• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the roles of language and reason in history.

Extracts from this document...


Discuss the roles of language and reason in history. IB Theory of Knowledge Essay Word Count: 1577 Sean Okundaye Question 9: Discuss the roles of language and reason in history. The study of history is one in which people or communities attempt to understand the nature of humans through the study of events in the past. When we look at historiography or the writings of history, we are looking at the study of historical events that have been seen as relevant and meaningful by historians. So when we study this area of knowledge, we need to think about what affects the way we interpret it, and therefore by association, how it is taught to us. There are various components to the learning and teaching of history and perhaps the two most prominent components are language and reason; two ways of knowing. Language is fundamentally a systematic means of communicating by the use of sounds or conventional symbols. This is in itself linked to reason, which is a rational motive for a belief or action. Indeed language is a powerful tool that can communicate beliefs and facts but also manipulate such facts. ...read more.


Given the heatedness of this debate between the two schools of thought, what we see is evidence of how language influences the way that the German reader would understand the Holocaust and WW2. The way in which German historians on the rightist side of the Historikerstreit present the Holocaust is one in which, whilst never fully justified, was often presented as being understandable. However, the leftist side completely abhorred the events and so this would present a German person with a dilemma. Whom do they choose to believe? The fact that these historians would share a common language with the German people means that there would be little room for linguistic misinterpretation. However, since there may be some bias with the rightist view, perhaps the most logical step would be to use the leftist view of the Holocaust as a stepping stone towards understanding WW2. This is where reason comes in. The German term, "vergangenheitsbew´┐Żltigung" describes the process of dealing with the past, best translated into English to mean "struggle to come to terms with the past"4. This is especially targeted at schools in Germany where they are made to learn repeatedly about different aspects of Nazi Germany from the 5th grade when the students are aged from 10-11 onwards and visit various concentration camps and Holocaust survivors5. ...read more.


The reason behind this is the fact that the British are generally unanimous in their view that they were on the side of the "good" and the Japanese and Germans were "evil". One could then perhaps argue that the reason for this stems from our own interpretation of the relationship between ethics and war, as opposed to the fact that we are British. Language-wise, however, we do not have any unique words associated with these events and so that perhaps is the reason why we are unable to fully comprehend the views of the Japanese, and to a lesser extent, the Germans. However, the British view of WW2 is perhaps one that would be echoed in other societies, be it American or French. Given my investigation, I believe that language and reason both have significant impact on history as it is these ways of knowing that we use to analyse such events. Without language, we simply would not be able to have history as this area of knowledge is something that I believe is the result of language, as well as important events, over many generations. I also believe that reason is part of history because I believe that every individual is able to give their own personal interpretation of events, although this will always be open to possible bias, be it culturally or ideologically. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge essays

  1. TOK History Essay

    The actions of the people of the Middle Ages could have been determined by their emotions and the way the historians have interpreted this information has had a significant impact on the importance of certain events in the Middle Ages.

  2. In what way does the problem of evil lead to atheism?

    be for everybody: "He causes the sun to rise on the evil and the good".

  1. Seven Days: A Brief History. During the week of November 7th to November ...

    it stopped and involved Prince William and having his phone hacked and having the newspaper listen to his phone conversations.4 The newspaper's owner, News Corporation is being investigated for intercepting his voicemails as early as the year 2006. In the United States, the Penn State University coach Joe Paterno has

  2. Discuss the Role of Language and Reason in History

    for the words, untranslatable words, or sometimes a language does not even have a word that another language contains (Lagemaat, 60). This creates a problem because historians around the world interpreting the same document have many different viewpoints and people usually get confused as to who is right and who is wrong.

  1. Discuss the roles of language and reason in history

    the information is correct and this is indeed what had happened in the past. Since the information that we learnt from these textbooks and resources are correct, then it has to be the truth. In other words, we are interpreting that whatever content these textbooks and resources present to us is the truth about the past.

  2. Discuss the roles of language and reason in history

    Many historians wield their imaginative thinking or reason to write history but ?is not memory fallible, evidence ambiguous and prejudice common3?? According to historian Barbara Tuchman, ?Each man is a package of variables impossible to duplicate. His birth, his parents, his siblings, and the variables inherent in all of these,

  1. As an IB student, how has your learning of history and science ...

    wealth, and that a society cannot put up with the stigma of the elopement of a woman. Literature helps us realize that we are not living in The Golden Age of mankind. There is no utopian society today. Patriarchy is still the order of the day, and women are still called the weaker sex.

  2. As an IB student, how has your learning of literature and science contributed to ...

    For example at one time slavery was considered as common during the middle ages. In the ancient culture, birth of twins was considered ominous. An individual suffering from leprosy was considered a sinner, and was ostracized from the society. Literature also tells that this so called deified society can be diabolic to an individual also.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work