Comparing portrayal of death In The Story of Zhara and Seasons of Migration

Authors Avatar

Compare the portrayal of death in ‘The Story of Zahra’ and ‘Season of Migration to the North’

In both ‘The Story of Zahra’ and ‘Season of Migration to the North’, many characters die as a result of their own actions. Some deaths are ambiguous, like those of the narrator and Mustafa Sa’eed in ‘Season of Migration to the North’, whilst others are more overt – such as the death of Zahra in ‘The Story of Zahra’ and that of Jean Morris. In all these events, characters have chosen death, and it is this self-destructive death that I will be examining.

        Zahra becomes obsessed with the sniper as a result of the events of her life in the ‘Story of Zahra’. When Zahra first learns of the presence of the sniper, she makes a conscious decision to die by purposefully walking down the street which he is targeting. She anticipates ‘only one thing: hearing a bullet and then falling dead’. She does this because, traumatised by her mother taking her on her mother’s illicit assignations with her lover, she had lived her life with great apathy. She later a man to seduce and continues to allow him to use her even once it is clear that he isn’t prepared to marry her. In Africa, she agreed to marry a man she had only just met and didn’t even like. After they separated, back in Beirut and the midst of civil war, she cowered in the house with her mother, waiting ‘to be obliterated’. After escaping the city with her family, she feels compelled to return.

In ‘Season of Migration to the North’, Sa’eed’s widow, Hosna Bint Mahmoud, is forced into marrying Wad Rayyes, an elderly man. Although many of the villagers advise Rayyes not to marry Hosna Bint Mahmoud, everyone in the village, apart from the narrator, supports Rayyes’ right to marry her, against her will. Despite Hosna Bint Mahmoud’s grievances, she remains submissive, causing very little commotion - at least until her tragic death at the end. When Hosna Bint Mahmoud kills Rayyes this is described very graphically and visually: ‘blood covered the mat and the bed and flowed in rivulets across the floor of the room’. The detail of this description shocks the reader, especially as the book has been philosophical peaceful up until this point. Hosna Bint Mahmoud’s body is covered in bites and scratches. Hosna Bint Mahmoud stabbed Wad Rayyes in the groin multiple times, as a woman’s purpose in marriage in this society is to produce children and do as the man wants. It could be said that both Hosna Bint Mahmoud and Wad Rayyes caused their own deaths: Hosna Bint Mahmoud killed both her husband and then herself, falling onto the dagger, in the literal sense, yet Wad Rayyes also played his part. He forced a woman into marrying him who did not wish to do so, and went against the advice of the rest of the village.

Join now!

The pressure on the similarly apathetic Zahra mounts up until she finds that when she wants to do something, she is powerless: after seeing a group of refuges, she wishes desperately to help them, but at the time had only watched ‘like a tourist’. It is at this point – when she realises her apathy – that she becomes scornful of herself, comparing herself to a tourist, and she becomes fixated by death. She walks to where she believes the sniper to be targeting and thinks ‘well here I am. I am about to lose myself forever’. She thinks this ...

This is a preview of the whole essay