.19 9.62 25.72 16 F 10.22 14.03 25.41 25.12 12.13 25.27 16 F 12.03 14.75 22.06 18.28 13.39 20.17 17 M 7.75 8.60 27.03 24.12 8.18 25.58 17 F 8.65

  2. psych ia SL

    on the immediate free recall of concrete and abstract words and replicate the results. The study conducted by Dukes and Bastian used college students as participants, these participants were presented with concrete word lists and abstract word lists, each containing 10 words.

  1. Abu Ghraib Psychology Essay. What do you think you would do in a ...

    must be equivalent in intensity to the pain accompanying serious physical injury such as organ failure, impairment of bodily function, or even death. In Iraq, a team of soldiers were told to shoot anyone that looks like the enemy. In addition to that, a soldier said that everyone here looks like the enemy.

  2. Ethics In Psychology

    Any procedure performed upon an animal can only take place if it can be successfully argued that is scientifically justified, and there are strict regulations in place to ensure that all animal experimentation is necessary.

  1. EE PSYCHOLOGY

    Positive reinforcement can be classified into five categories: consumable, activity, posessional, manipulative and social. Consumable which is the most used and known in animal training include such items as food. Activity reinforcement is letting the animal execute a desired activity such as being allowed to run freely or play.

  2. How Psychology Could Help Reverse the Trend in Obesity

    None of these key points appears to vary from culture to culture (Gary D. Foster, 1994). There are, in fact, many different 'psycho-stereotypes' that draw variously on these theories. Binge eating disorder, emotional eating, food addiction, night eating syndrome and body image dissatisfaction as well as various psychological factors in

  1. Psychology IB Abnormal Notes and Essay Plans

    Depressed moods can lead to cognitive symptoms. 2. Cognitive theorists like Ellis and Beck believe that cognitive distortions and irrational beliefs can lead to depressed or anxious moods. 3. The way that we think of ourselves may be affected by the levels of serotonin and dopamine in our brains or

  2. Psychology IB Abnormality Notes

    Evaluation point: 1. Drug treatments work, which supports the idea of neurotransmission imbalance. Abnormal level of neurotransmitters may not cause depression, According to Burns, there is inadequate evidence to support the idea that this is the cause. Lacasse and Leo agree, stating that the brain is far more complex and

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work