• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The effects of honesty by the protagonist in the outsider and the lack of it by the antagonist in crime and punishment (svidrigailov)?

Extracts from this document...


Rohan Bansal Word Count- 1107 The effects of honesty by the protagonist in the outsider and the lack of it by the antagonist in crime and punishment (svidrigailov)? "The outsider" set in the 1940s in the heat of Algiers is a novel written 80 years after "Crime and Punishment" and has some similarities in the protagonist of "the Outsider" and one of the antagonist from "Crime And Punishment". Meursault an honest man is sent to his death for murder and his brutal honesty in the courtroom. Svidrigailov on the other hand commits suicide after a life spanning many murders and many other crimes. Both characters meet their end even after following completely separate paths and leaves the reader thinking as to what difference lies in honesty or in deceitfulness. Truth is an underlying motif in "The Outsider" as Meursault is shown as being consistently honest and direct. Meursault is seen as being deathly honest who blatantly refuses to lie even when discussing matters in court or on love. Such as when asked by Marie on page 38 as to whether Meursault loves her to which he replies, " I told her it didn't mean anything but that I didn't think so." ...read more.


Svidrigailov's perverted side is on show in part 6 chapter 4 when he blatantly exclaims, "I like all children. I like them very much," laughed Svidriga�lov." This scoundrelly behaviour leaves the reader appalled and reveals his vulgar side. But whereas Luzhin only has an evil side to him svidrigailov alternates between extremes of cruelty and kindness with a mix of honesty. Unlike Meursault who is completely honest Svidrigailov isn't only leaning to one extreme but alternating between honest and deceitful. In part 6 Chapter 5 Svidrigailov tricks Dunia to come to his house and blackmails her into marrying him, revealing his selfish side and how he only thinks for himself. But after the third gunshot he suffers deeply and show that he might still be a good man from inside. The path of honesty and dishonesty are intertwined in the respected books in the sense that both characters meet their demise due to that fault. When meursault is arrested he is asked if he has a lawyer and his response to that is rather telling, " I confessed that I hadn't and inquired as to whether it was absolutely necessary to have one. ...read more.


He only comes into the book in the 4th part and suicide's in the 6th part but he proves to Raskolnikov that the superhuman theory of his unreal and changes his ways in a last attempt to come to terms with what he has done. Meursault on the other hand is sentenced to death partially for his murder but also because of unwillingness to say nothing but the truth. It is interesting to note even though svidrigailov is one of the villains he dies with dignity and his life becomes a meaning when he decides to help a family by giving that 10,000 roubles as his final act. Meursault also reaches some sort of a conclusion and comes to terms with life and is at peace. It is interesting to not that Svidrigailov kills himself of his own accord and he is the deceitful one and the antagonist of the book. Whereas Meursault despair's first at the death sentence and takes some time to finally realise what he faces. In conclusion both the characters are killed due to different reasons but hence indicate that you be truthful about your deed it or try ignoring it for a certain point, but whatever your do you will repay in kind. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate World Literature section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate World Literature essays

  1. The Paradox of the settings: St. Petersburg & the Siberian Prison in Crime & ...

    From its first appearance, Raskolnikov's room is quite horrible and oppressive, yet by the end of the passage, he seems to find it agreeable. Although "a more slovenly and degraded manner of life could hardly have been imagined, it suited Raskolnikov's present mood" (Dostoyevsky).

  2. In Ernest Bucklers The Bars and the Bridge, the protagonist is stuck between adoring ...

    In Ernest Buckler's "The Bars and the Bridge", the protagonist is stuck between adoring and fearing his father, endures the ignorance of the man whose affection he longs for more than anything. The father and son "exchanged almost the same awkward words every time"(Buckler4).

  1. World literature - the outsider

    person today to believe in the light" (Anouilh, 6), the light symbolising Antigone's hope for a new day and Meursault's hope for freedom. The symbol of freedom is expressed through the use of earth in Antigone. Antigone defies Creon's command by covering Polynice's body.

  2. World Literature 1 - Clouds of Discontent in Crime and Punishment(TM) and Siddhartha(TM)

    He blamed such people for his failures. The reader can gauge his extreme sense of hate from the incident at the K--- Boulevard when he addresses a 'coxcomb' as Svidrigailoff, a man aiming to take advantage of the vulnerable. An analysis of the text reveals that Raskolnikov also believed in the 'Superman'9 and that he was part of the echelon.

  1. In the Outsider and the Metamorphosis, the central characters are indicted by the Universal ...

    Gregor finds it hard to adjust to his new condition, and therefore he does not accept it. His belief is that he will one day return to being the breadwinner, and this transformation is a temporary measurement. In the meanwhile, he must work through his physical sentiments, seeking for physical satisfaction.

  2. Camus' Outsider and Solzhenitsyn's One Day

    Shukhov gets into trouble and is threatened with three days in the hole not for any active wrongdoing but simply for being ill. Similarly, Buynovsky, unable to stand the cold, protested that they "have no right to strip men in the cold" (Solzhenitsyn 38), receives ten days in the guardhouse

  1. Adele Ratignolle is portrayed as an antagonist in "The Awakening". How does the narrator ...

    She also kisses Alcee and enjoys his caressing as she wants to satisfy her animal urges.

  2. Analyse the Philosophic Justification of Raskolnikov's Actions in "Crime and Punishment".

    Hence, it austerely violates the utilitarian concept as he does not consider all available options which could have brought about a reduced pain and could have maximized the value generated. Now that it has been established the murder contradicts the action principle in [g]utilitarianism, how to defend value?

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work