• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent do researchers agree on the causes and remediation of developmental dyslexia? How do you think any differences should be resolved?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent do researchers agree on the causes and remediation of developmental dyslexia? How do you think any differences should be resolved? Developmental dyslexia is a specific learning difficulty that primarily affects the acquisition of word reading (and spelling). During early schooling, individuals may display difficulty in acquiring adequate reading skills, reading more slowly or less accurately than expected. The following description of the subject of an early case study of dyslexia captures the challenging paradox faced by the wide variety of researchers of this developmental disorder. "He has always been a bright and intelligent boy...in no way inferior to others of his age. His great difficulty has been...his inability to learn to read...." (Morgan, 1986, cited in Brown, 2003). Why is it that these articulate, intelligent people show such a problem in what seems like one of our most routine skills? Due to this unexpectedness in reading failure and its high incidence in Western populations (between 5% and 15%), dyslexia research has instigated great passion and controversy. Early pioneers in dyslexia research, Morgan, Hinshelwood, and Orton believed that visual problems underlay an apparent 'wordblindness'. Orton (1925) introduced the term 'strephosymbolia' to specify that, although the problem was believed to be primarily visual, it was not one of blindness as such, but one of 'twisted symbols', a difficulty in distinguishing the order of letters. However, around a quarter of a century ago, there was a gradual realisation that problems of language must be, at least in part, responsible for the reading deficits (Vellutino, 1979). This general hypothesis has been refined over the years to provide what is arguably the consensus theoretical belief of most dyslexia researchers, namely that dyslexic children suffer from an early impairment in their phonological skills, and this impairment prevents them from acquiring the word decoding and blending skills that are essential for the acquisition of skilled reading. Following on from this consensus, systematic phonics instruction, as a remediation for dyslexia has become largely popular. ...read more.

Middle

demonstrated that developmental dyslexics had slightly reduced contrast sensitivity at the low spatial frequencies and low luminance levels favoured by the magnocellular system, particularly during flicker. Stein and Walsh (1997), also committed proponents of the visual magnocellular hypothesis and has argued that dyslexic individuals have difficulties with binocular vision. Eden, Vanmeter, Rumsey, Maisog, Woods and Zeffiro (1996) reported a brain-imaging study in which a small sample of dyslexics showed impairments in judging the relative velocity of movement of visual stimuli. In addition they also exhibited abnormal activation in area V5/MT, part of the magnocellular system (Rayner, Foorman, Perfetti, Pesetsky & Seidenberg, 2001). It should be emphasised that these supporters of the magnocellular theory do not dispute the phonological deficit hypothesis. Rather, they challenge that phonological problems are caused by a basic deficiency in hearing sounds, and that a visual deficit might independently contribute to reading problems. Therefore, on the basis of the two alternative approaches discussed so far: the phonological deficit and magnocellular deficit, it can be seen that dyslexia researchers agree that a phonological deficit is a cause of developmental dyslexia. However differences in the exact degree of centrality of the phonological deficit in explaining the reading retardation and about the importance of apparent sensory impairments in the dyslexic population reduce the strength of the consensus and give rise to an alternative magnocellular account of dyslexia. Recently, Roderick Nicolson and his colleagues have criticised that "in spite of extensive research, these approaches have failed to account for the full range of difficulties established for dyslexic children" (Nicolson, Fawcett, Dean, 2001, p.508), specifically the more recently established impairments in balance and motor skills. Initial cognitive level arguments (Nicolson & Fawcett, 1990) emphasised an all-encompassing difficulty in skill automatisation, an inability to become completely fluent in cognitive and motor skills to the extent that they no longer need conscious control. The same researchers have now implicated abnormal function of the cerebellum, a system long known to be responsible for motor skill execution and more recently thought to play a central role in skill automatisation and skills relating to language. ...read more.

Conclusion

route, and the visual (whole word) route respectively (Manis, Seidenberg, Doi, McBride-Chang & Petersen, 1995). It could be then that different dyslexic research, especially concerning phonological, auditory and visual impairments, is studying different types of dyslexics. However more extensive research does need to be carried out regarding the issue of subtypes and the underlying causes of dyslexia. The occurrence of sensory and/or motor disorders more often in the dyslexic than in the non-dyslexic population gives rise to the possibility that dyslexia could be viewed as a general sensorimotor syndrome, as opposed to a specific phonological deficit on the other side of an antagonistic divide. However the prevalence is limited in comparison to that of a deficit in phonological processing. Indeed a recent large scale study (Ramus, Rosen, Dakin, Day, Castellote, White, & Frith, 2003), has found every single dyslexic in their sample to display a phonological deficit, with a third of them seeming to be spared by any concurrent sensory or motor deficit. Another caveat of the proposed sensory and motor disorders is that they seem to have limited consequences on reading skill. The relationship of visual deficits to reading retardation, for example, is hotly debated, especially as visual disorders are frequently accompanied by a phonological deficit. The visual, along with the rest of the sensory and motor hypotheses outlined above are very controversial and overall very different to the largely held phonological deficit. It is therefore unlikely that they will all be able to peacefully co-exist. But until one side of the antagonistic divide decides to give in or are proved wrong it doesn't seem like their will be any long-term resolution. In the meantime based on this current knowledge, Franck Ramus (2003) proposes a viable immediate resolution, that is the characterisation of dyslexia as a specific phonological deficit, optionally accompanied by a sensorimotor syndrome. Consequently whether or not the remediaition of the dyslexic individual will involve additional or alternative interventions to the successful phonics instruction, will depend on the absence or presence of this optional feature. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Clinical Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Clinical Psychology essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Compare and contrast the person-centered approach and cognitive-behavioural approaches to understanding and working with ...

    person centered approach is used for people not achieving in life and feeling very low, as it encourages the client to express their feelings and the meanings of these experiences in more depth, they are allowed the power and the freedom to choose when they speak and the therapist will

  2. Developmental theories that inform social and emotional development

    peers and caregivers, emotional regulation and self development, as regards their self-understanding, self- esteem and self efficacy. In a research study carried out by Haskett & Kistner (1991) in which 3-6-year-old children with a history of physical abuse and a closely matched comparison group of 14 non abused children, all

  1. n this assignment I will look at how I would prepare for and set ...

    McGuiness (2009) states that 'household policies are unlikely to include parts of the home used for business activities'. It will be important to take tax advice from an accountant as to what can be claimed as expenses with regards my private practise and my voluntary work.

  2. This paper analyzes the psychological profile of the character Selena from the movie Dolores ...

    However, gender matching seems to be a more productive form of treatment for female survivors of sexual abuse (Fowler & Wagner, 1993). As such, Selena will be paired with a female counselor. Summary of Selena's Treatment Plan Selena's treatment plan will start with frequent visits that may be reduced as Selena shows signs of progress.

  1. Is Schizophrenia inherited?

    Psychodynamic theories suggest that Schizophrenia results from very negative experiences in early childhood between child and their primary caregiver, when mothers are extremely harsh and withhold love from a child, and hence the child develops not being able to function between reality and non-reality.

  2. Counselling Theory - Good Practise and Ethics

    concerned Increasing personal effectiveness Enhancing the quality of relationships between people Appreciating the variety of human experience and culture Striving for the fair and adequate provision of counselling and psychotherapy servicesâ (BACP Ethical Framework for Good Practice in Counselling & Psychotherapy, 2010, P2)

  1. POSSIBLE CAUSES OF SCHIZOPHRENIA: NATURE VS NURTURE. The causes of schizophrenia have been ...

    families with schizophrenia, is a result of defect in an autosomal gene. According to Heston (1970), defect in a single autosomal gene, which is found on one of the 22 autosomal chromosome pairs, is an explanation for the genetic contribution to schizophrenia.

  2. Theories of Human Behaviour: Psychodynamics, Behaviourism and Cognitive Psychology

    Within the social work and foster care settings, behaviourism provides useful mechanisms for undoing previously-established patterns of expectations and behaviour, such as in connection with child abuse and neglect. By repetitively reinforcing positive experiences and associations, the behaviourist approach can change existing negative patterns and replace them with positive patterns and expectations (Gross, 2010).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work