Customer Relationship Management: Tennyson Case Study

Authors Avatar

Introduction

This case study is based on Tennyson Ltd, which is a UK registered tour operator, and has trading names such as ‘Visit Asia’ and ‘Visit Vietnam’.  Tennyson Ltd is also a member of the Association of British Travel Agents (ABTA) and the Pacific Association of Travel Agents (PATA). Tennyson Ltd is in an alliance with well-regarded tour operators, which are both publicly and privately owned (Visit Asia, 2008). They operate in the busiest areas in both central and Greater London, such as Colliers Wood, Fulham and Hammersmith. A wide range of activities including skiing, snowboarding, sailing, yachting, diving, mountain biking and walking are offered.

Tennyson Ski merged with Merryweather Sailing in 2002. Merryweather Sailing, which is another tour operator, targets a different group of customers such as novice and experienced sailors.  Their hotels were located near water sports locations, which were a considerable distance away from the heavily commercialised holiday centres and were staffed entirely by Tennyson’s employees. However, according to the case study, the ratio of ski representatives to clients is 1:30, which shows a poor indication of good customer relationship.  

Despite CRM’s importance as a business approach, there is no concrete definition of relationship marketing at present. However, (Parvatiyar and Sheth, 2001) defined relationship marketing as a method of acquiring, retaining and liaising with targeted customers to provide better value for both the organisation and the customers. The combination of marketing, sales and customer service and the distribution elements of the organisation in an integrated manner enable higher efficiencies and improved effectiveness, which lead to better value for the customers.  

CRM evolved from direct response marketing, with emphasis placed on the building of long term relationships with customers rather than on individual transactions.  Relationship marketing involves an understanding of customers’ needs and wants through their life cycles, and the provision of a range of suitable products and services.

The problem with the company is that Tennyson Ski, which is a part of Tennyson Ltd, is not CRM oriented. However, this is vital for the organisation in order to retain competitive advantage in the tourism industry. CRM is also key to the retention of Merryweather Sailing customers.  According to Payne et al (1999) the managers and employees of an organisation is the most important single influence in ensuring the future success of the organisation.  However, Tennyson Ltd did not acknowledge this as there are significant staff shortages, with a ski representative to client ratio of 1:30 in Tennyson Ski. This result in the neglect of customers, and therefore customers would perceive that they are not being adequately attended to.  Lack of awareness in the market environment especially in the ski market and there was no clear strategies used in creating and maintaining a good relationship with their customers is also another problem for Tennyson Ltd.

Transactional marketing, which is dominant in Tennyson Ski, is an outdated approach. There is an urgent need to change strategies with a movement towards Relationship Marketing.

This report explains Tennyson’s potential for relationship marketing strategy, their attempts at building relationship market and what strategies can be adopted in order to improve their relationship marketing.

1.1 Features of Tennyson’s business

Merryweather Sailing

Merryweather Sailing has been in the tourism industry for a significantly longer period of time than Tennyson Ski. It therefore has greater control due to its knowledge of the entire holiday experience and a greater knowledge of consumer markets due to their belief that the key to success lies in the marketing culture that flows between the management and staff and from the staff to customers. This in turn feeds back positive attitude and knowledge back to the company, enabling it to refine its policy. Merryweather Sailing, which is a specialist tour operator, is responsible for the ‘hot’ holiday experience.

Tennyson Ski

Tennyson Ski however, did not have the same level of control over their holiday experience, with a distinct lack of customer focus. This is highlighted by the fact that the ratio of ski representatives to clients is only 1:30, compared to the significantly higher ratio of 1:8 for Merryweather Ski. The customer profile is such that a large majority of skiing and snowboarding holidays are booked at the last minute, with much of the tourist market being potentially classified as mass market tourism.

1.2 The potential for RM in Tennyson

Relationship building, which is vital for customer loyalty, recognises that multiple market domains can directly or indirectly affect a business’s ability to win or retain profitable customers. These other markets include suppliers, employees, influencers, distributors and alliance partners. (Christopher et al. 2002:5)

The main objective of marketing activity is to build relationship with customer and retain them.  

Companies that are choosing to adopt a strategy of ‘customer intimacy’ will need to focus on developing a close and customised relationship with their customers.  This depends on identifying those customers or segments that are interested in having a relationship with the company and how beneficial it will be for both parties.  Such companies tend to focus on building relationship with existing customers with the greatest potential for growth and profitability (Christopher et al. 2002:201).  Therefore, organisations should point their marketing activities less at the transactional marketing mode, and place its emphasis on the single sale, and ways in creating a long term relationship with their customers.

Tennyson made this attempt by talking “to their own customers, to people who had holidayed with competitors and to people who had fancied the idea of an activity holiday but had never taken one” and “looked at consumer trends”. This helps the company to better understand the changes within the holiday market, therefore targeting the right people.

Merryweather Sailing had a close relationship with their customers as “the service was highly personalised and care of the customer and service quality were of paramount importance”.  Szmigin and Bourne (1998) state that the value of the relationship, and by implication the desire to commit to it, will depend on the nature of the service, the nature of the consumer and the nature of the situation.

However, Relationship Marketing is very expensive, more suitable to some markets than others so not all customers will want a relationship with a supplier. Therefore, companies should focus more on those customers with whom they will have profitable relationships.  

Tennyson Ltd offers high quality product, and this means they need to create and maintain excellent relationship with their customers.

Although Merryweather Sailing offers an excellent relationship with their customer, Tennyson Ski is still struggling in the market.  One of the main problems with Tennyson Ski is that they did not have a clear strategy of customer retention, customer care and service quality as evidenced by the case study “The snow market is quite different.  Tennyson Ski did not have the same level of control over the holiday experience and were therefore unable to build up the same kind of relationship with their clients…Once clients had arrived they might not see a Tennyson Ski representative until the day of departure”.

This does not mean that the company do not have potential for CRM; in fact they do because the strengths from Merryweather Sailing can be transferred into Tennyson Ski, which will eventually make the relationship stronger with customers.   As mentioned in the case study that research is being done to find out more about their customers (hot and cold) and found that the income profile for both groups were the same.  “Some clients are experts and have advance knowledge of the entire holiday experience, while many of them are not sure which company they will holiday with in the future”.  This clearly shows that Tennyson’s products and customer markets offer a relatively high potential for relationship marketing strategy as they know that customers, “want to relax by actively engage in an activity, and they are discerning, hate inefficiency and are happy to pay for quality” so, all Tennyson need is a strategy to help them to achieve this and make the clients more satisfied.

Join now!

2.1 Relationship Building

As the rapid and radical changes in today’s marketing environment resulted in an emphasis on relationship marketing, it is crucial that organisations build and maintain a close relationship with their existing and new customers to increase profitability and maintain customer loyalty.   reported that more and more firms are capitalising on strong relationships between firms and customers to gain valuable information on how best to serve customers and ...

This is a preview of the whole essay