• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Thoery of Knowledge Essay

Extracts from this document...


"Different cultures have different truths". "A truth is that which can be accepted universally." What are the implications for knowledge in agreeing with these opposing statements? Jack Tomlinson Theory of Knowledge Word Count: 1300 6/04/09 When first approaching these statements it appears as though they are contradictory, as they seem to convey two conflicting ideas of truth. The first statement relates to the idea of relativism, which simply refers to the belief that what is true is that which is accepted by one�s culture or community, whereas the second statement relates mainly to the idea of absolutism, which refers to an argument that claims that a statement is either completely true, or completely false, leaving nothing in between. The statements are in direct conflict with each other by means that the first leads us to imply that each individual culture has its own set of truths which do not have to be in correlation with other cultures truths, while the second directly contradicts the first by stating that nature of truth allows it to flow through all barriers (including the barrier of culture), making it universally acceptable. The implication for knowledge, if we agree with these conflicting statements, is the realization that cultural beliefs/truths are not automatically equivalent to universal truths and allows for an additional understanding of the ethical and moral decisions which we accept, regardless of our diverse cultural background. ...read more.


One�s cultural background can also influence one�s perception on matters like that of beauty. For example, the perception of beauty in some Ndebele tribes in southern Africa is that a woman stretches her neck my means of using large copper rings. The disproportion that this causes is considered remarkably beautiful in Ndebele culture. This is often viewed in western cultures peculiarly as it does not conform to the cultural truth that western culture was brought up with. In contrast, western culture seems to idolize the "perfectly" proportional body as beautiful. These examples perfectly illustrate that "different cultures have different truths." They first statement therefore illustrates that truth is not necessarily universal and culture-based in reality. The implications for knowledge of agreeing with the first statement are that each culture or the person within a culture obtains varied amounts of knowledge from different truths, or in this case, from their cultural backgrounds. In essence one�s knowledge is often modified, or refined by one�s cultural background and bias. The statement "A truth is that which can be universally accepted", in contrast, presents the idea that truth is a fact that will be accepted by the entirety of humanity, making it an idea that is accepted everywhere, an absolute truth. ...read more.


This is the reason as to why the two statements contradict one another. Thus, a truth that is universally accepted is one that is absolute and isn't as limited as a relativist truth. The fact that the universal truths are accepted by everyone gives us an awareness of reality as it is. Another example is that of the universally accepted concept "Treat others as you want to be treated" This idea tends to be accommodated by humans who live by a concept of morality and conduct, a universal truth so to speak. The implications for knowledge of agreeing with this statement become clear; hardly ever does one have to use objective judgments in the explanation of absolute truths. The lack of bias results in nearly everyone gaining access to clearer, untainted, form of knowledge. The implications for knowledge in these two statements are quite different, the first one providing a more personalized version of knowledge and the second statement conveys the idea of universal consensus. Conclusively, the implication for knowledge, if we are to concur with the two contrasting statements: "Different cultures have different truths" and "Truth is that which can be universally accepted", is the realization that cultural beliefs/truths are not necessarily equivalent to universal truths and allows for a supplementary understanding of the ethical and moral decisions which we acknowledge, regardless of our cultural background. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge essays

  1. Tok essay- context is all

    Another criticism of coherence is that it cannot exclude crazy beliefs, which do not cohere with the population at large. With a little imagination it is easy to twist the truth by sticking to an initial belief which is false.

  2. What is culture?

    In all societies, those who become the mechanism for welcomed change, the innovators, can be seen to achieve high social status. Culture therefore determines the overarching values and attitudes for the group. Food attitudes and beliefs are part of the overall cultural value system, so that food choices, habits and rituals are in themselves symbols of meaning for the group.

  1. Theory of Knowledge Essay on Choices in the World ...

    This is because understanding the Penrose Triangle requires a holistic judgement, only when we consider the "big picture" does it become evident that the shape is not self-consistent when considered as a whole. Each individual corner, however, taken as a self-contained unit, makes perfect sense.

  2. Tok essay 2009

    Por realidad entendemos a todo lo que nos rodea y nos permite existir, dentro de un contexto y fuera del sujeto. Y al mismo tiempo nos es muy dif�cil adquirir un conocimiento certero. Ello as�, debido que resultan totalmente cuestionables las diferentes formas de captar las cosas que nos rodean

  1. Theory of Knowledge Essay

    3 If you look at this picture what do you see? I asked 3 people and all of them came up with a different answer for this question. The answers were: * The grey figure is swimming for his life.

  2. Extended Essay. How do social class and gender affect the pursuit of happiness ...

    Bronte, 24) Before Heathcliff arrived on the manor, she served only Catherine and her brothers. In this time, she grew very close to Catherine. When she seen the relationship between this wild orphan boy change Catherine is, she becomes weary of him and starts to develop a strong displeasure for the boy.

  1. Can we have beliefs or knowledge which are independent of our culture?

    So in that case, for them it is normal to have sexual relations since you become a teenager, rather than the west, where sex is taboo for young people (Ember, 1997). However, the moment when other cultures are accepting knowledge that is independent of our culture, even if it is second hand knowledge, it has a limitation.

  2. Can we have beliefs or knowledge, which are independent of our culture?

    Even music of India is lot different from those of UK or US. A study by me on the cultural impact on the paintings of famous artists suggests the same impact and all these ultimately hamper our knowledge. Almost all categories of art field have a cultural touch that can never be ignored.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work