• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In Laura Esquivels Like Water for Chocolate, and Ariel Dorfmans Death and the Maiden, both central women characters are aggrieved and both embark on a search for amendment. Though the emotions of inability to love and anger experienced by the charac

Extracts from this document...


The Search for Atonement: Readers' Response Atonement is a stage of recovery every victim looks for. Whether the motive is retribution or placation, the desire for reparation of a wrong exists. In Laura Esquivel's Like Water for Chocolate, and Ariel Dorfman's Death and the Maiden, both central women characters are aggrieved and both embark on a search for amendment. Though the emotions of inability to love and anger experienced by the characters in the two events are fairly similar, Esquivel's choice of diction and character development serves to justify Tita's search for atonement while Dorfman's use of such literary techniques creates the antithesis effect for Paulina. As a result, readers support the actions of Esquivel's character but do not take complete sympathy with that of Dorfman's. In both works, the author starts with a "crime" and then transitions into the theme of atonement. Tita, the youngest daughter of the De La Garza family, is denied marriage to Pedro by Mama Elena and is further hurt when Rosaura marries her true love. ...read more.


She does not have her engage in lengthy external dialogues. Often, it is those around her who are speaking and controlling the conversations in which she does partake. For example, when Tita and Mama Elena are discussing the issue of marriage, Mama Elena controls the exchange when she says "in a tone of final command: 'That's it for today'" (Esquivel 11) while Tita "lowered her head...as her tears struck the table" (Esquivel 11), not having "even the slightest voice in the unknown forces that fated" (Esquivel 11) her. Readers thus see Tita as a constrained, vulnerable and helpless being who is unable to stand up for herself and obtain the desired atonement. Conversely, Dorfman makes Paulina's speech insolent and governing. Paulina's dialogue consists largely of abrupt, bitterly sarcastic sentences replete with crude words where she is often cutting off Gerardo or Roberto's voices and controlling the conversation. In Scene 1 of Act 2, Paulina says several things coated with mockery: "Of course I'm going to listen to you. Haven't I always listened to you?" ...read more.


He has Paulina, on several occasions, begin "to laugh softly but with increasing hysteria" (Dorfman 10), having to be soothed by Gerardo by being called "silly girl, my baby" (Dorfman 11). Also, Dorfman bases her accusations of Roberto on "the way he laughs. Certain phrases that he uses...that voice mixed with saliva" (Dorfman 23) and not on facts such as evidence or facial recognition since she is blindfolded. This insinuates that he sees her indictments as undependable and impulsive. Although the consequences of the situations that the characters go through are similar and the search for atonement is prevalent for both, the generated responses of readers are opposing. Because Esquivel does not have Tita speak her mind and portrays her as subjugated and powerless, readers pity her and wish for her to regain Pedro, thus advocating her need for atonement. Alternatively, Dorfman depicts Paulina as dictatorial and obdurate, compelling readers to condemn her treatment of Roberto and not justify her search for atonement. Authors' employment of literary techniques can bring about the demise or rise of their own characters in readers' eyes. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate World Literature section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate World Literature essays

  1. Setting and its influence on the female characters in Hedda Gabler by Henrik Ibsen, ...

    The second instance of her manipulation is of her Husband, Tesman. Although she does not find him stimulating, he provides the respectability that she requires. In Act Two, Hedda is having an intimate conversation with Lovborg about their past.

  2. Joe-Clarissa-Jed-ENDURING LOVE. Background information about the character details about family, career

    We see how Joe disagrees on some of Keats work, which is more emotional than scientific, which once again shows an opposition between Clarissa's artistic and emotional perspective, and Joe's scientific and rational perspective. These scientific passages emphasize Joe's rational personality and eagerness for sciences in contrast with Clarissa's emotional personality shown with Keats.

  1. Theme of Food and Magical Realism in Like Water for Chocolate

    her own way she too does crave recognition and enjoys being praised for her hard work that she carries out so silently and diligently.

  2. Woman at Point Zero by Nawal el Saadawi and Like Water for Chocolate by ...

    at the beginning of each chapter), which are metaphors for what you can expect throughout the chapter. It is evident that the way Tita produces and presents her food depends on her emotions. When she is joyful, her food is flamboyant and tasteful but when she is upset, her food is dull and sour.

  1. the portrayal of women in lysistrata

    This is a role that has transcended to our time occupying the same priority ever since, and it is this corrupted notion which unnerves Lysistrata deeply. However, Lysistrata's real complaint is that their husbands take them for granted: "Lysistrata: Sorry Calonice but I'm furious.

  2. Importance and influence of the Gun and the Cart in Ariel Dorfmans Death and ...

    choices, in Act 1 Scene 4 when Gerardo tells her to put the gun down as it is preventing any dialogue from taking place, she counters saying that as soon as she puts the gun down "all dialogue will terminate" since Gerardo would use his "strength to win the argument"

  1. The Theme of Truth in The Outsider, A streetcar named desire, Death and the ...

    As we have seen lying is easier than telling the truth, and there are different ways of doing it: (lying for omission, commission, over exaggeration and under exaggeration)[1]. Lying is part of our day to day. Is so simple as omitting a name, a number with an objective, we do

  2. Treatment of escapism in A Street car named desire by Tennessee Williams ...

    In order to further delude herself she has to resort to drinking. ?Suddenly she notices something in a half-opened closet. She springs up and crosses to it, and removes a whiskey bottle. She pours a half tumbler of whiskey and tosses it down.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work