• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Planting a Sequoia, Poetry Commentary

Extracts from this document...


Planting a Sequoia In the poem ?Planting a Sequoia? Dana Gioia writes about her and her brothers planting a tree. This tree is of significance to her as it is planted in memory of her dead son, in a way, as a continuation of his short life. The author uses the weather as a metaphor for the sadness of the day, a physical manifestation of her emotional state creating contrast between the idyllic land of her fathers and the harshness of reality. In the poem she comforts herself with reflection on the fact that he is simply returning to the natural cycle which they will all one day join and that will out last the ephemeral human lives they will live. The author conveys the sadness of the day using the weather as a metaphor for her own mood. She writes how ?The sky above us stayed the dull grey?. The word grey has connotations of blankness and of unfeeling and this impression is cemented with the description as ?dull? suggesting something that may have once been very sharp and poignant but has been worn away. ...read more.


This is first suggested with the care she takes to look after this tree ??laying you into is, carefully packing the soil.? She uses words that have a connotation of tenderness; laying, carefully, as well as the use of multiple commas on the same line making it sound slower and softer. She refers to the tree using the inclusive pronoun ?our? (?when our family is no more??) and yet she refers to her son as ?a first-born son? suggesting that she has transferred the familiarity of her son and attached it to the tree now he is gone. She talks of how ?We will give you what we can- our labour, our soil? and we can imagine her taking care of this tree as she would a child, caring and nourishing, giving it as much as she can. The imagery of the tree, ?a slender shot?? suggest fragility and youth further encouraging that idea of a child. A major theme in the poem is that of the cyclic and transient nature of life. The author sees the trees life as a replacement, a reincarnation almost, of her sons. ...read more.


At the same time as he has moved on from this life to become part of one that will outlast the people that remain part of fleeting human life for a bit longer and even future generations will seem ?young and ephemeral?? un-lasting and fleeting to him. She is comforting herself with the fact that he has become part of something much more stable and steady than her human life and that he has just become part of what is natural. Although the author is filled with sadness at the death of her son she uses the poem as a device to come to terms with this and to comfort herself by presenting to the reader the idea that he is just a part of the same cycle that they are all part of and he is still present if in a different form. The very human emotion of sadness is one we can all understand and is presented to the reader in a subtle yet affecting way with the use of description of physical manifestations of emotions and ideas; the weather mirroring her emotions and the young tree growing from the atoms of the dead son as a symbol of the cyclic nature of life. caitlin bevan ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate World Literature section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate World Literature essays

  1. How to write a commentary

    The first novels that are read in class should be used for practice in prose commentary. Some novelists (Hardy, Dickens, Lawrence, the Bront�s, Cisneros) are excellent for practice; this kind of analysis will also deepen your students' understanding of their works.

  2. Extended essay-The bean trees

    is passed on at the same moment when an unplanned woman appears and leaves her a baby. "Take this baby, she said."7 This is quite ironic since she has been avoiding pregnancy her whole life. Turtle starts off being so still Taylor thought she was dead, "After a while I began to wonder if it was dead.

  1. How does Hughes use different voices to present his ideas about African American experience ...

    Hughes clearly separates and varies the speaker in this poem via the use of italic writing and indentation. For example we see it says 'I can understand - some decent man? Did it ever occur to you son?' Hughes makes it very obvious that the change in speaker this helps

  2. Planting a Sequoia Analysis

    This shows that he wishes to take care of tree as he cannot take care of the child he has lost. He also describes the tree as "a slender shoot against the sunset." This is symbolic of a part of the child surviving despite his early death.

  1. The Second Coming - A Commentary on William Butler Yeats

    best lack all conviction, while the worst / Are full of passionate intensity? - which would seem to be a paradox. Are good people still good if they don?t act in the face of chaos? The question of how to tell good and evil apart ? and whether they can

  2. Racism in African-American Poetry | Poetry Anthology Project

    The main underlying theme ?Africa? is the suffering which the African people have endured in the past. This is evident in many lines of the poem, for example ?brigands ungentled -- icicle bold? and ?took her young daughters - sold her strong sons?.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work