• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Reason and Emotion

Extracts from this document...


Theory of Knowledge Prescribed Title #2: ARE REASON AND EMOTION EQUALLY NECESSARY IN JUSTIFYING MORAL DECISIONS? Word Count: 1,557 Moral decisions are presented to us every single day and we are challenged to choose between what our heart tells us is right and what reason is beckoning us to do. Generally, it is reason that makes the better judgment because it has been more thoroughly thought over. But although reason might make the better judgment, it does not mean that it is used more often nor is it a necessary component of moral decision-making. Emotion, on the other hand seems to be the way of knowing that compels us to make hot-headed decisions; meaning that emotion overwhelms us when making spur of the moment decisions that at first do not seem to have any consequences. Nevertheless, which one is the one begging and screaming to be exercised when we are faced with a moral decision? Is it reason or emotion or both? Reason and emotion both play a considerable role in justifying moral decisions in prosaic controversies, but emotion in more situations than others tilts the balance of moral decisions. ...read more.


The use of reason and emotion relies upon that factor. Emotion usually responds faster than reason when a decision is to be made without previous consideration. Imagine a young man who did not reach to his capacity during the years of his education. His lack of knowledge and education resulted in his present financial insecurity and perhaps even future bankruptcy. Through all his unfortunate issues, he manages to meet a wonderful girl who blindly falls in love with him because of his charming bravado and dazzling good looks. Further down the road, he begins planning his proposal to her, and he goes through the huge process of finding the right ring, seeking the girl's parents' permission, but most importantly, asking her at the right time in an exceptionally romantic atmosphere. He is attempting to use emotion to overwhelm any reason that might disqualify him as the one. In most cases, emotion will cause the girl to accept his proposal because it can be overpowering when set in the right mood. But later on, when the initial excitement has died down, it is highly plausible that the girl will use reason to decipher what she had really gotten herself into. ...read more.


Four out of the five male friends I asked about whether reason and emotion are equally necessary in justifying moral decisions answered without missing a beat that reason was more potent in handling decisions. They later admitted that they thought that using emotion as a primary way of justifying moral decisions seemed too "girly". This created yet another bias since every single female I asked decided that emotion is more exercised more prominently when they make decisions. Peers, friends, and family members can strongly influence what and how we think without our awareness. Emotion is inevitable. It is from deep within. Reason is an attempt at logical reasoning behind every action. Emotion cannot be put into words or described. Much like love, joy, and fear; we cannot describe these "feelings" in such a way that others can feel it too. They have to experience it for themselves. When justifying moral decisions, emotion inevitably tilts the balance whether it is desired or not. Although it is important to acknowledge our emotion, good moral decision making involves more than just acting on our intuitions. It is possible to make a moral decision with only emotion involved so that they are not both equally necessary, but reason should be thoughtfully considered with much reasoning and perhaps less emotion. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge essays

  1. Emotion Vs Reason

    In contrast to this, my reasoning told me that this song was definitely not about sadness, however about human nature and evolution. As I pieced all this information together, with recognition to both reason and emotion, I decided that my emotional version carried significantly more meaning, and thus I decided to stick with it.

  2. Free essay

    Are moral values invented or discovered? What importance does this question have for moral ...

    Of course this does not preclude the possibility that what they evolve towards is some kind of objectively correct standard. But I don't think there is any motivation to believe this, given the already cited difficulties of elucidating the strange nature of this objective reality.

  1. Free essay


    This shows that emotional reasons cannot actually help justify a decision one has to use reason too. Even in places where one is not emotionally attached to a person, both, reason and emotion are required to justify a decision. Take the example of law in the area of human sciences.

  2. Are reason and emotion equally necessary in justifying moral decisions?

    be based on reason, as most medical advisers cannot give emotional input into a clients case as it may give false hope to a vulnerable patient. Pro-choice groups believe that a woman should have access to whatever health care she needs and that she should have control over her own body.

  1. Reason and emotions in justifying moral decision

    We, the boats cannot retaliate much to our emotion, which are the tides. Moreover, they are not dependent on cognition, reason or perception. To have an engagement with the people and the world around us requires emotions. We must be able to understand and be able to sympathise with others

  2. Reason and emotion

    I know that after the father of a close friend of mine died of cancer it changed the way I view the information, they weren't simply facts anymore, the emotional contribution helped me understand the real consequences in a deeper level.

  1. Seeing James the Red Engine cry, prompted me to ask whether a machine could ...

    electricity in our brains, making our mental life really a phenomenon of physical brain states which are as determined as the motion of snooker balls on a snooker table - or trains on a train track! In this way we are mindless, non-thinking machines.

  2. Are reason and emotion equally necessary in justifying moral decisions?

    or choosing a strong team optimizing our chances of victory. I thought it through, and my emotional need to win clouded my vision, then I went through a rational process and therefore went with choosing a strong team. The result of the choice derived through reason was a well deserved

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work