• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

TOK How do these considerations (of age, identity) play a role in convictions? Are there ever justifications for falsely sentencing a man to death? If not, is it at least understandable?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

´╗┐TOK Summer Homework YouHyun Lee The thin blue line Adams? lawyer said the state didn?t want to convict a young boy with his whole life ahead of him. They were much more willing to convict an older outsider. How do these considerations (of age, identity) play a role in convictions? Are there ever justifications for falsely sentencing a man to death? If not, is it at least understandable? Many countries set age of criminal responsibility at which juveniles become liable to the penalties of law. In the countries that use the death penalty, it is not permitted for a person who was less than 18 years old at the time of the crime although they commit adult enough crimes. On the average, juvenile offenders are sentenced less severely than adults who commit similar crimes because they are considered to be less mature and blameworthy and have greater capacity for reform. In addition, more serious sentences are given to offenders who have little education, low incomes and hold inferior jobs or no jobs than similar offenders who are well educated with good jobs. This means judgment is, to a greater or lesser extent, susceptible to bias. In any cases, however, it cannot be justified to sentence an innocent person to death. ...read more.

Middle

Why do they change? What does this suggest about perception, emotion and reason. How do these three interact in this case? To what extent should or can we trust perception, emotion and reason in the criminal justice system? Should or can we put more emphasis on or more weight on one over the others? According to the initial firefighters? reports, Willingham was so hysterical and Father Monaghan, a policeman chaplain, reported that Willingham was devastated and risked his life to go into the burning house. After Willingham became the prime suspect, their testimony changed. They testified against him, saying that he had not appeared very concerned. Diane Barbee, a neighbor said that he could have gone back to rescue his children and did not, saying that there had not been a lot of smoke. Monaghan said that Willingham was in complete control. This suggests that our perceptions are not entirely determined by what our senses detect. They are also determined by what we expect and what we believe. Perception is dependent upon expectation and emotional states. Therefore, testimony should never be regarded as reliable evidence. Faulty eyewitness testimony is the leading cause of wrongful conviction. Rather than relying on witness testimony, jurors need to try to perceive and understand physical and scientific evidence to make admissible judgment. ...read more.

Conclusion

To what extent and in what role or capacity should or can authority shape and direct the criminal justice system? The criminal justice system exists to deter and prevent crimes. The police, probation, courts and corrections are all part of the criminal justice system. The main role of the criminal justice system is to investigate crimes, to prosecute individuals who violate laws, and to punish offenders. In addition to this, the criminal justice system develops programs designed to rehabilitate a criminal offender. One of the noticeable features of the criminal justice system is that its whole operation depends on the decisions and actions of ordinary citizens. Citizens play many roles in the criminal process. First, citizens play a substantial role in detecting and reporting crime. Police investigation and evidence gathering depend heavily on the citizens as witness and victims of crime. Another role of citizens in the criminal justice system is serving as jurors and participating in court as witness. Citizens also work as volunteers and paid workers in criminal justice agencies and in organizations. In this case, Gilbert played a pivotal role in proving Willingham?s innocence. This shows how important public participation is to deliver justice and increasing public participation and cooperation in the criminal process is necessary to make a fair and effective criminal justice system. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge essays

  1. Art assignment TOK

    Vincent Van Gogh (b) Do you think the famous artist's work is superior to the less famous artists in the same room? If not, whose work is better? Personally when Ifirst see a piece of art, I don't see the artist's name, so I judge based solely on your initial

  2. The knowledge that we value the most is the knowledge for which we can ...

    Strong justifications so far seem to make certain knowledge more reliable than others. However there are also justifications for knowledge that may seem to be strong but can in fact be quite weak. Justifications based on perception are an example.

  1. What are the differences between "I am certain" and "it is certain", and is ...

    have to be alert to the fact that passionate conviction itself cannot be proven. As mentioned above, knowledge can be proven by controlled experiments, and by trying to find results that are maximally independent of place, time, observer or means of observation.

  2. The knowledge that we value the most is the knowledge for which we can ...

    Knowledge causes happiness because of the intelligence level. This causes someone who is happy a lot to save more justifications for the knowledge that makes them happy. This also works for mad individuals because the more angry they gets, the more justifications they choose not to store for it.

  1. Belief System or not?

    There are many branches of Christianity, the two main ones being Catholicism and Protestantism, which are further divided into subgroups. However, common to all Christians is the belief in Christ as a prophet of God. Furthermore, Christian worship follows a clear set of rituals regardless of denomination, rituals that have

  2. Is it easier to have the courage of your convictions or to have the ...

    For instance, I felt that I should keep the stray I found in my yard. I begged my mom to keep it. It had a collar but, I didn't see any 'lost dog' signs so its owner couldn't have cared that much. Therefore, that dog should be claimed my own.

  1. Why punish with the death penalty?

    Feelings like vindictiveness are subjective and neglect the moral connotations which on the other hand are emphasized in ?punishments?. This why throughout history we have come to see inflicting physical voluntary pain, like torture and death, as inacceptable punishments. This is because of what a punishment represents nowadays.

  2. TOK Journal. The film, The Thin Blue Line, tells the story of Randall ...

    Randall Adams was arrested and interrogated. He was not permitted to make a phone call, and his requests for a lawyer were refused. After refusing to sign the initial confession written up b the police, Adams eventually signed a statement saying that he knew David Harris and had been with him on the night in question.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work