• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically compare and contrast 'hard' and 'soft' models of human resource management.

Extracts from this document...


Critically compare and contrast 'hard' and 'soft' models of human resource management. Human resource management (HRM) initially emerged in the US in the 1980's and then extended into the UK. (Morris et al. 2000). It has been described as an evolving set of competing theories (Pinnington and Edwards, 2000) and a group of interrelated policies with an ideological and philosophical underpinning (Guest, 1991). Writers have developed many definitions for HRM; Armstrong (1999) defined it as 'the strategic approach to acquiring, developing, managing, motivating and gaining the commitment of the organisations key resource - the people who work in it and for it' (p 13). Storey (1992) suggested that it is a 'distinctive approach to employment management which seeks to achieve competitive advantage through the strategic deployment of a highly committed and capable workforce, using an integrated array of cultural, structural and personnel techniques' (p 5). There have been many differing views by writers on the subject, as to what exactly HRM is, such as questioning whether it is a practice, a philosophy or a theory (Legge, 1995). In many cases writers are cautious not to describe HRM as a theory, but they do however offer various models to describe approaches to HRM. Some of these approaches are normative (e.g. Legge, 1995), others are theoretical and derived form literature (e.g. Guest, 1989) and others are empirically derived (e.g. Storey, 1992). Although there are a number of models, there has been little success achieving a fully-fledged theory due to complexities in terminology; lack of generalisation; contradictions and failure to provide any predictive capability (Truss, 1999) ...read more.


Storey (1992) stated that "it is human capability and commitment which distinguishes successful organisations...the human resource ought to be nurtured" (p.26). If commitment is to be retained HRM needs to train and develop their employees. This idea is emphasised within the soft model. The need to retain knowledge workers is one of the biggest challenges, which faces organisations today. In America, Ford offered a PC, printer and Internet access to all employees for $5 a month. The idea was that by being able to communicate amongst themselves much more easily, being more able to use the computers at work and becoming more acquainted with the mindset of the e-consumer, that it would make the whole organisation much more customer focused. (Johnson and Scholes, 2002) By training and developing employees there is a potential to create a win-win situation, with employees gaining job security, interesting work and an improved work-life balance, with the best organisations gaining competitive advantage from the best workers (Peter Drucker, 1988, cited in Johnson and Scholes, 2002). Individual development, flexibility, self-fulfilment, high trust, autonomy and adaptability are all aspects that are closely associated with the 'soft' model (Morris et al. 2000). There has been some criticism of these concepts, which the soft model adopts. It has been argued the concepts of commitment, flexibility and quality are somewhat ambiguous and open to debate and interpretation (Purcell, 1993). Flexibility has been noted to come in a number of different forms; it could be to 'express the value of employee upskilling, development and initiative or the numerical and financial flexibility to be achieved by treating labour as a variable cost-to-be-minimised input' (Atkinson, 1984 cited in Legge, 1995). ...read more.


The main assumptions on which the soft approach is based such as flexibility, commitment and quality have been argued by critics to be ambiguous and open to debate. In many instances it is unclear as to what exactly the model is referring to when it uses these concepts. They can take the form of many different meanings and interpretations and if interpreted wrongly can even finish up with a practice, which is hard in approach rather than soft. These three concepts were also viewed by critics as being incompatible and difficult to achieve in practice. This is a major factor that needs to be considered when models are being developed, they may work theoretically but do they work in practice. There are many conflicts and tensions that are evident between these two models such as the soft placing emphasis on self-expression and high trust and the hard model emphasises direction and low trust, this makes it extremely difficult to place the two together in a single model. They both consider strategic integration between business strategies and the HR policies but from conflicting viewpoints. At present the literature is incomplete making it difficult for a single model of HRM to be developed. The flaws in the current models either soft or hard are evident and further work needs to be carried out to clarify exactly what each of the terms within the models is referring to. They're a number of weaknesses within the models and these need to be considered and improved. If there was more clarity within the models then perhaps it would be possible to even take elements that are positive from each to create an overall model or theory, which could be used in practice. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. Compare and contrast two models of HRM, one of which must be the Harvard ...

    consequences would then be dependant on how effective the HR policy and HR outcomes are which in turn would go back to the effect on the stakeholders for example dividends, bonuses, projects and policy changes etc The model has evolved through different takes on the model by different theorists.

  2. Critically discuss the Best Fit approach to strategic human resource management (HRM)

    A good empirical example that supports this statement is 'Call centres' in US telecommunications industry where best fit approach in increasing performance was very effective (Batt & Moynihan, 2004) Differentiation strategy can be profitable if targeted at costumers that are not particularly concerned with price.

  1. The Role Of Human Resource Management. Theories and Case Study of HRM ...

    over time (Robbins et Coulter, 1996 was referenced in Human Resource Management, Amos et al, 2008:3). It is an open system because it does not exist and function in isolation but is influenced by external factors namely political, economic, social, technological, environmental and legal.

  2. To what extent is HRM different from conventional Personnel Management? Is it the same ...

    A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE ABOVE FUNCTIONS Andrews, Y.(1996:13) defines: (i) Planning It is 'an activity that concerns itself with the proposals of the future, with the evaluation of alternative proposals, and with the methods by which the proposals may be achieved". In other words, the main objective of planning is to plan in advance for the availability of personnel and to have personnel ready should the demand arise.

  1. HRM best practise case study. Research into HRM at a branch of Barclays ...

    This is also seen as a way for employees to offer their ideas within an open management culture (Marchington & Wilkinson 2002). Pfeffer (1998) argues that 'employee ownership, effectively implemented, can align the interests of employees with those of shareholders by making employees shareholders too'.

  2. Human Resource Management: Development, Activities, Planning and Recruitment

    Recommended actions:- Identify appropriate policies, procedures and practices in respect of * Career pathing * Performance appraisals * Employee development and learning * Reward Management (compensation and benefits) * Promotions and job assignments * Separation Assessing and sustaining organisational competence and performance Finally, few organizations effectively measure how well their different inputs affect performance.

  1. Human resource management - Microsoft problems and recommendatins

    Such a system will concentrate on developing the good performers as well as provide training to the average performers. Also the employees who have got low ranks will not be able to prove that the system is producing discriminatory scores on the basis of caste, gender or age as they are being ranked on absolute basis.

  2. Cape Breton Wallcoverings - HRM analysis

    A rather large issue is also the fact that the supervisors themselves were not able to use the latest cutting edge machinery and had no knowledge or experience on how to conduct effective training. Rather they provided an example and showed ?on-the-job? how to do things for employers, which incidentally lowers the effectiveness of training provided.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work