• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically evaluate the notion of scientific management. Is it still a relevant concept for understanding contemporary work organisations?

Extracts from this document...


Critically evaluate the notion of scientific management. Is it still a relevant concept for understanding contemporary work organisations? Frederick W. Taylor invented the theory of scientific management in the late nineteenth century. The theory refers to the attempt to make business decisions on the basis of data that is researched and tested quantitatively. It was based on the idea that in order to raise, and secure, a high level of output it was necessary to determine what levels of performance were physically possible, and to link these to pay (Kelly, 1982). Taylor argued that the principal objective of management should be to secure the maximum prosperity for the employer, coupled with the maximum prosperity for each employee (1911). Scientific management was a replacement for "rule of thumb" management practice. This generally consisted of guesswork and was highly inaccurate and inefficient. Taylor's model was therefore established to make management and, to an extent, industry more proficient and logical by substituting science for rule of thumb. He proposed that the application of the methods of science be brought to the arena of industry. In particular, Taylor proposed to measure what workmen actually did, according to times taken, and to develop on that basis the 'one best way of working' (1911). By means of quantitative methods, Taylor managed to improve accuracy and successfully contributed to determining measurement of employee output. ...read more.


Workers are driven by financial motivation; being given a consolation of high wages while employers maintain control over the workforce. The antithesis of scientific management is the human relations movement established by Elton Mayo. The model is based on the research undertaken by Mayo at the Hawthorne electrical components factory between 1927 and 1932. Mayo followed Taylor's methods and was attempting to measure the impact on productivity of improving the lighting conditions within the factory. He followed Taylor's scientific principles by testing the changes against a control, a section of the factory with unchanged lighting. Although productivity rose where the lighting was improved, Mayo was surprised to find a similar benefit where no physical changes had taken place. This led him to conduct further experiments, which cast doubts on Taylor's assumptions about the importance of money in motivation (Marcouse, 1996). Mayo's work brought forward an alternative to Taylor's methods of controlling the workforce; studies suggested that scientific management could not explain key aspects of people's behaviour at work, specifically within work groups. Instead Mayo found that employees whose social needs were being fulfilled produced above average levels of output, as it acted as a source of empowerment. There are many benefits of the human relations movement. It suggests a company should organise the social needs of the workforce and stresses that the role of management is to provide organisational environments in which employers can fulfil the social needs of their employees thus encouraging employees' desire for co-operative activity (Fincham & Rhodes, 1999). ...read more.


In his research Ritzer asserts that the business principles pioneered by McDonalds are increasingly dominating other industries and activities (Fincham & Rhodes, 1999). The underlying theme of his work is that particular aspects of scientific management have been adapted to contemporary business organisations in order to help management find the most cost effective and rational production technique thus leading to an increase in productivity. Tenets that are taken from Taylor's model include the division of labour, where there is a split between planning and execution, specialisation, when workers are highly efficient in their specified task, and time and motion studies, which includes timing the job in order to find the most efficient method. Despite the adopted principles from scientific management, McDonaldisation also contains aspects of the human relations movement. For example, if output is above average the employee responsible will usually be praised and singled out. By doing so, management fulfils their social and psychological needs. This can affect the culture of an organisation as it means that employees are motivated by self-actualisation and not exclusively by financial incentives. The above example proves that the theory of scientific management is compatible in understanding contemporary work organisations. Taylor's recommendations have become standard practice around the world and have certainly been adopted throughout the manufacturing industry and increasingly in the services sector. Taylor himself prophesised "that these principles are certain to come into general use practically throughout the civilised world, sooner or later... and the sooner they come the better for all the people" (1911). ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. Human Resource Management: Development, Activities, Planning and Recruitment

    in consultation with the postholder * An indication that the postholder will carry out any other duties as are within the scope, spirit and purpose of the job as requested by the line manager or Head of Department/Division * A statement that the postholder will actively follow UCL policies including

  2. Context of Employee Relations and Industrial Conflict

    contract' with the trade unions which incorporated an agreement that the Trade Union Congress (TUC) would support the introduction of a number of positive union rights. These included a statutory recognition procedure and in effect meant that the unions expressed their commitment to legal enforcement as a means of restricting management's prerogatives.


    Three respondents had no formal experience of performance appraisal prior to Passenger Focus. 4.4.2 Purpose of performance appraisal The researcher attempted to understand what respondents considered to be the key purpose of performance appraisal. The table below is a summary of the reasons they offered .

  2. Context of Employee Relations and Industrial Conflict

    In order to help UK businesses to compete effectively, the CBI works with carious other agencies: * UK Government * International Legislators * Policy Makers On-ground support is available to members through the CBI network of offices in the UK, Beijing, Brussels and Washington. Appendix 6 shows a CBI Campaign.

  1. The purpose of this exercise is to introduce the relationship of selecting, evaluating, building ...

    Much of this frontline information is available to the general public, with some password-protected areas of linked resources. Newsletters and financial information geared towards PWC's membership are also hyperlinked on-site. This, coupled with employment listings from various construction-based organizations, offers the membership both personal growth and professional benefit.

  2. Balanced Scorecard for Telecom Industry

    the profit; and a business environment which would attract investors and thus contribute to the FDI flowing in the country, and eventually landing in the GDP of Pakistan. Exhibit 5 shows that the total FDI flowing into the telecom sector; the highest has been retained by the Cellular Sector, as compared to the other sectors in the telecom industry.

  1. Reward Management, Monitoring Performance and Exit Rights & Procedures

    There was a steady improvement in productivity throughout all the changes, even for instance when the lighting intensity was raised in imperceptible stages over a long period to a very bright intensity and then gradually reduced to that of a moonlit night.

  2. What are the potential causes of stress one might encounter at work? With reference ...

    There is Type A and Type B people. The most extreme Type A people will have a desire for recognition and promotion, they will be very competitive, they will tend to be involved in various activities involving deadlines, and they will also have high levels of mental alertness among others.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work