• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the Role of Language and Reason in History

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

TOK Essay Title Number 9: Discuss the Role of Language and Reason in History "A nation without an idea of history is like a person without a memory. A victim of amnesia who is lost the remembrance of things past is incapable of acting in the present or of planning for the future" (Fischer on heroesinamerica.org). This quote by David Hackett Fischer is very accurate because it proves that without history nothing has an identity because history defines how a person or place came into existence. It is not only a record of past events and times but it also a way of understanding the present and foreseeing what will happen in the future as it is generally said that history often repeats itself. In this essay, I will be exploring three knowledge issues which are: in what ways do reason and language contribute to the certainty of historical explanations, how far can we talk coherently about a historical method, and to what extent is history an objective discipline? Language is one of the main ways in which we acquire knowledge about the world. It is extremely important in history as the only thing all historical documents have in common is that they are written in a particular language. According to the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, language determines our experience of reality, and we can see and think only what our language allows us to see and think. ...read more.

Middle

The British however did not feel that they were treating the Americans unfairly and merely wanted the colonies to bear the expense of their administration and defense as British were facing a lot of postwar debt (Ibis Communications). This example shows that both countries have their own reasons for their actions and both seem to believe that they are correct. Historical methods comprise of techniques by which historians use primary sources and other evidence to research and then advance further by writing the history of that particular event. Bias plays an important role in this because individual historians interpret the same evidence in their own different ways. Bias is based on many things such as culture, religion, political or social differences, and past experiences (Lagemaat, 309).This is the reason why it is commonly said that no two historians will have identical views on the same event. Proof that historians are influenced by cultural and political factors is shown clearly during the Seven Years War in 1592 when Japan invaded Korea in the hope of conquering over them. Korean historians perceived this event as a tragedy which was not beneficial to Korea at all whereas Japanese historians believed that Japan was able to significantly improve the economic and political status of Korea (Wikimedia Foundation). This is just one example of many which shows both sides of the argument and an outsider can never tell which side is right and which side is wrong. ...read more.

Conclusion

Although this is not entirely true for all historical events one can never be absolutely sure as eye witnesses are not always reliable and evidence can always prove to be false or altered. An example in which history was abused is found in the October Revolution in 1917 in Russia. Historians have found two similar pictures from this event: in the first picture Trotsky is standing in the center of the stage next to Lenin however, later after Trotsky fell from grace and fled into exile he was erased which is clearly shown in the second picture. This has been proven has the two pictures are identical except for this one major difference. This shows how evidence has been tampered with in the past and what a significant impact it has caused on the rest of the world and how they now perceive the October Revolution (Lagemaat, 306). After having discussed the above knowledge issues, it is clear that history is not always reliable yet it is a very important for one to study history since knowledge of the past is vital if we want to make progress in the future. Although interpretations of the same event are confusing they may also be beneficial as it allows people to think of all the possibilities that could have occurred. I would like to conclude with the following quote "we do not live in the past, but the past in us" (Phillips on Primal-Page). This means that even if one tries to ignores history it is not possible as history is inevitable and very important in order to succeed in life. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge essays

  1. TOK History Essay

    uncertainty to the existence of certain historical events that have not been proven through logical reasoning.

  2. Discuss the roles of language and reason in history

    He argued that defining what we mean is totally impossible! Misused words often generate misleading thoughts. George Orwell in his famous dystopian novel 1984 says ?if thought corrupts language, language can also corrupt thoughts7.? The central doctrine of rationalism is that we can discover important truths about reality through the use of reason alone.

  1. TOK: What are the effects of biased language and unsound reasoning on history?

    Validity is very different from truth. Arguments can be fallacious. Reasoning is subject to variations and prejudice is what fools use for reason. It may vary from person to person. Our thinking our reasoning may be opposite to the others?. Reasoning is confined to a person?s cognition, maturity, and experiences.

  2. There are no distinctions between what is true and false, Discuss with relation to ...

    The idea of truth is a hard concept because we cannot certainly say that something is true but merely believe it is because of evidence provided and through the four ways of knowing.

  1. Scholarship should be awarded based on social economic status and not on academic achievement. ...

    Leaders will never lose their track their studies as they know how to balance and juggle all the responsibilities that they have as a student, scholar, son or daughter, and others.

  2. Discuss the roles of language and reason in history

    account of how World War two started and then translate it to English. However, there are always issues in translation that can affect our interpretation of history and make it unclear. A chain of reasoning is no stronger than its weakest link.

  1. Discuss the roles of language and reason in history

    Therefore, since Hitler introduced conscription, it means that he wanted to wage a war. Due to deductive and inductive reasoning by historians, the view that Hitler is bad and Hitler wanted to wage a war is then presented to us.

  2. Astronomy Biography Giordano Bruno

    Bruno found a real patron in Henry Ill and it had much to do with the success of his short career in Paris. It was about this time that one of Bruno's earliest works was published The Shadows of Ideas, which was shortly followed by Art of Memory.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work