• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Like Water for chocolate Comparitve essay

Extracts from this document...


Spontaneity vs. Caution: Pedro's Persona Compared to John Brown's Like Water for Chocolate by Laura Esquivel is the story of a girl named Tita who throughout her life has to deal with chaos. Mama Elena prohibits her from marrying the man she loves, Pedro, and instead, her sister Rosaura marries him. However, Pedro's intent is to be close to Tita and they each spend a lifetime trying to get closer and find a way to marry. Later on, John Brown comes into her life and Tita believes she is falling in love with him. John proposes to her and at first Tita accepts but later changes her mind and ends up marrying Pedro. Esquivel uses Pedro's spontaneity to make the book more exciting and unpredictable while she uses John to add an element of stability to Tita's chaotic life. Pedro is a spontaneous character who is constantly changing his mind and jumping from mood to mood. While Tita was cleaning up in a room by the kitchen after John had proposed to her, Pedro came in, surprising Tita. ...read more.


When Tita was turning sixteen, Pedro showed up with his father to ask for Tita's hand in marriage. Mama Elena explained to don Pascual that it was impossible for Tita to marry Pedro "but if you really want Pedro to get married, allow me to suggest my daughter Rosaura, who's just two years older than Tita. She is one hundred percent available, and ready for marriage. . . ." (13). On that day, Pedro agreed to marry Rosaura in a marriage of no love for Rosaura but a great love for Tita. Esquivel intended to create the conflict of the book by using Pedro's spontaneity. His quick decision became one that was regrettable for both Tita and himself. Rosaura and Mama Elena became a barrier between them and they were not able to marry each other until both were dead. On the contrary, John is much more cautious with his actions and takes things much slower. He thinks his actions through thoroughly before making any decisions. When Tita told him she had relations with Pedro while he was gone and lost her virginity, he told her, "I would be delighted to be ...read more.


Under his patient, loving care, she eventually broke her silence as she realized she was free of her chaotic life and for once felt at ease. "She had to find someone who could kindle her desire. Could that someone be John? She was remembering the pleasant sensation that ran through her body when he took her hand in the laboratory. No. She wasn't sure" (118). John had the reliable care that Pedro was unable to give Tita and his stability was what allowed her to recover when she hit rock bottom. Esquivel uses Pedro's spontaneity to create the conflict and make the book more exciting and unpredictable while she uses John Brown's caution, patience, and care to heal Tita and stop the chaos in her life. Pedro was reckless and his unpredictable actions made the reader wonder what would happen next. He was basically the root of Tita's problems along with Mama Elena and was the driving force behind the book's conflict. John, on the other hand, brought stability to Tita's life. The stability he brought her allowed her to finally be with Pedro in the end, the man she truly loved. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate World Literature section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate World Literature essays

  1. How does love and suffering connect the characters and their lives in Allende's HOUSE ...

    from the horror and she would never forget it." Same suffering making Tita silent for some time had played the most important role to find one more character, The Real Tita. The narration 8"But now she preferred silence. There were many things she needed to work out in her mind."

  2. like water for chocolate

    This parallels the setting of the Mexican Revolution growing in intensity. Mexican screenwriter Laura Esquivel's first novel, Like Water For Chocolate, met with unusual success when it was published in 1989. The enthusiasm about the book led to a Spanish-language movie of the same title, which also was immensely popular.

  1. A comparison of the relationship between Gregor and Grete in The Metamorphosis and Tita ...

    This transfer of love shows the ability of the siblings to sympathize and understand each other's feelings. Gertrudis also represents free spirits as she is able to gain freedom from Tita's love. Gertrudis is able to share Tita's feeling of lust strictly through the way that Tita uses her feelings to cook.

  2. A close look at how family honor is wrecked and the lead to struggle ...

    To coincide with the darkness of it all, sex outside of marriage, a tradition that culturally is forbidden to all Spanish families creates more tension between fighting for love and carrying on family honor. Outraged even in death, Mama Elena comes back and scolds Tita for disowning her family name.

  1. Extended Essay

    Nermin, Anna'ya "Senin kisisel olarak sorununun aslinda kadin olmak ya da ekalliyet olmakla dogrudan bir ilgisi olmayabilir. Belki asil sorun senin sevimsiz, aksi ve k�t� ruhlu bir kadin olmanla ilgilidir." (YT, s.281) demek istedigini soyler. Sifatlar yine son derece olumsuzdur ve bu durum �zerine de bir saptamada bulunur Nermin: "Yillar kimi insanlarin bilgisini, g�rg�s�n� degil, �fkesini ve hirsini artirir yalnizca.

  2. Annotations for Seabiscuit by Laura Hillenbrand

    He spent a lot of his time sleeping. Most horses sleep standing up but Seabiscuit slept laying down almost every time possibly because he could not lock his knees. He slept so deeply that the grooms had trouble getting him to stand up. Seabiscuit was easygoing and loved to eat.

  1. The conception of conformity and confinement in 'The sailor who fell from grace with ...

    because she is impounded in Mama Elena?s metaphorical cage. Similarly, Tita is forced work for Mama Elena with infinitesimal rewards just like how a chicken has to provide eggs everyday for their owners. Furthermore, the quotation ?she was covered with pigeon droppings? (p100) lends into the idea of her deprivation as it symbolizes how Tita is in fact ?covered? with oppression.

  2. The question of whether humanity still exists or has faded as a result ...

    Despite every dark and bitter feeling that crossed her mind, she remained loyal. An extraordinary man who deserved to be seen in a worthy light was Pedro Tercero, the lover of Clara?s daughter Blanca. He fought fearlessly for ?justice?, equality of all classes of people.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work