• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Camus' Outsider and Solzhenitsyn's One Day

Extracts from this document...


World Literature Assignment #1: ATROCITIES ATTRIBUTED TO UNJUST PUNISHMENT IN CAMUS' OUTSIDER AND SOLZHENITSYN'S ONE DAY By Sharon Pao Word Count: 1,345 K. Lorenz Friday, February 01, 2008 IB English 12 HL The two principle questions revolving around punishment are, "What gives us the moral right to punish anyone when we are imperfect ourselves?" and "What do we hope to accomplish when we punish someone?" Punishment is a penalty imposed for wrongdoing. Injustice is the violation of another's rights or of what is right; lack of justice. Together, unjust punishment can be defined as the imposition of a penalty that greatly exceeds the crime that was committed. This act of punishing unjustly and immorally is prominent in both literatures that were examined. Atrocities attributed to unjust punishment in the short novels, The Outsider by existentialist author, Albert Camus, and One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich by early 20th century author, Alexander Solzhenitsyn, critically challenges human dignity. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the display of unjustified punishment manifested throughout the two novels and how the characters, especially Meursault and Shukhov, adapt to the punishments while retaining a sense of self dignity. Instances of unjust punishment are peppered throughout history during times of war and captivity. It was mainly a method of maintaining power and fear. ...read more.


Not only does Shukhov have to concentrate on avoiding punishment at the hands of the enforcers of the camp's often absurd regulations, but he also has to protect himself from the cold. Solzhenitsyn's constant emphasis and repetition on the biting cold reminds us that Shukhov is not only a political prisoner but a prisoner of nature as well. No one ever considers trying to escape from the camp, for the obvious reason that the intense weather would cause a quick death. "Prisoners had gotten over the wire across these snowdrifts and made a run for it. But it's true they didn't get far" (Solzhenitsyn 58). The combination of the hard camp life and forbidding weather creates the sense that the whole universe is against Shukhov and his fellow inmates - their lives are hindered by both humans and nature. This sense of oppression highlights the anguish of the human condition. The world is inhospitable, and yet it is the fate of humans to carry on, one day at a time. In the Outsider however, it is not the biting cold but the harrowing heat that torments Meursault. He is relentlessly struggling with the calidity nature has bestowed upon him and feels as if "there was no way out". The heat prevents him from acting sensibly which might also contribute to his outward image of seeming indifferent. ...read more.


Shukhov invariably insists on removing his hat, however cold it might be, before eating, to give himself a sense that he is behaving in a civilized manner. He refuses to passively allow anyone to dehumanize him and take his dignity away from him. Meursault as well, preserves his self dignity by collectedly accepting his fate without outward rebellion. Even when committed for something as absurd as being indifferent to the happenings around him, he retains his posture and achieves a level of human dignity that did not seem possible in his undeserved situation. So, "What gives us the moral right to punish anyone when we are imperfect ourselves?" and "What do we hope to accomplish when we punish someone?" We do not have the moral right to punish anyone. Society only does so because they have no alternative choice. Law and order must be established to ensure the peace and harmony of citizens within a precinct. However, it is still possible to discipline criminals without enforcing unjust punishments. Marcus Tullius Cicera, a great roman philosopher said, "Care should be taken that the punishment does not exceed the guilt; and also that some men do not suffer offenses for which others are not even indicted." Punishments should only be implemented when the offender has been proven guilty and when the punishment has been put into perspective with the crime committed. Therefore, punishments should be cautiously enacted and human dignity deeply reflected upon because "an unjust punishment is never forgotten" (Penelope Fitzgerald). ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate World Literature section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate World Literature essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Character development of Shukhov in One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich ...

    3 star(s)

    It shows his concern about his values and human dignity. 5"Then he removed hat from his clean- shaven head- how- ever cold it might be, he could never bring himself to eat with his hat on." He is accommodating to others.

  2. How does Shukhov struggle to preserve his dignity throughout the course of his imprisonment ...

    different paths, inevitably Fetiukov coming out worse off by succumbing to the policies lay down out before him, and corrupting himself to less than human, a scavenger amongst the community in the camp. However, the lack of Fetiukov's dignity is placed in stark contrast to Shukhov's admirable actions.

  1. During the entire novel of The Sorrow of War Kien is on a quest ...

    is worth it, "ignore the warmth and passions among the remnants of this fallen luxurious society of the South." Ultimately, Kien has changed from an innocent optimist youngster to a man who has, witnessed the most horrendous, experienced the extremes which a soldier essentially does in war and felt the grief which has often brought him to reminiscence.

  2. An investigation into the roles of social protocol in One Day in the Life ...

    The injustices that plague Tita throughout the novel are a product of these cultural traditions. From the moment of her birth she is beset by an 'absurd destiny' to be denied marriage until the death of her mother. These rules enforced by Mama Elena are responsible for Tita's frustrations with

  1. The Paradox of the settings: St. Petersburg & the Siberian Prison in Crime & ...

    Just as Raskolnikov shifts between confidence and doubt, he ironically changes his feelings about his living conditions, which renders ambivalence for the reader. As he alters between loathings for his room and ironically feeling comfortable and depressed, his shifting relation with the room reveals the dual nature of his character.

  2. Reading Notes: One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich

    Throughout the novel, Solzhenitsyn shows how strong russian peasants can be when faced with degradation and his ability to adapt to life at the gulag. He has managed to make his presence at the camp a bit more meaningful. This was, I think, meant to give hope to the everyday russian man that nothing was to difficult to get through.

  1. Commentary on a short passage on The Outsider (IB exam 2010)

    His gesture suggests an anti-social behavior. When Meursault reaches the village, he "wanted to see mother straight away." However, he had to meet the warden. In a way, the need of a third-party to get him to see his own mother emphasizes the distant relationship he has had with his mother.

  2. In what ways do the actions of Meursault and Firdaus demonstrate their resistance against ...

    Copyright (c) 2011 Jensen Pon 13E Island School. All rights reserved. A second act of resistance is when Firdaus willingly becomes an prostitute in order to be economically self-sufficient. Firdaus had been aware that her marriage was based on the assumption by her uncle and his wife that Firdaus was

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work