Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7

Discuss the two basic styles of social interaction and the ways they can affect the development and

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

Discuss the two basic styles of social interaction and the ways they can affect the development and From a wide variety of possible styles of social interaction that might inevitably play a role in the development of independence and conformative behaviour in children, Subbotsky (1976) choose two styles which he considered to be particularly relevant to the development of independent and conformative behaviour. The first being an authoritarian style the second a democratic style, of which he wrote; In an authoritarian style of social interaction (ASI) one party has the opportunity of controlling, and in fact does control, the action of another in his or her interests; the other party does not have this possibility. In a democratic style of social interaction (DSI) , both parties have equal rights to control, and indeed do control, each other's actions according to certain common rules or programmes. (1). Subbotsky's decision to choose these two basic styles of social interaction was based on previous experiments he had conducted to determine which styles of interaction enhanced dependency in a child's behaviour. He found that when a child was put in a situation whereby they were allowed to take a leading, teaching, or controlling role in an accompanying adults actions, this was enough to eliminate the child's Global imitative attitude (GIA) towards the adult and to foster a more independent role. Subbotsky, therefore concluded that independent and conformative behaviours in children are a product of the styles of interaction the child is exposed to.

Middle

Whereas, children who were accompanied by the democratic adult partner showed a higher rate of independence than they had displayed in the pretest trials. This results indicates that ASI appears to prompt the development of conformative behaviour whereas DSI fosters independent behaviour. Experiment 3. Subbotsky (1981), decided to undertake further studies to determine whether DSI enhanced independent behaviour, but this time he chose to conduct his studies outside the laboratory and in the children's classroom. These studies were conducted in Moscow, where the prevailing style of teaching is authoritarian. In order to introduce a democratic style of social interaction a break had to be made with the traditional authoritarian style of relationships which existed between the teacher and the pupil and to introduce a democratic style of social interaction within the classroom. This involved two essential changes: (1) an equalisation of the demands made on the respective behaviours of adult and child which both children and educator may equally exercise the functions of model and controller, and (2) the educator's repudiation of social control over the child's acts (rewards and punishments) as much as possible. (3) The purpose of these changes was to make the child feel as if he/she was playing a more equal role in the interaction between the teacher and themselves. To make the child realise that the teacher was not an infallible person, that they too could sometimes make mistakes and require guidance.

Conclusion

By encouraging this type of two way interaction between the child and adult it appeared to enhance the children's confidence, which was further illustrated by their increased independent behaviour. This in turn appeared to make them less inhibited, which might well account for their heightened spontaneous, creative, active involvement in various types of lessons. Despite all the positive effects produced by the democratic style of interaction, it also produced a certain amount of negative results, such as liberation of aggressive tendencies and a lack of discipline displayed in the children's behaviour. The process of introducing a democratic style of interaction into the classroom was also time consuming, labour intensive and emotionally draining for the adults who took part. However, Subbotsky suggested that the disadvantages could be eliminated if a mixed style of social interaction was applied. In a further study using such tactics he found that this was the case. In conclusion, It would seem that a child's social position, reflected in the style of social interaction he or she is permitted to participate in is, to a substantial degree, responsible for the development of either independent or conforming behaviour. An authoritarian style of social interaction promoting GIA and a democratic style of social interaction promoting nonconforming behaviour. In the classroom a democratic style of interaction fosters not only independent behaviour but also seems to heighten children's spontaneous creativity. It appears however that children may benefit most from a mixture of authoritarian and democratic styles of social interaction, because the authoritarian styles seems to reduce some of the negative consequences that arise from applying the democratic style of social interaction alone.

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Social Psychology essays

  1. Use the literature on Social Facilitation to discuss the extent to which task performance ...

    According to Cottrell, it is not the mere presence of others that causes arousal but rather than the expectation that an audience will be judging one's performance. Consequently, if subjects are asked to perform in front of a group of people who are blindfolded, they should show less arousal than

  2. Aggression and violence effect society in a variety of ways.

    Applying this to the Bosnian civil war one can see that the Serbs identified themselves as different to the Croats and the Muslims. Robert Ardrey's 'territorial imperative' (1967) suggests that man is dominated by an instinct for defence or gain of territory, inherited from his animal ancestors.

  1. Explain the importance of team building, the stages in the development of team cohesion ...

    One theorist identifies the categories of attributes of successful teams as falling under individual and relationship issues such as: commitment to the team, improvement of safety, narrowing the discussion, neutralisation of defensiveness, explanation of each perspective, changing of one's behaviour (compromise)

  2. Stigma Theories, Explain the exclusion of stigmatised Person’s from normal social interaction

    Some level of exclusion from social interaction is inevitable not just by the fault of those who create the label and stigma but also by the patients themselves. Goffman concluded from his studies that many institutions rather than reducing deviance actually reinforce it.

  1. Alcohol use in adolescence. By learning and studying what leads young people to ...

    According to a recent study done in Canada on high school and college students 72% of 20-24 year olds reported drinking alcohol regularly. Early twenties was the peak age for frequency and quantity drinking as it tends to decline as adult roles are initiated (Jessor, Donovan, and Costa, 1991).

  2. The Black Box Model.

    Characteristics that influence the Consumer Buying Behavior and the buying behavior of given products. Product Characteristics Affecting Consumer Behavior. Buying Behavior Mobile Phone. Age, Lifestyle, Personality Complex Clothes. Age, Lifestyle, Culture Variety Music System. Age, Lifestyle, Personality Complex A Car.

  1. Skinner's behaviorism and Bandura's cognitive social learning of personality

    Although the observer has no skill, no confidence, and no opportunity to reproduce the observed behavior, the new behavior has been added into the person's protential repertoire in motor reproduction processes.

  2. What do studies of conformity and obedience tell us about the influence of social ...

    In a variation, Asch planted a social supporter into the previously unanimous group who responded correctly. Error rates fell to 5.5%. The supporter provides an independent assessment of reality, which is enough to outweigh the potential informational value of the majority.

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.