• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Case analysis - Merloni Elettrodomestici spa: Building for Profit.

Extracts from this document...


College of Management CASE ANALYSIS Merloni Elettrodomestici spa: Building for Profit International Marketing Tuesday May 20, 2003 1. Why is Merloni having problems with profits? Numerous issues are raised when considering the currently profitability of Merloni, as at the timing of the case in 1995. Upon analyzing Exhibit 1 from the case, the following trend in Operating Income (pre-interest expenses) is observed: 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 Total Revenue 785.48 968.03 965.24 1071.41 1115.96 1209.54 Operating Expense 744.08 900.39 891.54 976.97 1017.23 1104.43 Depreciation & Amortization 28.34 37.35 40.04 43.67 44.02 51.19 Operating Income 13.06 30.29 33.66 50.77 54.71 53.92 Percentage Increase (Decrease) 132% 11% 51% 8% -1% Chart 1 So, from a dramatic increase between 1989 and 1990 of 132%, followed by continued positive increases of 11%, 51% and 8% for the years 1991, 1992 and 1993, it can be seen that going into 1994, a 1% decline in Operating Income was experienced. This can best be illustrated by examining the chart below: Chart 2 An initial factor that must be considered when considering profitability is whether operating expenses are increasing at a disproportionate rate as compared to total revenue i.e. whether Merloni has been experiencing a decrease in margins. When analyzing the operating expense ratio, which is a measure of the percentage ratio between operating expense and total revenue, it can be seen that Merloni's expense ratio has actually declined over the period 1990-1994: 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 Expense Ratio (Expense:Revenue) 95% 93% 92% 91% 91% 91% Chart 3 The issue of declining levels of profits does not therefore seem to lie with a relatively disproportionately large increase in operating expense as compared with the increases experienced in total revenues over the period. The home appliance market displays certain fairly unique characteristics that play a very significant role in explaining the declining level of profits being experienced by Merloni at this time. ...read more.


Indeed, the 1995 sales by volume figures tabulated on page 11 of the case show Indesit products accounting for 56% Merloni's volume of sales for that year, although it is noted that overall market share declined by 1%, from 5.8% in 1994 to 4.8% in 1995. This decline is attributed to the struggle being faced by traditional high street retailers and the closure of the electricity utility company stores, along with fierce competition from Zanussi and Hotpoint in the lower priced market segment, and the pulling of Indesit from Curry's stores, one of the Big Three appliance retailers. Merloni indicated that it has slated �20million for product development and productivity in 1995, which represents a significant 18% of the total sales revenue earned in 1994. As can be seen, the various international subsidiaries have faced very different business, marketing and competitive environments, and have responded to these in different ways. The international expansion approaches adopted, either from acquisition of existing companies, or from insertion of an existing product line into a market have resulted in different levels of performance being achieved. What must be noted is that "performance level" must be carefully defined, because while top management may consider a particular marketing strategy to have been highly successful by gaining an increase on overall market share by number of units sold, this may in fact have been at the expense of a reduction in market share by sales revenue either from price reductions, or a shift in product focus to selling more products at lower margin levels. 3. What is your assessment of the matrix that the consultants have provided for the company? Does it present the right solution? Why yes/why not? "The New Brand Multibrand Organization" that the Boston Consulting Group recommended handles the complexity of Merloni's multinational/multiproduct management structure quite comprehensively, leaving just a few logistical questions. It was created to effectively manage and coordinate countries and factories across their three brands: Indesit (a pan-European brand, able to take a dominant piece ...read more.


This may be due to the fact that they haven't yet overstepped their boundaries and acquired too many products/companies and taken on organizations that are beyond their expertise. The interesting aspect of this case is the fact that Merloni was growing (acquiring new products), and at the same time cutting back (consolidating factories and workforce), while making the appropriate changes to product line and positioning for the future. While Merloni has been successful, it is important to note that they did not achieve their current status without any challenges: they still face dilemmas in the United Kingdom and have yet to conquer the U.K. market - challenges still exist for even the most successful international expansion. For the U.K. case, it may have been beneficial to wait until they fully understood the market, and then entered quickly and confidently. The strategy an organization chooses to adopt when attempting to build capability for international expansion is clearly the most significant element in determining the success, or otherwise, of the organization's expansion plans. The decision to enter a country without first establishing business partners, or acquiring an existing operation, must be made extremely carefully, after considerable analyses of all the potential risks and downfalls involved. While this form of international expansion certainly has the highest levels of risk attached to it, it often also is the strategy that will reap the greatest returns for the organization, particularly where a gap in the existing international market can be identified and exploited. All in all, the main takeaways for building international expansion from the perspective of Merloni seem to be: stay within the realm of expertise, maintain the existing supply chain and retail relationships, trim the unnecessary workforce and integrate top management, have a clear depiction of where your products should fit in the marketplace and communicate that vision throughout the organization, and always focus the efforts to satisfy the end consumer. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Marketing section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Marketing essays

  1. Philip Morris - A case analysis

    shows that they still have a pretty clean slate in the international market. 3. The company is very confident within itself that it can defend all the claims against its name and that is always a good sign. Future strategy In 1997 the net earnings for the company was $6.3 billion dollars.

  2. Chapter Notes on Marketing Management by Philip Kotler 10th Edition

    Combined specialized structure. Sales Force Size and compensation Workload approach to establish sales force size - 1. Customers grouped into size classes according to annual sales volumes. 2. Establish for each class desirables call frequencies (no of calls on an account per year)

  1. Market analysis for Trung Nguyen Vietnamese Coffee Company's Expansion into Europe.

    VCA is trying to eliminate the negative effects of dumping and subsidy concerning the imported products into Vietnam. With the penetration of many foreign coffee brands, Trung Nguyen and other Vietnamese coffee enterprise have to confront with the tough competition from the outside.

  2. Honda case

    It is because the amount of personal income affects consumer a lot for their buying behavior. People with lower income will behave quite similarly when making purchase decision in different countries. For examples they will focus on the price and tax of motor vehicles.

  1. Air-Arabia critical analysis

    In addition, the infrastructure system at the airport is upgraded and expanded to cope with the additional demand, while maintaining safety, security, operational and functional requirements. [5] New Airport Dubai World Central International Airport is a colossal new airport under construction near Jebel Ali, South of Dubai, in the United Arab Emirates.

  2. Resource-Based View and the Competitive Positioning of the Organization

    Figure 2 - Business Strategy Matrix - ITS Position (ITS Marketing Plan, 2002) Since then, ITS had implemented more than fifteen (15) banking solutions projects and acquired a great deal of skills and knowledge. ITS got stronger over the years in the following areas: 1.

  1. The South African Breweries (SAB) has been operating since 1895 and holds 98% of ...

    1996 census, with roughly 50% living in urban areas, and 50% in rural areas. The population growth rate is 1.9%, and although this has been declining steadily over the last few years, the total population will continue to increase. The government's Reconstruction and Development Program aim for 2.1% fertility by

  2. Starbucks Complete Analysis

    Via has been put as one of the worst products of 2010 because of the lack of quality. 1. SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS A. GENERAL EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT 1. Technological Trends 1. Wireless communications 1. Environment: Wireless communications have existed since 1909 when wireless calligraphy was invented.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work