• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

TOK May 07/08 topic 2

Extracts from this document...


Are reason and emotion equally necessary in justifying moral decisions? Canic Ng TOK 12 Word count 1346 Topic 2 Mr. Vicente Everyday we make choices, every choice creates an effect in our world, the effects can be good, or can be bad, "every action creates an equal and opposite reaction."1 As observed in nature. We make choices every day, every second of our existence, from walking around, to what words we chose to express. In the making of each choice our minds takes in factors of emotion, along with reasons to justify our decision. Emotions make up whom we are, without emotions we would be nothing more than a machine. Yet we must not be clouded by our emotions, which would make use do unreasonable things. Although the knowledge that is presented in this essay is only from one mind, there is an obvious limitation in knowledge. No matter how hard one might try we can't write out our thoughts without having our own biases in the topic. This is the thought of one person, objections can't be eliminated, there is no verification of this topic, only the verification of the existence this essay brings with it. Which leads to the first issue, no matter how much one might try, our decisions will always be tainted by our emotions. ...read more.


Reasons' approach to life is more logical, less impulsive, and to the point, judging things harshly, like black and white, conversely our emotion would stand in-between to act as a middle ground, like a gray scale. If what was said so far was true then how does one emotionally justify a moral issue, one such as choosing to believe. Belief is a feeling that something is real or true, so our beliefs are based on our feeling, furthermore feelings are an emotion, which then leads us back to square 1. However there are many people which have a religion, with religion based on belief, and in turn is our emotion we then start to develop a way of substituting emotion as if it was reason, making it true if we believe, but if we oppose it, it would be label as false. By tricking itself with reason our mind makes emotion justify morality,. Prior to our action of sitting in front of the TV, we make the choice of going to the TV then planting our big lazy butts on the surface of our choice to watch what you desire. How do we justify our decision? There is no logical reason for watching TV, other than for our pure enjoyment, or perhaps it was for an assignment. ...read more.


If we look at emotion as well as reason we find that they are very similar but yet they are different. Emotion along with reason are both ways of knowing, each as significant as the other. Without the presence of each other our judgments would lack in crucial areas, which helps us, interpret the world around us. If reason were left out in judgment, our unstable emotion would then produce a inconsistent answer, one which there is no limit to, but if all we had was a sense of reason to guide us onto our judgment, without emotion, our judgment would lack the human quality in which it demands, making it nothing more than a calculated answer. This essay believes that it is equally important to regard both reason, as well as emotion to be equally important in the making of each choice to justify our moral decision. Emotions make up whom we are, without emotions we would be nothing more than a machine. Yet we must not be clouded by our emotions, which would make use do irresponsible things. Thus there is reason. Justifying moral decision requires, reason, and emotion, however we must not let our emotion take control of our decision. We have to aware of our moral judgments for it creates a ripple effect in the world around us. Newton's Third Law of Motion1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge essays

  1. Free essay


    A justification of a moral decision does not necessarily mean that it justifies a decision to be taken in the future; one can also justify a decision which was taken in the past. If such type of justification is to be made, one needs enough evidence to support a reason

  2. Art assignment TOK

    Oil on canvas Strong, freehand S and M A111 Abstract Expressionism Contrasting colour Oil on masonite and canvas 3D, different layers XXL XL A112 Realistic Paintings, Abstract. Modern Figurative Art Stand out colour, realistic. Oil on masonite and canvas Undetectable Large.

  1. TOK essay topic 5

    One would never see a child learning through scientific psychology. The stories, nursery rhymes and fairy tales that we are exposed to in the initial stages of our life are definitely involved in forming the fundamental concepts of human life, personality and behavior.

  2. are reason and emotion equally necessary in the justifying a moral decision

    From this example we deduce that in order to do the right thing people can go to any extremes. If something is considered moral, as in this case family honour, then people do anything to enforce it. Like all these theories stated above, a moral decision cannot be solely justified by emotion or reason.

  1. Are reason and emotion equally necessary in justifying moral decisions?

    to better ourselves, to do more to improve our current or past situations.5 Both are needed to balance each other. But Reason cannot be applied without the emotional "feel" of what is true or false, what is right or wrong, what seems better or worse or closer to the ideal solution.

  2. Reason and emotions in justifying moral decision

    Although we would certainly want to take others' welfare into account, it does not seem reasonable to live totally for others. So we need to find a way of balancing our needs with those of other. Utilitarianism allows both altruists and egoists to attempt to maximise someone's utility.

  1. Knowledge and Emotions

    Therefore, it can be seen that emotional response and the level of emotion expressed is dependent upon the importance of the knowledge to the person in question. In addition to valuable knowledge producing certain degrees of emotion, it can also be seen as the motivating force that pushes people to pursue knowledge.

  2. Are Reason and Emotion Equally Neccessary in Justifying Moral Decisions?

    As both women fight over the custody of the child, Solomon declares that the child should be cut in two so that the women may have half each. One woman agrees with the verdict, reasoning that - should the boy be split in half - none should fight over him any longer.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work