The dependent variable, thus measured, was the number of correct placements of country names on the blank map.
Participants
Data was collected from 60 participants in total that carried out different tasks. 20 participants carried out each condition. The participants were selected randomly and they aged 18 years and over. None of the participants was familiar with the hypothesis being tested until the end of the experiment when they were given debriefing. Another possible confaounding variable was whether the participants had any previous knowledge of the African continent, so the questions were asked in order to eliminate that problem.
Materials
A stopwatch accurate to 1/10 th second was used to time 5 minutes that each participant was allowed for each condition and also to time 2 and a half minutes allowe for each participant to perform the task of placing the country names on the blank map.
A consent form was given to each participant before the experiment was performed which each of them had to sign. The consent form contained that the Open University students are conducting an Exploring Psychology Online Project as part of the course requirement. It stated that the duration of the experiment will take no more than half an hour, and that anonimity of the participant is guaranteed as well as their right to withdraw from the research at any time.
After the consent form was signed each participant was given instruction as to what are they requred to do, and the instructions differed according to the condition each participant did.The consent form as well as the Instructions for the participants are attached in the Appendices at the end of the assignement. A map of the African continent was used for the participants to study it and the blank Map of Africa was used for the participants to perform the task. For participants doing condition two questions were prepared and asked while studying the map, these will also placed in the apendix.For condition three a jigsaw (14 pieces) were provided for the participants to put the jigsaw while studying the map.
Procedure
Each participant was approached and asked if they would be prepared to take part in a psychology experiment and if they agreed, they were given the consent form to read and sign it.
The participants who agreed to take part were tested individually. Before explaining what would happen in the experiment the age od the participant was recorded and also questions which showed whether they had any previous knowledge of African continent ( have they ever visited the continent , have they ever had to study the area, at school or college...).
After that was established, each participant was provided with instructions deepending on which condition they performed.
For condition1 each participant was given a map of Africa (which had all country names on) in front of them to study it for five minutes.
For condition2 each participant was given a map of Africa (which had all country names on) in front of them, and they had to answer 10 questions based on Africa while studying the map for five minutes.
For condition3 each participant was was given 14 jigsaw pieces of Africa and a map of Africa (which had all country names on it). They were asked to put the jigsaw pieces together while looking at the map.They were given five minutes to perform this task.
After each condition every participant was asked to perform a simple task of placing country names on a blank map of Africa based on what they have learnt from the previous task. The time allowed for the performance of this task was two and a half minutes.
Each participant was then debriefed and asked if they had any questions regarding the experiment.
The research used the quantitative method approach, collecting data by scoring three points for correctlly placed countries, 1 point for a country one place out and no points for incorrectly placed countries.
RESULTS
The experimental hypothesis tested was the method of learning would have an affect on the level of memory processing. In other words participants doing conditions 2 and 3 would score more than participants doing condition 1.
The results were based on the Independent Variable which was manipulated by the three conditions. The dependent Variable was the score measured for the amount of correct placements of country names. The results of the experiment are shown in Table1 below.
Descriptives
Table1
The results in this table show the mean scores for each condition.
The results were also analysed using ANOVA. Those results are shown in Table 2 below.
ANOVA
Table2
ANOVA shows that the f ratio = F(2.57)=3.519, p=0.036. The effect size n2 = 138,133 equals 0.110. According to these
1256.983
results p value is less than 0.05, so the results are statistically significant. Based on these results it is possible to accept the experimental hypothesis and reject the null hypothesis.
DISCUSSION
As we have predicted, the results of this experiment showed that participants who did condition3 had actually got the highest mean score. In our predicitions we were hoping that our condition2, where participants were asked questions about the map they were studying would also produce the highest scores as those participants should have remeberd more according to the theories put forward by Craik and Lockhart. On the contrary at the end of the experiment we have concluded that the questions provided for condition2 actually distracted the participants and drew the participants concentration away from the actual task of studying the map.
Compared to condition3 condition1 did turn out to be as we have expectedbut compared to condition two it did not since our predicition was that conditions 2 and 3 would score more than condition1.
Confounding variable were minimised as much as possible by reading the same written intructions to all participants and using the same materials when carrying out the conditions, they were also provided with the same maps and the same questions. Abother confounding variable was minimised since all the participants were asked questions about their previous knowledge of the African continent.
We agreed that if this experiment was to be repeated the questions asked in condition2 would need to relate more to the task in order to help the participants and not to distract them, and another thing that would need to be changed would be the instructions read to the participants where we could add that the participants should carry out the task quietly so as to avoid distractions and loosing time by asking questions during the performance.
We all agreed that eventhough some things could be changed in order to improve the experiment, the method we have used was appropriate for the research question, using an objective view and establishing cause and effect from carrying the experiment.
REFERENCES:
-
Craik, F.I.M., & Lockhart, R.S. (1972). Levels of processing. A framework for memory research. Journal of Verbal Learning and Behaviour
-
Lockhart, R.S. and Craik, F.I.M. (1990) Levels of processing:a retrospective commentary on a framework for memory research, Canadian Journal of Psychology, vol.44, pp.87-112
-
Christine P. Dancey and John Reidy, Statistics without Maths for Psychology, second edition, first published 1999, Prentice Hall
-
Graham Pike, Methods booklet 3, The Open University
APPENDIX 1
Explore
Case Processing Summary
Descriptives
ONE
ONE Stem-and-Leaf Plot
Frequency Stem & Leaf
,00 0 .
1,00 0 . 6
2,00 0 . 99
8,00 1 . 00011111
3,00 1 . 233
3,00 1 . 455
2,00 1 . 67
1,00 1 . 9
Stem width: 10
Each leaf: 1 case(s)
APPENDIX 2
Explore
Case Processing Summary
Descriptives
TWO
TWO Stem-and-Leaf Plot
Frequency Stem & Leaf
1,00 0 . 0
9,00 0 . 567788899
5,00 1 . 02333
2,00 1 . 67
3,00 2 . 011
Stem width: 10
Each leaf: 1 case(s)
APPENDIX 3
Explore
Case Processing Summary
Descriptives
THREE
THREE Stem-and-Leaf Plot
Frequency Stem & Leaf
2,00 0 . 99
9,00 1 . 001123444
4,00 1 . 5589
5,00 2 . 00001
Stem width: 10
Each leaf: 1 case(s)
APPENDIX 4
- My name is Drakulic Tijana , and I am currently taking part in DZX222 Exploring Psychology: Online Project with the Open University. As part of that study I am required to conduct a practical assignment.
- The practical assignment will take no more than half an hour, included in this time will be, signing a consent form. instructions, the practical task and a short debrief.
-
If you agree to take part in this practical assignment you will be asked to look at a map of the African continent and remember certain information about it. The information you give will be made anonymous and analysed in my final report.
-
While I am grateful to you for agreeing to take part in this practical assignment you are under no obligation and are free to withdraw at any time.
I understand the conditions above and consent to take part in the study.
Signed: Date:
APPENDIX 5
Instructions for participants
Condition 1:
In a moment I will place a map of Africa in front of you, this will have all the country names on it. What I would like you to do is study the map for 5 minutes, after the 5 minutes are up, I will take the map away. You will then be required to perform a simple task based on what you have learnt from the map. You will be give 2 and a half minutes to do this task.
Do you understand what you have to do?
Condition 2:
In a moment I will place a map of Africa in front of you, this will have all the country names on it. What I would like you to do is answer 10 questions, whilst studying the map, the questions will not all be based on the map, but will be based on Africa, you will have 5 minutes to do this task. You will then be required to perform a simple task based on what you have learnt from the map. You will have 2 and a half minutes to do this task.
Do you understand what you have to do?
Condition 3:
In a moment I will place jigsaw pieces of Africa in front of you and a map of Africa I would like you to put the jigsaw pieces together by looking at the map. You will be given 5 minutes to do this task. You will then be required to perform a simple task based on what you have learnt from the map. You will be given 2 and a half minutes to do this task.
Do you understand what you have to do?
Debriefing:
The memory experiment you have just undertaken is part of my on-line project I am conducting with the Open University. In my project I am studying how well information is processed and whether doing different tasks shows that there are different levels of processing information.
Also no judgements will be made based on your performance, all results will be anonymous and will not be able to be traced back to you and if now after doing the task you want to withdraw, I will destroy your results.
Thank you very much for your co-operation.
APPENDIX 6
QUESTIONS FOR CONDITION2
- What is the capital of South Africa? JOHANNESBURG
(2) Which is the biggest country in Africa? SUDAN
(3) What is the capital of Zimbabwe? HARARE
(4) Which country is bordered by Libya, Niger, Nigeria, Cameroon, Central African Republic and Sudan? CHAD
(5) What is the capital of Egypt? CAIRO
(6) Which is the smallest country? SWAZILAND
(7) What is the capital of Ethiopia? ADDIS ABABA
(8) What countries border Mali? (A) ALGERIA, MAURITANIA, SENEGAL, GUINEA, COTE D'IVOIRE, BURKINA FASO & NIGER.
(9) What is the capital of Burkina Faso? OUAGADOUGOU
(10) What countries border Zimbabwe? ZAMBIA, BOTSWANA, SOUTH AFRICA & MOZAMBIQUE
[2] Craik and Lockhart 1972