TOK Madame Grier 10/2/2008 Stephanie Gina Chan 12BJ
Theory of Knowledge: 12 Angry Men
Is it an oversimplification to claim that some Ways of Knowing give us facts while others provide interpretations?
We all live in a complex world where we are not sure if anything we know is true. We distinguish knowledge from belief when we are certain of what we believe in. However, in a lot of cases, we believe a fact is a fact because we see that people all around us believe in that fact, or merely because we are used to being told that fact over and over again. But in fact, what we think is a fact now might not be a fact, therefore, I would say that it is an oversimplification to claim that some Ways of Knowing give us facts and others provide interpretations. There are four ways of knowing – language, perception, reason and emotion.
One way of knowing is by communicating with each other through language. We claim to know many facts because we have been told or read of those facts, and language is the main way of knowing what other people know. However useful it is, there are many disadvantages of knowing through language. First, language is vague. For example many words such as “big” and “small” hugely depends on context, therefore you might not have an idea of how big or small an object is through the context. Second, language is ambiguous where one sentence can have many meanings, or a word can have a secondary meaning like “passed away” actually means “dead”. There are also some literary techniques like irony and metaphor that can confuse people from the meaning that it wants to communicate. Therefore, I would say that language can give us facts or interpretations, all based on an individual’s judgment on what to believe. I personally believe that judging through problems like the ambiguity of language would be easier because one would eventually be experienced in a particular language, but other problems with other people persuading you to believe in something is much harder to judge from, because it is not a pure language problem but problems like authority and their manipulation of language to make you believe in them.