• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In the collection of short stories in Arranged Marriage, the author, Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni, portrays the theme of keeping secrets in two short stories, Affair and Meeting Mrinal.

Extracts from this document...


English Comparison Essay Arranged Marriage: Affair, Meeting Mrinal: Fragile Women Hiding the Truth November 3rd, 2008 In the collection of short stories in Arranged Marriage, the author, Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni, portrays the theme of keeping secrets in two short stories, "Affair" and "Meeting Mrinal". The protagonists in these two stories suffer from keeping secrets, particularly with important people in their lives. In the story "Affair", the protagonist, Abha is not able to confront her good friend, Meena and keeps secrets from her. It is most evident in the story where Abha thinks Meena's secret affair has to do with her husband. However, they resolve their problem by telling the truth. In the other story "Meeting Mrinal", the protagonist, Asha, is not able to be truthful and suffers from it until she decides to tell the truth at the end. Fragile women from the story "Affair" and "Meeting Mrinal" suffer from keeping secrets from other characters until they tell each other the truth. Asha's frailty is shown in her idolization of her friend Mrinal and her need for her friend's acceptance. She creates an ideal picture of her friend who "has the perfect existence - money, freedom, admiration and she doesn't have to worry about pleasing anyone." ...read more.


My nose is broad and honest but by no means elegant, while hers straight and chisel-sharp, looks as through it belonged on an apsara from classical Indian sculpture...I constantly battle the inches that accumulate almost by magic around my hips, while Meena glides through life slim and svelte, eating whatever she wants and wearing designer bikinis." She uses constantly contradicts herself to Meena to show the differences between their appearances and to emphasize Meena's physical beauty. On page 266, Meena says: I was afraid to. I knew you'd be upset. You disapprove of my clothes, even. How could I tell you I'd fallen in love with another man...Perfect at all the things I didn't want to do but knew I should. Like a mother, kind of. I wanted your approval. Needed it. For a long time I told myself, I've got to stay with Srikant. What will Abha say otherwise? to show Abha that she was afraid to tell her the truth and wanted her approval because Abha is like a mother figure to her, by using dictions like afraid, upset, disapprove, mother, and approval. Accordingly, Meena and Asha both seek for approval from their friends. Meena also says to Abha: I couldn't face trying to explain to you- the expression I knew you'd have in your eyes. ...read more.


Like mine is suffocating you. ... We are spiraling towards hate. And hopelessness. That's not what I want for the rest of my lire. Or yours. ... It's better this way, each of us freeing the other before it's too late... so we can start learning, once more, to live. (271) Conversely, Asha who decided to keep secrets attempts suicide in her despair. Parking her car in the garage, she attempts to gas herself with the exhaust. In the end like Abha, Asha accepts help and faces her frailty. She moves forward into a life of truth and self-acceptance instead of false images of perfection. The author, Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni, depicts the themes of fragility in her two protagonists of her two short stories, "Affair" and "Meeting Mrinal." Both characters show their frailty through the act of keeping secrets from important people in their lives. Protagonists in each story try to hide their important aspects in their lives from people who know the most about them. Both characters seek to gain approval from their friends and show their insecurity through envying their friends' apparent perfections. Both protagonists realize that perfection is impossible to attain and gain self-acceptance. Even though they suffer from attempting to gain perfection and acceptance from their friends and keeping secrets, at last, as they all confess the truth, they find happiness and feel relieved. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate World Literature section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate World Literature essays

  1. Nadine Gordimer Comrades commentary. The following extract is from the collection of short stories ...

    in her actions, "the spokesman holds out the emptied sugar-bowl to her.-Please-. She hurries to the kitchen and brings it back refilled". The words ''she hurries'' reflect her desperation to mark an end to the Black people's suffering, but Gordimer suggests that she is not able to eradicate the negative implications of the Apartheid system such as inequality.

  2. William Trevors short stories explore several themes; faded love, hopeless marriage, as well as ...

    A rather eloquent and beautiful looking women who appears to be of Indian extraction, but talks with a cockney accent meets a typical English middle aged man, with greying hair, wrinkled face, and tanned skin. These two central characters Normanton and Iris seem totally out of place against the ancient skyline and surroundings of Isfahan.

  1. The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World by Gabriel Garcia Marquez and The Drowned ...

    later, "at least two hundred of them standing on the giant", "circulating in a ceaseless melee", "straddled the nose", "crawled into one of the nostrils", "covering the arms and legs like a dense flock of gulls sitting on the corpse of a large fish".

  2. These two short stories The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World and A Very ...

    angel, such as the growing of teeth, or the man who almost won the lottery. The people's reaction to his arrival affects the setting greatly- the angel helps the owners of the house experience prosperity, and the other locals experience "miracles".

  1. Two Kinds, a short story by Tan, and Under Pressure, a story by Honore ...

    hopes and hopes that "Nairobi" could be an alternative way of pronouncing "Helsinki." On the other hand, Honore in her description of her tribulations with Queeny describes many different places and items in an attempt to give an illustration to the reader of the various things she did.

  2. The characters and narrative method of the short story "The bottom line and the ...

    Unlike careerist, her next sweetheart wanted a family and children, but she "never fell for baby with him". They also parted. There were a lot of men in her life, and she loved everybody in her way. Going this way we can see the evolution of Avril's love.

  1. Short Questions on Ernest Hemmingway's Short Stories

    For example, in ?Hills Like White Elephant,? readers are presented with vague information at the beginning of the story when a American man and a girl are having a conversation at a train station. Therefore, readers are forced to wonder what these people are discussing about (the American persuading the girl to have abortion)

  2. So Long a Letter, by Mariama Ba, and Song of Lawino, by Okot pBitek, ...

    Oddly, Ramatoulaye decides to stay with Modou because of her good faith. Ramatoulaye often prays to God for her strength as she is deeply troubled by her husband?s neglect. After the sudden death of Modou, Ramatoulaye morns his death for four months and ten days (a Senegalese tradition), and it is at this point where Ramatoulaye discovers her oppression.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work