• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison/Contrast of L1 and L2 Acquisition.

Extracts from this document...


Comparison/Contrast of L1 and L2 Acquisition In order to be a better language teacher, one must understand how language is acquired. The environment in which an infant learns its first language is usually quite different than how a second or third language is acquired. In this paper we will try to discover the similarities and differences between first language (L1) and second language (L2) acquisition and by doing so, hopefully discover ways to help the student and teacher in improving their respective goals in language education. When comparing/contrasting L1 and L2 acquisition one of the first things we must consider is the age of the learner. By defining the terms 'child' and 'adult' in the broadest senses, Mangubhai (2004) suggests four comparisons, which we can represent in chart form as follows: Child L1 Adult L1 Child L2 Adult L2 The box containing Adult L1 is normally not possible because most all individuals learn their first language in childhood. Only in rare circumstances would you find someone learning L1 as an adult. Such cases may result from children being raised in extreme social isolation (Fromkin, 2003) or the complete loss of memory due a disease or an accident. We are thus left with three types of comparison: 1. First language acquisition in children vs second language acquisition in adults (Type A) 2. First and second language acquisition in children (Type B) 3. ...read more.


I say pronunciation or fluency here because it is controlled by neurological processes resulting in psychomotor responses, whereas other aspects of language acquisition - syntax, morphology and lexicon - are not (Scovel, 1988). Studies by Patkowski (1980) and Johnson and Newport (1989) on Type C group's second language learning ability showed that, of migrants arriving in the United States, the age of arrival was significant. Those who arrived before the age of puberty tended to out perform those who arrived after the age of puberty. This supports Lenneberg's theory. There are many other ways besides lateralization in which the CPH has been debated, in both strong and weak forms. The weak forms suggest that there is a gradual movement from what is possible to what is not possible in language acquisition, as opposed to the very specific ages theorized above. Not all researchers agree that there is a critical age and have backed their belief with examples, of adults who have managed to succeed in areas of SLA, that the CPH argues only children will be successful in. It is not the point of this paper to pursue this. In summary, we can say that the Critical Period Hypothesis suggests that the older the second language learner (SLL) is the more difficult it will be for s/he to acquire a new language, compared to that of a child. ...read more.


Young children are very self-centered. They seem themselves as the center of the world with everything and everyone revolving around them. This view changes as they mature. They begin to become more self-conscious and try to discover their own uniqueness. By the age of puberty, they are aware of who they are and very insecure about how others see them. Thus, applying this to L2 learning, we could assume the pubescent or young adult L2 learner would be uncomfortable with making mistakes. We could apply this to the older adult as well. A result of this insecurity or awareness of others is that the L2 development could be hindered. Very young children, on the other hand, do not have this problem. They see no wrong in anything they do and have no concerns as to how others may perceive them. Summary Observing a child learn a first language with ease and seeing how difficult it is for the average adult to learn a second language, as resulted in much of the research presented in this paper. Many parameters for the comparison/contrast of first and second language acquisition have been looked at. Arguments and hypothesis about each have been presented. Similarities and differences have been observed. Though many points are still debatable, many things have been learned to help us understand how language is acquired and how we, as teachers, might be able to help those acquiring a second language. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Developmental Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Developmental Psychology essays

  1. Discuss, Compare and Contrast Piaget and Vygotsky’s Learning Theories.

    Formal Operational Stage This final stage, according to Piaget, starts at approximately 11 years. The child is now fully decentred and can undertake abstract reasoning and perform logical operations. Once in the final stage of development, students are encouraged to discuss social issues and given the opportunity to explore many hypothetical questions.

  2. Psychological and Sociological Perspectives On Human Development and Behaviour.

    After this break, they all go back to class and continue with their work. At the end of the day, the bell rings and they all go home. At nighttime, they will all do different things. Some will stay in and socialise with their family, they will also watch the television and listen to the news.

  1. Self-Report Measurement of Adult Attachment: An Integrative Overview.

    The correlations in Table 4 will allow experienced attachment researchers to see how their favorite scales fit into our two-dimensional scheme, and hopefully will help novices decide whether or not to use our scales for their particular purposes. Our Avoidance scale correlates highly with several other scales measuring avoidance and discomfort with closeness.

  2. How well does the linguistic theory of Chomsky explain language acquisition?

    Goldin-Meadow and Feldman (1977) studied such a group of congenitally deaf children aged around three and found that the gestural system they developed shared many similarities with spoken language. Firstly, gestures were used in combinations that seemed to possess a grammatical structure, and secondly, the number of gestures the children

  1. Psychology was a branch of philosophy before it broke away into a distinctive discipline ...

    Maslow contended that there were two types of motivation - 1. Deficiency motivation - The importance to decrease physiological tensions such as hunger and thirst. 2. Growth motivation - The importance of satisfaction requirements such as the need to be loved and esteemed.

  2. Universal Grammar In Second Language Acquisition: The nature of interlanguage representation.

    In other words, the input underdetermines the output. Assuming a logical problem of L1 acquisition, people have asked whether the same holds true of L2 (White 1985a; Bley- Vroman 1990). This question remains central - is it the case that L2 learners attain unconscious knowledge (a mental representation)

  1. "Theory affects the work of practitioners in the area of loss to varying degrees

    Although she loved him very much she is angry at him for taking his own life and for leaving her with three small children to raise alone. hat she sees as a selfish acthowever he died suddenly of a heart attack before she could From a psychoanalytic perspectiveThe ambivalent feelings

  2. Compare and contrast the contributions to progressive educational thought of Sigmund Freudand Jean Piaget.

    However Freud differed from Piaget as he was more interested in the effect of others on the individual, and how those others play a role in the integration of the individual into society during its development through Freud's five psychosexual stages.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work